Beer And Whiskey: Mixing Alcohol Safely

Drinking beer and whiskey together has been a tradition since the 15th century. The Boilermaker cocktail, for example, is a simple mix of beer and whiskey. However, the saying beer before liquor, never sicker; liquor before beer, never fear is a well-known drinking adage. The idea is that if you start with beer and then switch to liquor, you may end up drinking faster and consuming more alcohol, leading to increased sickness. On the other hand, starting with liquor and then switching to beer may result in a slower rate of consumption and a lower risk of a hangover. Ultimately, the amount of alcohol consumed is more important than the type or order of drinks.

Beer and whisky have been drunk together since the 15th century

Drinking beer and whisky together has been a tradition since the 15th century. The practice of drinking whisky and beer together likely originated in Ireland and Scotland, where the distillation of "aqua vitae" or spirit alcohol, primarily for medicinal purposes, was common. Whisky, then known as "aqua vitae", was highly regarded for its medicinal properties and was even consumed by a chieftain in Ireland in 1405, as recorded in the Annals of Clonmacnoise.

Over time, the combination of beer and whisky evolved into a ritual, with miners in Butte, Montana, in the 1890s enjoying a drink called a "Sean O'Farrell" at the end of their shifts. This drink, later named the "Boilermaker", consisted of a glass of beer mixed with a shot of whisky. The tradition of drinking beer and whisky together has endured for centuries and has even inspired various cocktail creations, such as the Irish Car Bomb and the Chicago Handshake.

Today, the pairing of beer and whisky is considered an art, with experts offering guidance on how to create harmonious flavour combinations. For instance, a German weissbier, with its light banana flavours, is recommended to complement the gentle, easy-drinking style of Irish whiskey. On the other hand, a stout or a hop-forward IPA could stand up to the smoky flavours of an Islay whisky.

While the order of consumption may not be as crucial as once believed, with some sources claiming that "ethanol is ethanol", others maintain that drinking liquor first and then switching to beer can lead to a more pleasant experience, as the faster consumption of the more potent liquor can be offset by the slower drinking of beer. Ultimately, the key to enjoying any alcoholic beverage, including beer and whisky, is moderation.

The Boilermaker cocktail is a simple mix of beer and whisky

The Boilermaker is a classic cocktail that has stood the test of time, with various origin stories and cultural variations. In the United States, it is commonly associated with the hard-working spirit of frontier men and working-class drinkers. In England, the term "boilermaker" traditionally refers to a mix of draught mild and bottled brown ale, while in Scotland, it is known as a "half and a half", consisting of a half pint of beer with a whisky.

The act of drinking a Boilermaker can be a ritualistic way to unwind after a long day or shift. It is a straightforward cocktail that allows drinkers to savour the nuances of their chosen spirit without the interference of mixers. The beer serves as a chaser, providing a refreshing contrast to the whisky.

Over the years, the Boilermaker has also found a following in bohemian and artistic circles, and it has experienced a resurgence in recent times, with trendy cocktail bars offering creative variations on the classic combo.

While the order in which different types of alcohol are consumed may not have a significant impact on the intensity of intoxication, as popular sayings like "beer before liquor, never sicker" suggest, the Boilermaker provides a structured approach to enjoying whisky and beer together.

Whisky and beer can be paired together to complement or contrast flavours

Whisky and beer have been drunk together since the 15th century. They are made from the same three base ingredients: grains, yeast, and water. During their creation, they go through similar processes, which is why there are similarities in their flavour profiles. Whisky and beer can be paired together to complement or contrast flavours.

For instance, both whisky and beer have a strong malty undertone, a slightly sweet and nutty flavour. This can be played upon in whisky cocktails and drinks. A British amber ale, for example, balances the sweet, toffee notes of malt barley against the bread-like flavour of hops. This would pair well with a whisky that has flavours of poached pears and chocolate-dipped raisins, such as The Glenlivet Captain’s Reserve Single Malt Scotch.

On the other hand, cutting through a flavour or aroma with something totally different can elevate a drink further and make something truly special. This is why lots of whisky cocktails blend both sweet and sour flavours. A German weissbier, for instance, has the same light banana flavours that you would associate with a good bourbon cask maturation. This would pair well with an easy-drinking Irish whiskey, such as West Cork 10-year-old single malt.

There are many different styles of beer that each go well with whisky, and the fun part is that there are endless whisky and beer combinations to try.

Drinking whisky then beer may lead to less sickness than the other way around

Drinking whisky and then beer may lead to less sickness than drinking beer and then whisky. This is because the order in which you drink them can affect your overall alcohol consumption.

Whisky has a higher alcohol content than beer. If you start with whisky, you're likely to drink more slowly and then switch to the less potent beer. This means you'll be drinking the less alcoholic beverage at a faster rate, which can help you avoid overconsumption and reduce the chances of getting sick.

On the other hand, if you start with beer and then move on to whisky, you're likely to increase your overall alcohol consumption. Beer typically takes longer to drink, especially when you're sober. As you relax and the alcohol starts to take effect, you tend to drink each subsequent beer faster than the previous one. If you switch to whisky at this point, not only have you increased your drinking speed, but you've also increased the amount of alcohol you're consuming per drink by 30-40%. This spike in blood alcohol levels can lead to blackouts and severe hangovers.

The saying "beer before liquor, never been sicker; liquor before beer, never fear" captures this idea. Starting with beer and then moving to liquor can be riskier and may increase the chances of negative consequences. However, it's important to remember that the amount of alcohol consumed and individual factors, such as body weight and metabolism, also play a significant role in how drinking whisky and beer affects you.

Additionally, whisky and beer have a long history of being paired together, dating back to the 15th century. The "Boilermaker" cocktail, for example, consists simply of a shot of whisky and a glass of beer. This combination is believed to have originated with blue-collar workers in the railroad or steel industries in the late 19th or early 20th century.

Beer before liquor, never sicker; liquor before beer, never fear

The saying goes: "Beer before liquor, never sicker; liquor before beer, never fear." But is there any truth to it?

Well, it's not technically true. "Ethanol is ethanol," says Brian St. Pierre of Precision Nutrition. In other words, the amount of alcohol you drink is what matters, not the type or the order. However, the saying has persisted for a reason.

The saying is based on the idea that, as you drink more, your rate of consumption increases. If you start with beer and then switch to liquor, not only have you increased your consumption, but you've also increased the amount of alcohol you're consuming by 30-40% per drink. This can lead to a spike in blood alcohol levels and a nasty hangover the next day.

On the other hand, if you start with liquor and then switch to beer, you're decreasing the amount of alcohol you're consuming per drink. This can help you avoid drinking too much, too quickly, and may lead to a more pleasant morning after.

Of course, individual tolerance and drinking habits also play a role. Some people may be able to handle drinking beer and liquor in any order without issue, while others may find that either combination leads to negative consequences. Ultimately, it's important to drink in moderation and to know your own limits.

Now, if you're looking to pair your whisky with a beer, there are a few things to consider. The Americans have long honoured the "Boilermaker," a shot of whisky with a beer chaser. This combination is said to deliver maximum satisfaction with minimum fuss. When it comes to specific pairings, you can look for beers and whiskies with similar profiles, such as citrus notes, or opt for duos that complement each other, like toffee and apple flavours.

For example, a nice, big, corn-led bourbon like Maker's Mark pairs well with an American red ale or a Sierra Nevada Pale Ale, which has a strong, astringent flavour that cleanses the palate. If you're looking for something lighter and more mixable, try a Canadian whisky like Crown Royal Harvest Rye with a ginger-forward beer like Williams Bros. Midnight Sun.

So, while the order in which you drink your beer and liquor may not be the most important factor in determining your level of sickness, it can still be helpful to keep the old adage in mind to avoid overdoing it.

Frequently asked questions