Jewish Beer Culture: Exploring Ancient Drinking Traditions

While the stereotype of Jewish sobriety persists, Jews have a long and influential history in the alcohol industry, spanning Europe, Israel, and North America. In ancient times, wine was the preferred drink of the Israelites, but after their exile to Babylonia in the 6th century BCE, they began to embrace beer. In the Middle Ages, Jews were barred by law from brewing beer in Germany, but they became central to the industry in other ways, such as by growing hops, a crucial ingredient in beer. In Eastern Europe during the 19th century, approximately 30-40% of Polish Jews (including women and children) worked in the alcohol industry, and by the middle of the century, about 85% of Polish taverns had Jewish management. Today, Jews continue to play a significant role in the beer industry, with many key figures in the craft beer movement.

The Jewish preference for wine over beer

The Jewish people have historically had a complex relationship with alcohol, with varying levels of consumption and involvement in the alcohol industry across different regions and time periods. While there is a common stereotype of Jews as teetotalers or light drinkers, this notion is not entirely accurate.

One notable aspect of Jewish alcohol culture is the preference for wine over beer. This preference has deep roots in Jewish history and religious traditions. Ancient Israel, for example, favoured wine over beer, with an abundance of vineyards producing sweet, fat grapes. In contrast, beer brewing was more common in neighbouring regions such as Mesopotamia and Egypt, where barley and wheat were readily available.

The Talmud, a central text in Jewish religion and culture, provides further evidence of this preference. It records four different types of beer brewed from barley, dates, figs, and beer (Pesachim 107a). Additionally, the Talmud mentions the medicinal properties of hops, a key ingredient in beer, noting its preservative and antiseptic qualities (Avodah Zarah 31b).

Another indication of the Jewish preference for wine is its prominent role in Jewish rituals. Wine is used in Sabbath dinners and other religious ceremonies, such as the Havdalah ceremony, marking the transition from Shabbat to the rest of the week. While beer is sometimes consumed during celebrations like Purim, wine remains the beverage of choice for many Jews.

The history of Jewish exile and migration has also influenced their drinking preferences. After the destruction of the ancient Temple in Jerusalem in 586 BCE, Jews were exiled to Babylonia and adopted the local taste for beer. Notable Babylonian Jewish brewers, such as Rav Chisda and his pupil Rav Papa, became established during this period.

In more recent times, the association of beer with German culture and the rise of Nazism may have contributed to a psychological turnoff for some Jewish consumers in both Europe and the United States. German dominance over American beer in the 19th century, led by German immigrants settling in cities like New York and Milwaukee, further shaped drinking preferences.

However, it is important to note that Jewish drinking culture is diverse and evolving. While wine may be traditionally favoured, many Jews today enjoy a wide range of alcoholic beverages, including beer. Additionally, Jews have played a significant role in the alcohol industry worldwide, including the production and distribution of beer.

The role of Jewish innkeepers in Poland's alcohol trade

A census of Polish Jews in 1764 found that approximately 80% of Jews living in villages worked in the alcohol trade, distilling and selling wine, vodka, liqueurs, and beer. This was a much higher proportion than in other Jewish communities in Europe. Poland's vodka and beer industries grew in the 1500s as landowners devoted more land to growing the grains needed for these drinks and set up taverns to sell them in. Many of the innkeepers who ran these taverns were Jews, who were seen as more sober and responsible than the general population.

The image of the kindly Jewish innkeeper became ingrained in Polish life and culture. For example, Poland's national poet, Adam Mickiewicz, created the character of Jankiel the tavern-keeper, a wise and patriotic Jew, in his work "Pan Tadeusz".

However, in the 1800s, Jews found themselves gradually edged out of the beer and liquor trade in Poland by a series of anti-Semitic laws. Even then, many Christian tavern owners would continue to clandestinely employ Jewish managers, who had so shaped Poland's beer and tavern culture through the ages.

Jewish involvement in the alcohol trade in Poland was so prevalent that according to Glenn Dynner, author of "Yankel's Tavern: Jews, Liquor, & Life in the Kingdom of Poland", 30-40% of Poland's Jews (including women and children) worked in the industry. This amounted to about 25% of all Jews in the world at the time, as approximately three-quarters of world Jewry lived in Eastern Europe.

Jewish innkeepers and tavern owners played a critical economic role in Poland, despite the many bans, taxes, and residential restrictions burdening them. They served as fronts for taverns so that Jewish managers could stay in business, reflecting an impressive level of local Polish-Jewish co-existence that contrasts with the more familiar story of anti-Semitism and violence.

Jewish contributions to modern beer production

Jewish people have played a significant role in the beer industry for centuries, despite facing various restrictions and challenges. Here are some key contributions by Jewish communities to modern beer production:

Ancient Times to the Middle Ages

While ancient Israelites favoured wine, beer gained popularity among Jews after the destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem in 586 BCE, during their exile to Babylonia. The Talmud mentions four types of beer brewed from barley, dates, figs, and beer (Pesachim 107a). It also highlights the use of hops, noting its medicinal properties as a preservative and antiseptic (Avodah Zarah 31b). Beer was so well-liked by the ancient Jews that it was considered an acceptable substitute for wine in the Havdalah ceremony, marking the transition from Shabbat to the rest of the week.

During the Middle Ages in Germany, Jews were legally barred from brewing beer, the national drink at the time. However, they found an alternative way to contribute to the industry by growing and trading hops, a crucial ingredient in beer. By the time the Nazis rose to power in the 1930s, Jewish businesses controlled about 70% of Germany's hops industry.

Modern Era

In the 19th century, Jews were finally allowed to brew and sell beer in Germany, and they quickly revolutionized the industry. Jewish brewers introduced modern manufacturing methods and established best practices for pasteurization, enhancing packaging quality and facilitating international trade. One notable pioneer was Jakob von Hirsch, a Jewish baron who opened the Planegg Castle Brewery in 1836, becoming Germany's first industrial-scale beer brewer.

Jewish entrepreneurs also played a significant role in the iconic German beer steins. They started decorating the traditional plain steins, making them ornate and decorative, which caught on and became a quintessential German art form.

Global Impact

Jewish people also had a profound impact on the beer industry beyond Europe. In Colonial America, Jews were recorded as consuming beer regularly, as evidenced by the household expenses of Judah Hay, a middle-class Jew in New York City.

Additionally, German Jewish immigrants to the United States in the 19th century brought their beer expertise and influenced the development of top German-style brews. One notable example is Rheingold Beer, founded by Samuel Liebermann in Brooklyn in 1850.

In the 20th century, the current explosion of craft beer brewing in the United States has included a high number of Jewish producers, such as the Schmaltz Brewery of New York, creating boutique beers with Jewish roots.

In Israel, the first beer company in modern times was established in 1934, and today, the country boasts a cutting-edge beer scene with microbreweries and annual beer festivals. Israeli brewers have also innovated with gluten-free beer and the world's first date ale, capturing unique flavours of the Jewish state.

The impact of the Holocaust on Jewish involvement in the alcohol industry

For centuries, Jews have been vital in the production and marketing of beer. By the 1930s, Jews controlled about 70% of Germany's hops industry. However, the rise of the Nazis to power in the 1930s led to the persecution and expulsion of Jews from German cities, disrupting their involvement in the alcohol industry.

The Holocaust and the broader context of World War II had a significant impact on Jewish involvement in the alcohol industry. With the rise of Nazi Germany, many Jewish-owned breweries and alcohol businesses were confiscated or destroyed. Jewish families were forced to flee or go into hiding, disrupting their involvement in the industry. The Holocaust also led to a significant decline in the number of Jews involved in alcohol production and sales in Europe.

During World War II, Jewish immigrants to the United States, who had been disproportionately represented in alcohol production, particularly whiskey, faced challenges due to the temperance movement and anti-immigrant sentiment. The association of Jews with the liquor trade fuelled anxieties about immigration and cultural compatibility, leading to further marginalization.

In the aftermath of World War II and the Holocaust, the alcohol industry in Europe, including Jewish-owned businesses, had to rebuild and recover. Some Jewish families were able to reclaim their businesses, while others started anew in different countries. The trauma and displacement caused by the Holocaust contributed to a shift in Jewish involvement, with some choosing to distance themselves from an industry associated with pre-war life and others embracing it as a means of rebuilding and preserving cultural traditions.

Overall, the Holocaust had a profound impact on Jewish involvement in the alcohol industry, disrupting established businesses, displacing families, and shaping the trajectory of the industry for decades to come.

Jewish alcohol consumption in Colonial America

Alcohol was a significant part of daily life in Colonial America, with Americans drinking three times as much as they do now. Beer, cider, rum, and wine were all popular drinks, with the average American consuming eight ounces of alcohol a day. Drinking was believed to be a healthy alternative to water, which was often contaminated. Alcohol was also thought to be a cure for various illnesses and was used to dull the pain of manual labour.

Jewish people in Colonial America also drank alcohol, including beer. In his book, *The Jews in Colonial America*, Oscar Reiss gives the example of Judah Hay, a middle-class Jew in New York City, whose household spent 1.3 British pounds on three barrels of beer per month.

However, the stereotype of Jewish sobriety persists, perhaps due to the prevalence of wine in Jewish rituals, which may have lessened Jews' desire to drink recreationally. In the late 1950s, a study by the Yale Center of Alcohol Studies stated that alcoholism among Jews was virtually non-existent.

In the 19th century, German Jewish immigrants to America brought their taste for beer and knowledge of German-style brews with them. For example, in 1850, Samuel Liebermann founded Rheingold Beer in Brooklyn, which became a renowned and long-surviving brand.

Frequently asked questions