Mixing Milk And Beer: A Safe Drinking Combination?

Mixing beer and milk is an age-old tradition, with ancient cultures combining the two drinks, and even modern cocktail culture experimenting with beer-inspired drinks. However, the combination of beer and milk is not always well-received, and it raises the question: can one consume milk and beer at the same time? While it may be an acquired taste for some, there are potential health risks associated with this pairing, including increased acid production in the stomach, which can lead to acidic gastritis and other gastrointestinal issues. Furthermore, the curdling effect of mixing beer and milk is well-known, and the high acidity of beer can cause milk to curdle, resulting in an unpleasant drinking experience.

Milk and beer cocktails

Mixing milk and beer is an unusual combination, but many people find it pleasant when done correctly. The most important thing to remember is that beer can and will make milk curdle. This can happen in a glass or in your stomach, as the milk will curdle in the presence of an acid, including the acids in beer and in your stomach.

Milk stouts, which contain lactose from milk but not actual milk, won't curdle in the presence of an acid and can be enjoyed like any other beer. The lactose adds a nice sweetness.

There are a few cocktails that combine milk and beer, although they are not very common. One such cocktail is the "beer nog", which is similar to eggnog but made with a milk stout. Another is "bilk", which is roughly 70% beer and 30% milk. A more decadent cocktail combines old red wine, creamy milk, and your favourite beer. To make this, pour 150ml of old red wine into a shaker filled with ice, add 50ml of whole milk, and shake vigorously for 10 seconds. Then, pour the mixture into a large glass and top it off with five 250ml bottles of your preferred beer. Stir gently, and garnish with a slice of orange or a sprig of fresh mint.

For those with a sweet tooth, there are also beer milkshakes. A common one is a Guinness milkshake, but you can make a beer milkshake with any beer and ice cream combination.

The pH levels in beer

The pH level of a solution indicates its concentration of hydrogen ions. The pH scale runs from 0 to 14. If a solution has a pH value below 7.0, it is acidic, and if it is greater than 7.0, it is alkaline or basic. Pure water, which is pH neutral, has a pH of 7. Beer is typically slightly acidic, with an average pH of 4.0-4.4. However, beer pH levels can go as low as 3.0.

The pH level of beer is important during the brewing process as it affects the acidity of the beer and influences the taste, appearance, and storage quality of the final product. A high pH can lead to harsh flavours and incomplete enzymatic conversion of the mash. Therefore, brewers aim for a pH level of around 4.4 for a refined beer. During the fermentation process, the pH continues to drop, and the type of yeast added will determine the final pH. Most lager beers finish with a pH of 4.2-4.6, while some ales can end as low as 3.8.

The pH level of beer also plays a role in curdling milk. Beer is acidic, typically with a pH of 4.1-4.6, and this acidity causes milk to curdle. The fats in milk protect the proteins, but in low-fat milk, the unprotected proteins clump together and curdle when mixed with an acidic solution like beer.

The makeup of milk

Water

Milk is composed of approximately 85% water, serving as the primary solvent for the other constituents. This high water content contributes to milk's fluidity and makes it an excellent source of hydration.

Lactose

Lactose, or milk sugar, is a type of carbohydrate found in milk. It is a disaccharide, meaning it is made up of two simple sugars: glucose and galactose. Lactose gives milk its characteristic sweet taste and also provides energy. However, some individuals have difficulty digesting lactose due to lactose intolerance, which is caused by the lack of an enzyme called lactase.

Fat

Milk contains varying amounts of fat, depending on the type of milk. The fat content can range from skimmed milk with very low fat to cream, which has a high-fat percentage. Fat in milk provides energy and contributes to its creamy texture and mouthfeel.

Proteins

Milk is an excellent source of high-quality protein, containing two main types: casein and whey protein. Casein makes up about 80% of the total protein content, while whey protein accounts for the remaining 20%. These proteins are essential for growth, tissue repair, and various biological functions in the body.

Minerals and Vitamins

Milk is rich in essential minerals like calcium, phosphorus, potassium, and magnesium. Calcium is particularly important for bone health and plays a crucial role in maintaining strong teeth and bones. Milk also contains vitamins, including Vitamin A, Vitamin D, Vitamin B12, and Riboflavin, which are vital for various physiological processes in the body.

Other Components

In addition to the major constituents mentioned above, milk also contains smaller amounts of other components such as enzymes, hormones, and growth factors. These components play a role in the development and health of young mammals and can also influence the nutritional value and characteristics of milk.

The composition of milk can vary depending on factors such as the animal source, breed, feed, and stage of lactation. Additionally, processing methods like homogenization and pasteurization can also impact the final makeup of the milk we consume.

The history of milk and beer

Milk and beer are two beverages with long and distinct histories. The consumption of milk dates back to ancient times, with dairy believed to have first been produced in what is now Turkey around 8,000 BCE. Initially, milk was turned into yogurt, cheese, and butter for food safety reasons in the absence of refrigeration. However, a genetic mutation emerged, leading to lactose tolerance in some adult humans, and milk drinking gradually became more common.

Over time, milk became a valuable source of nutrition and flavour for various populations, including the first American colonists who brought cows with them across the Atlantic. During the Industrial Revolution, the rise of urban culture and large-scale production posed challenges for milk safety due to distance and unsanitary conditions. This issue was eventually addressed by pasteurization, a method of destroying harmful bacteria with heat, which was first applied to wine and beer and later adapted for milk.

Beer, on the other hand, has a more recent history, with the first known use of the term "stout" for beer dating back to 1677. Porter, a type of beer that originated in London, England, in the early 1700s, gained popularity due to its strong flavour, longer shelf life, affordable price, and heat resistance. Within a few decades, porter breweries in London had grown significantly, and the beer was exported to Ireland, with Arthur Guinness brewing it at his St. James's Gate Brewery by 1776.

In the early 1900s, brewers in England began experimenting with an unfermentable sugar derived from milk called lactose, creating a thicker, fuller, and slightly sweeter beer known as milk stout or cream stout. This style of beer was marketed as a health tonic, with advertisements targeting nursing mothers and the sick. While milk stout's popularity has waxed and waned over the years, it has experienced a revival in recent times, with craft breweries bringing back this style.

Today, the combination of milk and beer in beverages, such as beer nog and milkshakes, has gained a following, although some people find it unappealing due to the potential for curdling.

The health implications of drinking milk and beer together

Mixing milk and beer has been done in various cultures for centuries. In ancient Egypt, beer was highly valued, and ancient Greeks believed that mixing alcohol and milk had medicinal benefits. In modern times, the combination is less common, but some cocktails, such as beer nog and beer milkshakes, include both milk and beer.

The impact on digestion

Drinking beer can cause digestive issues such as nausea, heartburn, cramping, and bloating. It does this by disrupting the communication between the stomach and the brain, which controls stomach acid production, and increasing acidity in the stomach. Beer is also known to contain sugar or other carbohydrates, which can cause problems for those with sensitive digestive systems.

Milk, on the other hand, is a good source of protein, calcium, vitamin D, and other nutrients. However, when consumed after beer, the body's ability to absorb these nutrients is reduced due to the impact of alcohol on digestion.

Curdling

The combination of milk and beer can also cause the milk to curdle, either in the glass or in the stomach. This is due to the acidity of the beer, which neutralises the negative charge on the casein proteins in the milk, causing them to clump together and form lumps. The higher the fat content in the milk, the less likely it is to curdle, as fat coats and protects the casein molecules.

Diarrhoea

While curdled milk may be unpleasant, it is unlikely to cause diarrhoea. Instead, this is more likely to be caused by the beer, as alcohol disrupts the digestive process and can make it harder for the body to absorb water in waste products. Milk can make diarrhoea worse, but unless the person is lactose intolerant, it usually isn't the cause.

Long-term health implications

While the immediate health risks of drinking milk and beer together may be relatively minor, there can be more serious long-term effects. Regular or heavy consumption of alcohol can lead to damaged heart tissue, altered blood pressure, a weakened immune system, and liver cirrhosis. Combining dairy products with alcoholic drinks can also increase the risk of chronic acid reflux (GERD).

Frequently asked questions