Carnivore Diet: Beer Friend Or Foe?

The carnivore diet is a restrictive regimen that focuses on the consumption of animal products and the elimination of carbohydrates. Alcohol is made by fermenting grains and fruits, so it is not considered a carnivore-friendly drink. The carnivore diet is already restrictive, and adding alcohol to the mix can be challenging. Alcohol can interfere with metabolism, increase food cravings, and negatively impact ketosis. It can also lead to intense hangovers and disrupt sleep quality. However, some people may choose to include low-carb alcoholic drinks such as pure spirits, dry wines, or light beers in moderation. Ultimately, the decision to drink alcohol while on the carnivore diet is a personal one, but it is important to be mindful of the potential impacts on health and diet efficacy.

Beer is high in calories and carbohydrates

Beer is not considered a Carnivore-friendly drink. It is produced using grains and is not an animal product, which is what the carnivore diet is based on.

Beer is also high in calories and carbohydrates. A standard beer contains around 150 calories and 13g of carbohydrates per 12oz. This can be detrimental to the low-carb, high-protein nature of the carnivore diet, which aims to induce a state of ketosis. The high-calorie content of beer can also hinder weight loss efforts, as it provides empty calories that contribute to overall caloric intake without offering nutritional benefits.

The high carbohydrate content of beer can also negatively impact ketosis, which is an essential metabolic state for those following the carnivore diet. When alcohol is present in the body, it becomes the primary source of energy instead of fats and proteins, potentially slowing down the fat-burning process. This can lead to increased fat storage and negatively impact weight loss or weight maintenance efforts.

Additionally, the presence of alcohol in the digestive system can impair the absorption of key nutrients such as vitamins and minerals. This can be detrimental to overall health and may counteract some of the purported benefits of the carnivore diet, such as improved nutrient absorption and reduced risk of chronic diseases.

Therefore, while occasional moderate consumption of beer may not significantly hinder the health benefits of the carnivore diet, regular or heavy drinking could throw you off track from your health and weight loss goals.

Alcohol is not an animal product

The carnivore diet is a high-protein, low-carbohydrate diet that centres on the consumption of animal products. It is a restrictive regimen that advocates eating animal-derived foods to optimise health and reduce inflammation. Alcohol is neither a protein nor a carbohydrate, and it is not derived from animals, so it does not align with the core principles of the carnivore diet.

The diet's low-carb nature leads to a decreased tolerance for alcohol. As the body adapts to using fats and proteins for energy, it becomes more sensitive to alcohol's effects. Alcohol can also impact metabolism, slow down the fat-burning process, and increase food cravings. It can be addictive, and it interferes with the body's ability to metabolise dietary fats. Alcohol prioritises metabolism over other nutrients, slowing down the absorption rate of these nutrients. This can negatively impact weight loss efforts, as alcohol is prioritised in metabolism over fats and carbohydrates, potentially leading to increased fat storage.

If you are following the carnivore diet and choose to consume alcohol, it is recommended to opt for low-carb options such as pure spirits or dry wines. These include gin, vodka, whiskey, and tequila, which contain zero carbohydrates. Dry wines like Pinot Grigio, Sauvignon Blanc, and Chardonnay have lower carbohydrate content than sweeter varieties.

While moderate alcohol consumption may not significantly hinder the health benefits or weight loss potential of the carnivore diet, excessive intake can lead to more intense hangovers due to changes in the gut microbiome. Abstaining from alcohol or drinking in moderation can help maintain the integrity of a low-carb, high-protein diet.

Alcohol can cause metabolic problems

Frequent heavy drinking and binge drinking have been linked to poor long-term metabolic health and an increased risk of developing type 2 diabetes. However, the effects of moderate drinking are less clear. While moderate drinking may be associated with lower rates of diabetes and obesity, other factors could be responsible for this effect, such as moderate drinkers tending to have better financial and social circumstances, which are associated with improved health.

Alcohol consumption can also cause weight gain, as alcoholic drinks are often high in calories. For example, beer, wine, and spirits contain approximately 150, 125, and 95 calories, respectively. Drinking alcohol with meals or before meals adds extra calories, contributing to weight gain.

Alcohol increases food cravings

Alcohol is not considered compatible with the carnivore diet, which consists of meat and other animal products. Alcohol is made by fermenting grains and fruits, and it is a toxin that negatively affects physical and mental health.

However, if you are an occasional drinker, having a drink once in a while will not negatively affect your health. If you are truly committed to the carnivore diet, you should know that alcohol increases food cravings.

Alcohol stimulates the reward/pleasure centres in the brain. Sugar has a similar effect, and studies show that the consumption of sugar can be a gateway to alcohol use. When you drink alcohol, you trigger these reward centres, and your brain can push you to eat high-carb foods that are not on the carnivore diet food list.

A study of 282 college students found that almost 50% reported overeating and making unhealthy eating choices after drinking. Similarly, a 2010 study of women found that "Alcohol also increased rated appetite once the food had been tasted, suggesting alcohol may increase food-related reward."

In other words, drinking can make us eat more while reducing our discernment about what we eat. Well-known keto thought leader Maria Emmerich sums it up: "The more you drink, the more you tend to eat; and unfortunately, drinking will make your liver work to convert the alcohol into acetate, which means that the foods you consume at this time will be converted into extra fat in your body."

According to a 2020 survey, 60% of individuals on the carnivore diet experienced increased cravings and hunger after consuming alcohol. If you are on the carnivore diet and want to drink alcohol, you should opt for low-carb, low-calorie beverages.

Alcohol can cause worse hangovers

Alcohol is known to cause severe hangovers, which can be even worse when following a carnivore diet. This is due to the absence of carbohydrates in the carnivore diet, which leads to a faster absorption rate of alcohol and consequently, more intense intoxication and hangover symptoms. The metabolic disruption caused by alcohol consumption results in elevated blood alcohol levels, triggering throbbing headaches, nausea, and reduced sleep quality. The lack of deep sleep phases further spills over into daytime, causing sluggishness and unwelcome food cravings, making it challenging to adhere to the strict carnivore diet.

The negative impact of alcohol on sleep quality cannot be overstated. Alcohol acts as a central nervous system depressant, initially providing a sedative effect but ultimately disrupting sleep patterns by reducing the quality of REM sleep. This disturbance in sleep cycles and overall restorative sleep can have a detrimental effect on brain health and cognitive function.

Additionally, the presence of alcohol in the digestive system can impair the body's ability to absorb key nutrients effectively. Alcohol interferes with the absorption of essential vitamins and minerals, which can be detrimental to overall health. Specifically, alcohol may hinder the absorption of B vitamins, vitamin C, and certain minerals.

The combination of intense intoxication, severe hangover symptoms, and impaired nutrient absorption can significantly affect an individual's ability to maintain the strict carnivore diet. The physical and mental challenges presented by alcohol consumption may make it difficult to resist the temptation of deviating from the diet or giving in to increased food cravings. Therefore, it is crucial for those following the carnivore diet to be mindful of the potential impact of alcohol on their health and dietary goals.

Frequently asked questions