Should Beer Be Served With Ice?

Whether or not to drink beer with ice is a divisive topic. While some people are horrified by the idea, it is common in Southeast Asia and other hot climates where refrigeration is not always available. The ice cools the beer, but it also dilutes it, which can mute the flavour of the beverage. This is less of a problem with light lagers, which are often consumed in hot and humid climates, but it can ruin the taste of a full-flavoured beer. However, some people enjoy the milder taste of ice-cold beer, and it can be a refreshing option on a hot day. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference.

Beer with ice is common in Southeast Asia

The main reason why serving beer over ice is not common practice in the United States is that the ice melts and dilutes the beer, muting its flavour. This dilution of flavour is less noticeable in light lagers, which are similar in taste to water, and are commonly consumed in the hot, humid climates of Southeast Asian countries. In contrast, drinking a full-flavoured beer, such as an IPA or stout, with ice is generally not recommended as it would significantly alter the taste.

Despite the potential for dilution, drinking beer with ice can be incredibly refreshing, especially on a hot day. This combination is also a good way to make cheap, less flavourful beers more palatable. Beers like Budweiser, Miller Lite, Coors, Asahi, Sapporo, Singha, Corona, Modelo, and Pacifico are often served over ice in Southeast Asia and other parts of the world.

Additionally, beer cocktails, such as Micheladas or lageritas, can be a great way to enjoy beer with ice without worrying about dilution. Micheladas, for example, are made with Mexican beer, ice, lime juice, and sometimes hot sauce and salt.

It's seen as a necessity in hot climates with a lack of refrigeration

In hot climates with a lack of refrigeration, drinking beer with ice is not just a preference but a necessity. This is especially true in Southeast Asia, where there is often not enough room in coolers to keep the beer cold. As a result, the only way to enjoy an ice-cold beer is to pour it over ice cubes. This practice has led to many people from this region developing a taste for beer over ice.

The main reason why serving beer over ice is not a common practice in other parts of the world is that the ice melts and dilutes the beer, muting its flavour. This dilution can be a dealbreaker for those drinking full-flavoured beers like IPAs or stouts. However, in hot and humid climates, people tend to consume lighter lagers, whose taste profiles are similar to water, making them more suitable for drinking over ice.

Despite the potential for dilution, drinking beer over ice can be incredibly refreshing on a hot day. Taste receptors in our taste buds are temperature-sensitive, so when a drink is ice-cold, it tastes milder than at room temperature. Therefore, an ice-cold bitter drink will taste more mild, which can be appealing in hot weather.

For those wanting to try beer over ice, it is recommended to choose lighter beers with less concentrated flavours and lower alcohol content. Beers like commercial American brews (Budweiser, Miller Lite, Coors, etc.), lighter Asian beers (Asahi, Sapporo, Singha), and Mexican beers (Corona, Modelo, Pacifico) are good options. These beers are also cheaper, so if you don't enjoy the taste, you can afford to discard them.

Another way to enjoy beer with ice is by making beer cocktails, such as Micheladas or lageritas. Micheladas, a popular Mexican beer cocktail, are similar to Bloody Marys or Caesars but use beer instead of liquor. Lageritas are margaritas made with beer, sometimes with added tequila, creating a lighter cocktail without reducing the flavour. These complex flavours can mask the dilution from the ice, and the ice ensures the cocktail stays refreshingly cold.

It dilutes the flavour of the beer

The main reason why people choose not to add ice to beer is that it dilutes the flavour of the beverage. Beer is already mostly water, so adding ice waters it down, muting its flavour and resulting in a subpar drinking experience. This is especially true for beers with more full-bodied flavours, such as IPAs or stouts. However, some people argue that this dilution of flavour is not a significant issue when drinking lighter beers, such as lagers or commercial American brews like Budweiser, Miller Lite, or Coors.

The addition of ice can also affect the carbonation of the beer. As the ice melts, the beer becomes more diluted, and the carbonation is lost, causing the beer to go flat. This can further alter the taste and mouthfeel of the beer, making it less enjoyable for those who appreciate the complex flavours and textures of craft beers.

Some people also believe that drinking beer ice-cold is not ideal, as it can numb the taste buds and hide the true flavours of the beverage. Beer experts recommend serving beer chilled but not ice-cold to fully appreciate its flavour and aroma. However, in hot climates, an ice-cold beer can be incredibly refreshing, and some people are willing to sacrifice flavour for a cold drinking experience.

Furthermore, the practice of drinking beer with ice is considered acceptable in certain parts of the world, especially in Southeast Asia, where refrigeration may not be widely available. In these regions, beer is often served over ice to ensure it stays cold, and many people have acquired a taste for it. While it may be frowned upon in other parts of the world, such as the United States or the United Kingdom, it ultimately comes down to personal preference.

Finally, it is worth noting that while ice can dilute the flavour of beer, it can also be argued that it enhances the drinking experience in other ways. For example, on a hot day, an ice-cold beer can be more refreshing and thirst-quenching, even if the flavour is slightly milder. Additionally, some people simply prefer their drinks extra cold, regardless of the impact on flavour. Ultimately, whether or not to add ice to beer is a matter of personal taste and the specific situation.

It's considered acceptable to put ice in cider

While putting ice in beer is generally frowned upon, it is considered acceptable to put ice in cider. This is because cider is seen as more of a "quench your thirst" or "nice on a hot day" kind of drink. In hot climates, it is necessary to serve cider over ice as a way to keep it cold. In addition, there is a serious shortage of genuinely good ciders to appreciate at higher temperatures.

In the UK, it is common to be served a glass with extra volume to add ice while still having a full pint of cider. This is especially true during hot summer days. In contrast, in the US, cider is usually kept in the fridge, so there is less need to add ice.

However, some people still find it weird to put ice in cider. One person commented that they gave the bartender a "what the fk" look when he tried to put ice in their cider. Another person said that they had never seen ice with cider before and that it sounded weird. Ultimately, it is up to individual preference whether to put ice in cider or not.

Beer cocktails are a way to drink beer with ice

Beer cocktails are a great way to drink beer with ice. While some people may turn their noses up at the idea of drinking beer with ice, it's a common practice in certain parts of the world, especially in Southeast Asia, where it can get extremely hot and refrigeration may not be available.

One popular beer cocktail is the Michelada, a Mexican drink that's similar to a Bloody Mary or Caesar but with beer instead of liquor. To make a Michelada, simply take a glass of ice, add the juice of one lime, and a few dashes of hot sauce, and then pour in a Mexican beer of your choice. Some people also like to add tomato juice and salt to their Micheladas. Another beer cocktail option is the lagerita, which is essentially a margarita made with beer. You can also add tequila to a lagerita if you like. Using beer in a lagerita adds carbonation without diluting the flavour, as would be the case if you used club soda.

If you're not a fan of cocktails, you can still enjoy beer with ice. The key is to choose a lighter beer with less concentrated flavour and a lower alcohol content. Beers like Budweiser, Miller Lite, Coors, Asahi, Sapporo, Corona, Modelo, or Pacifico all work well over ice. The ice will make the flavours milder and more palatable, and it's a great way to make cheap beer more refreshing.

However, it's important to note that adding ice to beer is not always recommended. If you're drinking a craft beer with specific flavours and mouthfeel, ice can dilute the flavour and alter the carbonation. So, if you're looking to savour the complex notes of your beer, it's best to skip the ice.

Frequently asked questions