Beer And The 9 Days: What's Allowed?

The first nine days of the month of Av, known as the Nine Days, is a period of time established by the rabbis to mourn the destruction of the two Batei ha-Mikdash. There are certain activities that are prohibited during this period, including eating meat and drinking wine. However, it is permissible to consume other alcoholic beverages such as beer, whisky, and wine vinegar. This is because the prohibition is specific to wine and grape juice, which are considered to have a higher chashivos.

Drinking beer is allowed during the 9 days

The prohibition against eating meat and drinking wine begins at sunset on Rosh Chodesh Av and ends at midday on the tenth of Av. This restriction applies to everyone, including men, women, and children. However, exceptions are made for those who are pregnant, nursing, elderly, or sick, as they may consume meat for health reasons.

It is important to note that the customs and rituals observed during the 9 days may vary among different Jewish communities and individuals. While the consumption of beer is generally allowed, it is always advisable to consult with a rabbi or a trusted religious source for specific guidelines and practices.

The 9 days are a period of reflection and remembrance, and it is essential to respect the customs and traditions associated with this time. While beer consumption may be permitted, it is crucial to be mindful of the solemn nature of the occasion and to follow any other restrictions or guidelines that may be in place.

In addition to the restrictions on food and drink, there may be other practices observed during the 9 days, such as refraining from listening to music or engaging in activities that are considered joyous or celebratory. It is always best to consult with a rabbi or a trusted source for specific guidelines and practices during this time.

Wine and grape juice are prohibited

The restriction on wine and grape juice begins at sunset on Rosh Chodesh Av and ends at midday on the tenth of Av. All wines and grape juices are prohibited during this time, but alcoholic beverages like beer, whisky, and wine vinegar are permitted. The restriction applies to men, women, and children, even those who do not understand the concept of mourning for the destruction of the Beis ha-Mikdash.

However, there are some exceptions to the restriction. For example, a child, a pregnant or nursing woman, or an elderly or sick person who cannot eat dairy foods or who needs to eat meat for health reasons may consume meat. On Friday afternoon before Shabbat, it is permitted to feed children their regular meaty Shabbat foods. Additionally, on Shabbat, there is no restriction on eating meat or drinking wine, even if one began Shabbat early. It is forbidden, however, to eat food left over from Shabbat, even for melaveh malkah.

The restriction on wine and grape juice is also lifted during a seudas mitzvah, which includes a siyum, a pidyon ha-ben, and a bar mitzvah dinner that takes place on the day the boy becomes a bar mitzvah. During the week in which Tisha B'Av occurs, only a minyan of people plus close relatives may partake of meat and wine at a seudas mitzvah meal.

Whisky and wine vinegar are allowed

The first nine days of the month of Av, known as the Nine Days, is a period of time established by the rabbis to mourn the destruction of the two Batei ha-Mikdash. There are certain activities that are prohibited during this period, and it is important to be knowledgeable about the exact nature of these prohibitions.

One of the restrictions during the Nine Days is the injunction against eating meat and drinking wine. This prohibition is not clearly mentioned in the Talmud as binding halachah, but it is an age-old custom that has become universally accepted. Thus, today it may not be compromised in any way, and one who does so is considered a "fence-breaker."

However, it is important to note that alcoholic beverages like whisky and beer are permitted during the Nine Days. Wine vinegar is also allowed, and one may even season a dish with it. Additionally, if wine was added to dough, the resulting baked goods may be eaten during the Nine Days, as the flavour of wine cannot be detected in them.

While whisky, beer, and wine vinegar are allowed, all wines and grape juices are prohibited during the Nine Days. The restriction against eating meat and drinking wine begins at sunset on Rosh Chodesh Av and ends at midday on the tenth of Av. It is important to consult with a rabbi for final rulings and further clarification on these matters.

Beer is allowed for Havdalah

The first nine days of the month of Av, known as the Nine Days, is a period of time established by the rabbis to mourn the destruction of the two Batei ha-Mikdash. There are certain activities that are prohibited during this period, including eating meat and drinking wine. However, alcoholic beverages like beer are permitted.

According to Halacha, wine (and grape juice) are prohibited during the Nine Days, but other beverages are allowed. Beer is therefore allowed and can be used for Havdalah. In fact, those who usually make Havdalah with beer or another chamar medinah should continue to do so during the Nine Days.

The restriction against eating meat and drinking wine begins at sunset on Rosh Chodesh Av and ends at midday on the tenth of Av. It is customary to extend this prohibition until midday of the tenth of Av, even when it falls on a Friday. This is because the destruction of the Beis ha-Mikdash, which began on the ninth of Av, continued throughout the night and most of the next day.

During the Nine Days, it is permitted to drink wine at a seudas mitzvah, such as a siyum, pidyon ha-ben, or bar mitzvah dinner. It is also permitted to drink the wine after Birkas ha-Mazon. However, the cup of wine from a bris or pidyon ha-ben should be given to a minor or the mother of the child.

Beer is allowed for children at a bris or pidyon ha-ben

The consumption of alcohol is a contentious issue during the 9 days, with some sources stating that wine and grape juice are forbidden, while others claim that alcoholic beverages like whisky and beer are permitted. However, the debate surrounding beer consumption during the 9 days is not the focus of this response. Instead, we will explore the topic of beer consumption by children at a bris or pidyon ha-ben.

It is important to note that the legal drinking age in many countries is 21, and serving alcohol to minors is strictly prohibited. The following discussion is based on the assumption that the children in question are of legal drinking age in their respective locations.

In Jewish law and custom, a bris and a pidyon ha-ben are considered se'udat mitzvah, or celebratory meals, that are typically held after the circumcision of a baby boy and the redemption of a firstborn son, respectively. These events are considered joyous occasions and are often attended by family and friends.

While there are varying customs and opinions regarding the consumption of alcohol during the 9 days, it is generally accepted that meat and wine may be consumed at a se'udat mitzvah, such as a bris or pidyon ha-ben. This is because the celebration of the mitzvah takes precedence over the mourning associated with the 9 days. Therefore, it can be assumed that beer, as an alcoholic beverage, would also be permitted for adults and children who are of legal drinking age.

However, it is important to note that the customs and traditions surrounding Jewish law and the 9 days may vary among different communities and individuals. As such, it is always advisable to consult with a rabbi or a trusted religious authority for specific guidance on this matter.

In conclusion, while beer may be allowed for children at a bris or pidyon ha-ben from a religious perspective, it is essential to abide by local laws and regulations regarding the legal drinking age.

Frequently asked questions