Non-Alcoholic Beer: Safe Post-Liver Transplant?

Alcoholic liver disease is one of the most common reasons for liver transplants. However, it is a complicated topic from both medical and ethical standpoints, as it is often considered a self-inflicted disease. The survival rate of transplanted patients has improved significantly over the years, but the probability of relapse is high, ranging from 7% to 95%. Even occasional drinks can lead to graft damage and decrease survival rates. Therefore, complete abstinence is recommended to overcome addiction issues and allow the liver to recover. While non-alcoholic beer is often considered a healthier alternative to regular beer, it is important to note that it still contains some alcohol. After a liver transplant, it is crucial to avoid any form of alcohol, as it can be toxic to the new liver and interfere with medication metabolization.

Alcoholic liver disease is a common reason for liver transplants

Early LT for acute alcoholic hepatitis has been the subject of recent clinical studies with promising results in carefully selected patients. A multidisciplinary evaluation of candidates for LT is crucial, and complete abstinence from alcohol is essential to address addiction issues and allow the liver to recover. Risk factors for relapse include anxiety or depressive disorders, a short duration of sobriety before LT, and a lack of social support.

Alcoholic liver disease comprises several stages of severity:

• Steatotic (fatty) liver: This is the most common alcohol-induced liver problem, characterised by the build-up of fat inside liver cells, leading to an enlarged liver.
• Acute hepatitis: Alcohol-associated hepatitis is an acute inflammation of the liver, resulting in cell death and permanent scarring.
• Cirrhosis: Alcohol-associated cirrhosis is the destruction of healthy liver tissue, leaving scar tissue in its place. This can lead to liver failure.

Treating alcoholic liver disease primarily involves stopping alcohol consumption. Participating in an alcohol use disorder treatment program and abstaining from alcohol can improve the chances of recovery and reduce the need for a liver transplant. However, in severe cases where the liver has stopped functioning and does not improve with abstinence, a liver transplant may be necessary.

All liver transplant units require patients with ALD to refrain from drinking alcohol while awaiting the transplant and for the rest of their lives. This is because alcohol is toxic to the liver and can interfere with the metabolization of certain medications. Even "non-alcoholic" beers may contain some alcohol. Therefore, it is crucial for individuals who have undergone a liver transplant to abstain from all forms of alcohol to ensure the success of their transplant and avoid organ failure.

Liver transplants are a costly procedure

While non-alcoholic beer does contain some alcohol, it is not advisable to consume it after a liver transplant. This is because alcohol is toxic to the liver and can interfere with the metabolization of certain medications.

The transplant center may require proof of financial ability to support a transplant before adding a patient to the waiting list. This can be a significant barrier to care, as most liver transplant candidates cannot cover the cost of the procedure without assistance.

Insurance can often cover a large portion of the cost, but patients will still need to pay for expenses such as transplant facility charges, lab tests not covered by insurance, and a portion of the physician's fees.

Medicare Parts A and B can cover transplants and other medically necessary health services for patients with end-stage liver disease. Medicare Advantage (Part C) can help with out-of-pocket costs such as emergency ambulance transportation, mental health counseling, and physical therapy.

Medicaid may also cover liver transplant costs, including laboratory and X-ray tests, personal care services, and home health services, but this varies by state.

To help cover the remaining costs, patients can turn to fundraising or financial aid programs such as the American Transplant Foundation, Liver Health Connection, and National Foundation for Transplants.

Relapse is common after liver transplants

Relapse is a common occurrence after liver transplants, with rates of alcohol consumption post-transplant ranging from 4% to 95% across studies. This wide range is due to different definitions of alcohol relapse, with some studies defining it as any alcohol consumption, while others focus on harmful or heavy drinking.

Risk factors for relapse

Several factors have been identified that increase the risk of relapse to alcohol consumption after a liver transplant. These include:

• Psychiatric comorbidities such as anxiety or depressive disorders
• A short duration of sobriety pre-transplant (less than 6 months is a common cut-off)
• Lack of social support or a strong social support system
• Younger age
• Smoking, especially during the 6 months before and after the transplant
• History of previous treatment for an alcohol use disorder
• Non-compliance with clinic visits
• Family history of alcohol use disorders

Strategies to prevent relapse

Given the high risk of relapse, it is important to implement strategies to prevent it. These include:

• Pre-transplant substance abuse treatment and continued therapy after the transplant
• Abstinence from alcohol for at least 6 months before the transplant
• Involvement in support groups or Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) meetings
• Smoking cessation
• Close follow-up with the transplant team and primary care physician
• Careful patient selection, including assessment by mental health specialists and a strong commitment to change

Non-alcoholic beers may contain some alcohol

Non-alcoholic beers are often marketed as a safe alternative to alcoholic drinks. However, it is important to be aware of the risks before consuming them. While non-alcoholic beers typically contain very little alcohol, they may still possess small amounts.

By law, non-alcoholic beers can contain up to 0.5% alcohol by volume (ABV). However, research suggests that many of these beverages contain more alcohol than their labels indicate. One study found that 29% of no- or low-alcohol beers tested had higher alcohol levels than stated on their labels. Six beers labelled as containing 0.0% ABV were found to have alcohol levels higher than 1%.

It is also important to note that people with liver impairments may develop much higher blood alcohol levels than normal after consuming non-alcoholic beer. This may cause some people to test positive on alcohol urine or breath tests.

Therefore, if you are pregnant, trying to become pregnant, or have a history of alcohol use problems, it is best to avoid consuming non-alcoholic beers.

Abstinence is the best way to allow spontaneous liver recovery

Alcoholic liver disease (ALD) is one of the most common reasons for liver transplantation. However, it is a complicated topic from both medical and ethical standpoints, as it is often considered a "self-inflicted disease".

Complete abstinence from alcohol is critical to overcoming addiction issues and facilitating spontaneous liver recovery. The selection criteria for liver transplantation require 6 months of complete abstinence to address addiction issues and allow the liver to recover.

The risk factors for relapse include the presence of anxiety or depressive disorders, a short duration of sobriety before transplantation, and a lack of social support. Therefore, it is essential to identify these risk factors, strengthen the social support system, and provide family counseling to prevent relapse.

While non-alcoholic beer contains less alcohol than regular beer, it is important to note that it still contains some alcohol. As alcohol is toxic to the liver and can interfere with the metabolization of certain medications, it is recommended to abstain from all alcoholic beverages, including non-alcoholic beer, after a liver transplant.

Frequently asked questions