Drinking Beer: Bottle Or Glass?

There is a common perception that beer tastes better when served from a bottle than from a can. However, this may be a psychological preference rather than an actual difference in taste. Beer poured from a bottle into a glass is considered by some to be the optimal way to enjoy a beer, as it allows for the activation of carbonation, the creation of a foamy head, and the release of aromas that enhance the flavour.

Beer tastes better from a bottle than a can

There is a certain satisfaction that comes with popping the cap off a beer bottle and taking a swig at the end of a long day. However, pouring that cold beer into a glass offers a superior experience. While some may argue that beer tastes the same regardless of its container, research suggests that most people believe beer tastes better from a bottle than from a can. This preference may be influenced by psychological factors, such as the shape, weight, or design of the packaging, or the preconceived notions associated with each type.

The preference for bottled beer over canned beer may be more than just a psychological phenomenon. Some believe that the metal of a can may impart certain flavors that glass keeps more pure, affecting the chemical and physical interactions within the packaging and ultimately influencing the taste. However, others argue that once the beer is poured into a glass, these differences become negligible, and the original packaging format no longer affects the taste.

The aroma of beer plays a crucial role in enhancing its flavor. Drinking beer from a bottle or a can restricts the sense of smell, altering the overall taste experience. In contrast, pouring beer into a glass activates the carbonation, creating a foamy head. The popping of tiny bubbles releases bursts of aroma, which, when mixed with the tastes on the tongue, provide a fuller and richer flavor profile.

Additionally, the visual appeal of beer in a glass cannot be overlooked. The color of the beer can indicate its maltiness, while the thickness and texture of the head can suggest its creaminess and mouthfeel. Brewers put immense effort into crafting their beers, and pouring it into a glass allows for a more holistic appreciation of the beverage. So, while drinking beer from the bottle may be convenient, pouring it into a glass offers a more rewarding sensory experience.

Cans lock in flavour and keep out light

Beer is a delightful, multifaceted beverage, but it can develop some unpleasant off-flavours if not stored properly. One of the most common ways beer can be ruined is by exposure to light, a process known as "lightstrike" or "skunking". This occurs when certain wavelengths of light, including blue and UV light, react with the bittering compounds (iso-alpha acids) derived from hops in beer. Even a couple of minutes of light exposure can cause this reaction, resulting in a skunk-like aroma (or, to some, like freshly brewed coffee, grass, or marijuana).

The best way to prevent lightstrike is to opt for beer packaged in cans, kegs, or bottles that completely shield the beer from light. Cans and kegs eliminate the possibility of lightstrike altogether as no light can penetrate these containers. When it comes to bottles, brown glass offers superior protection against skunking compared to clear or green glass. Brown glass blocks most of the wavelengths of light that cause skunking, while green glass blocks very little, and clear glass offers no protection at all.

Some brewers who package their beers in clear or green glass bottles use specially modified hop extracts that do not react with light, ensuring their beer doesn't develop an off-flavour. For example, Miller uses a modified hop extract in its Miller Lite product, so it doesn't develop lightstrike even though it's in a clear glass bottle. However, other brewers who use clear or green glass bottles for marketing purposes have come to accept the skunky aroma as part of their beer's character.

In summary, to lock in flavour and keep out light, beer should be packaged in cans, kegs, or bottles that completely block light. Cans are particularly effective at preserving the freshness and flavour of beer, ensuring a consistent taste from the first sip to the last.

Aroma is important to how we perceive flavour

While there is no denying the satisfaction of cracking open a beer and swigging straight from the bottle, pouring beer into a glass has its own rewards. Aroma plays a significant role in how we perceive flavour, as we know from the blandness of food when we have a blocked nose. Drinking beer from the bottle or can cuts off your sense of smell and noticeably changes the taste.

When beer is poured into a glass, the carbonation is activated, creating a foamy head. The tiny bubbles release aroma compounds, which mix with the tastes on your tongue to create a full-flavoured experience. The glass also allows you to see the colour, which can indicate maltiness, and the thickness and texture of the head, which can indicate creaminess and mouthfeel.

The aroma of beer comes from the malt, hops, yeast, and any additional ingredients added during the brewing process. Malts vary widely in taste and aroma and typically define the character of the beer. Hops also vary in aroma, with centuries of breeding producing varieties that yield scents such as floral, citrus, or spice. The amount of hops used also affects the smell, with generously hopped brews like IPAs having a strong fragrance.

Yeast produces esters during fermentation, which give off a fruity flavour and scent that vary with the yeast strain. For example, the German Hefe Weissbier has hints of banana due to the esters released during fermentation.

To fully appreciate the aroma of a beer, it's important to use a glass that is shaped inward to capture the aromas while being wide enough to stick your nose into. A Teku glass is a good option, as it has a bowl shape that opens up the flavours and aromas, then tapers in to capture them.

Beer in a glass looks better

There are several reasons why beer in a glass may be preferable to drinking it straight from the bottle. Firstly, aroma plays a significant role in how we perceive flavour. Drinking beer from a bottle or can restricts your sense of smell, which can diminish the taste. In contrast, pouring beer into a glass activates the carbonation, creating a foamy head. When the bubbles pop, they release aroma, enhancing the flavour experience.

Secondly, the appearance of a beer can indicate its qualities. The colour, for example, can give an idea of its maltiness, while the thickness and texture of the head can suggest its creaminess and mouthfeel. Appreciating the beer's appearance is difficult when it's in the bottle.

Another reason to pour beer into a glass is to ensure it stays fresh. Cans are better at locking in flavour and keeping out light, which can cause beer to sour or spoil. Beer in a bottle may be more aesthetically pleasing, but it will not stay fresh for as long as beer in a can.

Finally, there is a psychological aspect to drinking beer from a glass. Research suggests that people tend to prefer beer from a bottle compared to a can, even when they cannot see the original packaging. However, when participants did not know the beer's origin, this preference disappeared, and the ratings for bottled and canned beer were very similar. Therefore, it seems that the preference for bottled beer is largely psychological.

Beer in a glass creates a foamy head

There is no denying the satisfaction of swigging straight from a beer bottle. However, pouring beer into a glass has its own rewards.

When beer is poured into a glass, the carbonation is activated, and a foamy head is created. This foam is produced from the bubbles of gas in the beer, predominantly carbon dioxide. As the gas bubbles rise to the top, they create a foamy layer full of protein, yeast, and hoppy residue. This process is called "nucleation".

The foam is influenced by the interaction of gas and protein, as well as the alcohol content of the beer. Beer with an alcohol content of around 5% tends to form and maintain a head of foam more effectively. The foam is created by the carbon dioxide produced during the fermentation process, which can occur before or after bottling. If the beer continues to ferment in the bottle, it will naturally carbonate and form a head when opened or poured.

The type of malt and adjunct used in fermentation also play a role in the density and longevity of the head. Wheat, for example, tends to produce larger and longer-lasting heads than barley. Additionally, the glassware used can impact the foam. Clean glassware is essential, as residue detergent or cleaning agents can reduce the amount of foam. The design of the glass can also affect nucleation, with some glasses featuring designs or etchings that encourage bubble formation and rising.

The foam on a beer has several functions. Firstly, it can influence the aroma of the beer, enhancing its scent and, in turn, influencing your perception of its flavour. Secondly, it can indicate the creaminess and mouthfeel of the beer. Finally, it adds to the aesthetic appeal of the beverage.

Frequently asked questions