Beer On Metro-North: What's The Rule?

Drinking on the Metro-North Railroad, which operates several routes from New York's Grand Central Station to upstate New York and Connecticut, is a topic of much discussion and some confusion. While the Metro-North's code of conduct discourages drinking on trains, and alcohol is banned during certain events and holidays, commuters report frequently drinking beer and other alcoholic beverages on board.

Beer is allowed on Metro North trains but not on platforms

Beer is allowed on Metro-North trains, but there are some important clarifications and exceptions to this rule. Firstly, while beer may be allowed on the trains, it is not permitted on the platforms, with the exception of platforms that sell alcohol. In Grand Central Terminal (GCT), for example, drinking is allowed downstairs but not in the main concourse. It is also important to note that alcohol consumption on Metro-North trains is subject to change during certain events or holidays. For instance, during SantaCon in 2021, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) banned alcohol on Metro-North trains and stations for a 32-hour period.

The rules surrounding alcohol consumption on Metro-North trains can be confusing, and there is a history of conflicting information and unclear guidelines. In the past, there were designated bar cars on certain routes, but these have since been removed. Additionally, the sale of alcohol at bar carts on platforms was discontinued in 2018, and commuters are now expected to purchase alcohol from stations to consume onboard.

Despite the rules, it is common for commuters to drink beer and other alcoholic beverages on Metro-North trains, and some commuters even bring coolers or share drinks with fellow passengers. However, it is important to note that the MTA discourages drinking on the trains, and there may be increased police presence during certain times to enforce alcohol restrictions.

In summary, while beer is generally allowed on Metro-North trains, it is not permitted on the platforms, and there may be exceptions or special restrictions during certain events or holidays. The rules are subject to change, and it is always a good idea to check for the most up-to-date information before consuming alcohol on Metro-North trains.

Beer can be purchased at Grand Central Terminal and Penn Station

If you're looking to purchase beer to take on your Metro-North journey, there are a few options available to you at Grand Central Terminal and Penn Station.

Grand Central Terminal is home to a wonderful food market on the street level, where you can find a range of beverages, including beer. Additionally, on the lower level, there is a food court offering soups, salads, and pizza, among other options. If you're looking for a quick beer before boarding your train, there is also a beer cart near the platform area. However, some commuters have noted that the beer quality at the cart may not be the best, and bringing your own drinks is always an option.

At Penn Station, alcohol is also available for purchase. While the platform bar carts at this station have been removed, you can still find alcoholic beverages at various vendors and dining establishments within the station.

It's important to note that while drinking on Metro-North trains is generally allowed, there are certain times when alcohol consumption is banned, such as during SantaCon and throughout the end-of-year holiday season. Additionally, drinking on the platforms is not permitted unless alcohol is sold at that specific platform. So, while you can enjoy your beer on the train, make sure to dispose of your empty cans or bottles before exiting at your destination, as drinking on the platforms is not allowed.

Drinking on the Harlem line is allowed

You can also bring your own drinks onto the train, but drinking on the platform is not allowed unless alcohol is sold at that platform. So, while you can't drink on the main concourse at Grand Central Station, you can on the lower level. Just remember to dispose of your empty cans and bottles in the bins provided on the platform when you get off the train.

It's worth noting that there are some exceptions to the usual rules. For example, there is a ban on alcohol during SantaCon weekend and throughout the end-of-year holiday season. So, if you're planning on drinking on the Harlem line during that time, make sure to check the latest regulations.

In addition, while drinking on the train is generally allowed, it's not encouraged by the Metro North or the LIRR. The official code of conduct for both discourages drinking on the trains. However, as long as you're polite and responsible, drinking on the Harlem line can be a great way to relax on your commute or start your night out.

Drinking is banned during SantaCon and the holiday season

While drinking on Metro-North trains is generally permitted, there are certain times when alcohol is banned, such as during SantaCon and the holiday season.

SantaCon is an annual event where people dress up as Santa Claus and go on a bar crawl. In 2021, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) banned alcohol on Metro-North trains and stations for 32 hours during SantaCon, which fell on December 11. The ban was implemented to maintain orderly travel during the busy holiday season and ensure that riders could get to their destinations smoothly and on time.

In addition to SantaCon, alcohol is also banned on Metro-North trains during the end-of-the-year holiday season. This ban implies that drinking is usually allowed on the trains but is restricted during this particular period. It's important to note that even when drinking is allowed, it is not encouraged by Metro-North or the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR), and it is not within their code of conduct.

The history of drinking on commuter trains in New York is closely linked to the presence of bar cars and bar carts on the trains and at the stations. Until 2014, the Metro-North New Haven Line had a designated bar car, and until 2018, the MTA commuter train lines allowed mid-commute alcohol purchases from bartenders at platform bar carts. However, due to various factors, including budget constraints, missing funds investigations, and concerns about serving alcohol to commuters who may drive home, these bar cars and bar carts have been removed or discontinued.

While drinking on Metro-North trains may be allowed outside of specific events and periods, such as SantaCon and the holiday season, it is always important to stay informed about the latest rules and regulations, as they can change over time.

Bar cars and bar carts have been removed from trains and platforms

In 2016, a probe into missing funds led to the removal of bar carts at Grand Central Terminal, and in 2018, the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) halted platform sales of alcohol. There were eight bar carts along the LIRR lines, including five at Penn Station, and they were the last of the bar carts on any part of the MTA system. The decision to go dry was made by MTA management, who felt that the MTA should not be selling alcohol to commuters, many of whom would then drive home.

While drinking on the train is still permitted, commuters now have to bring their own alcohol onboard if they wish to drink during their journey.

Frequently asked questions