The Art Of Beer Fermentation: Do Brewers Reoxygenate Before Yeast Pitching?

Home brewers often debate whether to rehydrate dried beer yeast before pitching it into the wort. While rehydrating adds an extra step, it can optimize the fermentation process and potentially result in a healthier, more vigorous fermentation. However, some brewers prefer dry pitching, as it is perfectly fine and works well. Ultimately, the decision comes down to personal preference and experience.

Rehydrating dried beer yeast before pitching

Dry yeast is a smart and simple place to begin when first making beer. It has its merits and limitations. Dry yeast offers a reliable fermentation media and while already resilient, rehydration helps to kickstart it. It adds more volume to the pitch and the yeast readily disperses into the raw wort, quickly moving into the respiration stage. Fermentation begins all the more quickly.

Rehydrating dry yeast before pitching is a decision that comes down to experience and personal preference. Some people always rehydrate their dry yeast before pitching, while others don't. There are several quantifiable benefits to using dry yeast, and some brewers are perfectly happy with the results they're getting with dry pitching.

Dry beer yeast needs to be reconstituted in a gentle way. During rehydration, the cell membrane goes through changes which can be lethal to yeast. In order to reconstitute the yeast as gently as possible (and minimize/avoid any damage), yeast producers developed specific rehydration procedures.

Popular homebrewing blog site, Brulosophy, have run a couple of exbeeriments (experiments) directly comparing the results of two otherwise identical beers made using dry pitched and rehydrated yeast. The first experiment from back in 2014 had 5/13 people correctly identify the odd beer out in a blind triangle test of the two beers which were a Munich Dunkel made with Nottingham yeast. Of the 5 who did accurately identify, the majority went on to report essentially no difference between them. Their second experiment, run 4 years later in 2018, yielded a similar result when brewing the same recipe using the same yeast.

Danstar Yeast recommends reconstituting the yeast as gently as possible (and minimizing/avoiding any damage). Yeast producers developed specific rehydration procedures to reconstitute the yeast as gently as possible.

Benefits of rehydrating dried beer yeast

Dry yeast is a smart and simple place to begin when first making beer. It has its merits and limitations. Dry yeast offers a reliable fermentation media and while already resilient, rehydration helps to kickstart it. It adds more volume to the pitch and the yeast readily disperses into the raw wort, quickly moving into the respiration stage. Fermentation begins all the more quickly. So yes, do hydrate your yeast.

Dry beer yeast needs to be reconstituted in a gentle way. During rehydration, the cell membrane goes through changes which can be lethal to yeast. In order to reconstitute the yeast as gently as possible (and minimize/avoid any damage), yeast producers developed specific rehydration procedures.

For most brewers, this decision will come down to experience and personal preference. If you've always rehydrated your yeast and get excellent results doing it this way, why change it? If you're undecided or on the fence, then see for yourself.

Popular homebrewing blog site, Brulosophy, have run a couple of exbeeriments (experiments) directly comparing the results of two otherwise identical beers made using dry pitched and rehydrated yeast. The first experiment from back in 2014 had 5/13 people correctly identify the odd beer out in a blind triangle test of the two beers which were a Munich Dunkel made with Nottingham yeast. Of the 5 who did accurately identify, the majority went on to report essentially no difference between them. Their second experiment, run 4 years later in 2018, yielded a similar result when brewing the same recipe using the same yeast.

There are definitely some use cases for yeast starters, such as when re-using yeast you've top cropped or captured from a previous fermentation, or from a commercially available beer, but that's a whole other conversation. When it comes to dry yeast, we'll keep on pitching dry, for now.

Comparison of dry pitched vs rehydrated yeast

The question of whether to rehydrate your dried beer yeast before pitching it into your wort has sparked numerous debates among home brewers. While rehydrating dried beer yeast before pitching can offer benefits, especially for those looking to optimise their fermentation process, it does add an extra step.

Popular homebrewing blog site, Brulosophy, has run a couple of experiments directly comparing the results of two otherwise identical beers made using dry pitched and rehydrated yeast. The first experiment from back in 2014 had 5/13 people correctly identify the odd beer out in a blind triangle test of the two beers which were a Munich Dunkel made with Nottingham yeast. Of the 5 who did accurately identify them, the majority went on to report essentially no difference between them. Their second experiment, run 4 years later in 2018, yielded a similar result when brewing the same recipe using the same yeast.

The first experiment from back in 2014 had 5/13 people correctly identify the odd beer out in a blind triangle test of the two beers which were a Munich Dunkel made with Nottingham yeast. Of the 5 who did accurately identify them, the majority went on to report essentially no difference between them. Their second experiment, run 4 years later in 2018, yielded a similar result when brewing the same recipe using the same yeast.

While rehydrating dried yeast can be beneficial, most brewers will keep on pitching dry yeast, for now. Understanding the reasons behind each method will help you make the best decision for your brewing needs.

Use cases for yeast starters

There are definitely some use cases for yeast starters, such as when re-using yeast you've top cropped or captured from a previous fermentation, or from a commercially available beer.

Rehydrating dried beer yeast before pitching is a practice that can offer benefits, especially for those looking to optimise their fermentation process. While it does add an extra step, the potential for a healthier, more vigorous fermentation can make it worthwhile. Whether you choose to rehydrate or pitch directly, understanding the reasons behind each method will help you make the best decision for your brewing needs.

Popular homebrewing blog site, Brulosophy, have run a couple of experiments directly comparing the results of two otherwise identical beers made using dry pitched and rehydrated yeast. The first experiment from back in 2014 had 5/13 people correctly identify the odd beer out in a blind triangle test of the two beers which were a Munich Dunkel made with Nottingham yeast. Of the 5 who did accurately identify, the majority went on to report essentially no difference between them. Their second experiment, run 4 years later in 2018, yielded a similar result when brewing the same recipe using the same yeast.

For most brewers, this decision will come down to experience and personal preference. Potentially, but for the time being, we just don't see a compelling need to, as we're perfectly happy with the results we're getting with dry pitching.

Rehydrating vs dry yeast pitching

Dry yeast is a smart and simple place to begin when first making beer. It has its merits and limitations. Dry yeast offers a reliable fermentation media and while already resilient, rehydration helps to kickstart it. It adds more volume to the pitch and the yeast readily disperses into the raw wort, quickly moving into the respiration stage. Fermentation begins all the more quickly. So yes, do hydrate your yeast.

Dry beer yeast needs to be reconstituted in a gentle way. During rehydration, the cell membrane goes through changes which can be lethal to yeast. In order to reconstitute the yeast as gently as possible (and minimize/avoid any damage), yeast producers developed specific rehydration procedures.

There are quantifiable benefits to using dry yeast. Dry yeast is a smart and simple place to begin when first making beer. It has its merits and limitations. Dry yeast offers a reliable fermentation media and while already resilient, rehydration helps to kickstart it. It adds more volume to the pitch and the yeast readily disperses into the raw wort, quickly moving into the respiration stage. Fermentation begins all the more quickly.

As stated at the beginning of this post, for most brewers this decision will come down to experience and personal preference. If you've always rehydrated your yeast and get excellent results doing it this way, why change it? If you're undecided or on the fence, then see for yourself.

There are quantifiable benefits to using dry yeast. Dry yeast is a smart and simple place to begin when first making beer. It has its merits and limitations. Dry yeast offers a reliable fermentation media and while already resilient, rehydration helps to kickstart it. It adds more volume to the pitch and the yeast readily disperses into the raw wort, quickly moving into the respiration stage. Fermentation begins all the more quickly.

Frequently asked questions