Beer-Soaked Middle Ages: Why Only Ales Were Quaffed

It is a common misconception that people in the Middle Ages drank beer instead of water due to poor sanitation and disease control. In reality, water was the most common drink, as it was free and readily available from sources like wells and fresh streams. Medieval societies understood the importance of drinking water and often emphasised the benefits of drinking it from good sources. Beer was also consumed but was considered more of a nutritious snack than a method of hydration, providing peasants and farmers with a calorie-laden beverage that doubled as a source of energy.

Water was free and accessible

Water was free and easily accessible in the Middle Ages. Most communities were smart enough to understand that they shouldn't pollute their water sources with human or livestock waste. Even in more densely populated areas, there was infrastructure in place to ensure that clean water was separated. For example, London had developed a complex pipe system by 1237.

In larger towns, there were even infrastructures to supply water to citizens. In 1236, construction of a system of pipes began in London. It was designed to move water from a fresh spring to a pumping house that would, in turn, make fresh water available at cisterns throughout the city.

In villages or on manor estates, water supply was available from nearby springs, rivers, lakes, wells, and cisterns. Like most civilizations in history, villages were positioned in proximity to water sources. Castles were treated the same but received additional water from masonry-lined wells sunk into their interior courtyards. Some castles even drew water from the well at every level of the keep using a system of buckets and ropes that ran inside the walls.

Water was also the centerpiece of villages. Medieval people weren't stupid; they didn't drink water that looked or smelled bad, and tradesmen that used water—such as tanning—faced hefty fines if they polluted the town's drinking supply.

Beer was a luxury

It is a common misconception that beer was more popular than water in the Middle Ages. In reality, water was widely available and consumed by people from all walks of life, from peasants to royalty. While it is true that water sources could become contaminated, leading to the spread of waterborne diseases, medieval communities understood the importance of drinking water from good sources. They also had some basic water infrastructure in place, such as pipes and wells, which helped to ensure access to clean water.

However, beer was still an important part of medieval life. It was seen as a nutritious alternative to water, providing calories and energy to those performing hard labor. Beer was also used to pay taxes and tithes, and it could be home-brewed or purchased. Beer was subject to taxes and transportation fees, making it more costly than water. Therefore, while beer was consumed in the Middle Ages, it was a luxury for many, especially those who could not brew their own.

The beer of the Middle Ages was also quite different from the beer we know today. It was weaker, with an ABV of around three percent, and was brewed with a combination of botanicals called "gruit" instead of hops. Gruit provided flavor and prevented bacterial growth, and its use was regulated by the nobility. However, by the 12th century, brewing with gruit fell out of fashion, and beers made with hops became more common due to their lower cost and longer shelf life.

So, while beer was certainly consumed in the Middle Ages, it was not the primary drink of the masses, but rather a luxury item that provided both nourishment and pleasure.

Beer was a source of nutrition

It is a common misconception that people in the Middle Ages drank beer instead of water. In fact, water was plentiful and common, and people were aware of the importance of drinking it, as long as it came from good sources. However, beer was viewed as a more nutritious alternative to water.

Beer was a staple in daily life during the Middle Ages. It was a source of essential calories and nutrients for the population. The beer of the time was weakly brewed, with an ABV of around 3%, and was consumed by people of all ages, often as a meal replacement. For peasants performing hard labor, beer was a more nutritious and energy-providing choice than water.

Beer also had social and cultural significance. People would gather in taverns or alehouses to socialize, discuss important matters, and conduct business transactions. Beer was integral to celebrations and festivals, bringing communities together and fostering a sense of camaraderie. Monasteries, which played a vital role in beer production, considered beer a divine creation, and its consumption was seen as a way to connect with spirituality.

In addition to its nutritional and social value, beer was also seen as a symbol of prosperity and community. Beer consumption was prevalent among all classes, from peasants to nobles, and served as common ground for people to gather and forge connections.

Beer was safer than water

It is a common misconception that people in the Middle Ages drank beer instead of water because the water was unsafe. In reality, there is plenty of evidence to suggest that medieval people understood the importance of drinking water and had access to clean sources.

Water was free and readily available from nearby springs, rivers, lakes, wells, and cisterns, and medieval communities were careful not to pollute these sources with human or livestock waste. Most people during this period lived in rural areas and could easily access clean water from the nearest stream or well. In larger towns and cities, there was infrastructure in place to supply clean water to citizens. For example, London had a complex system of pipes that transported water from a fresh spring to a pumping house, making freshwater available throughout the city.

While it is true that water supplies could become contaminated, especially in densely populated areas or during heavy rainfall, this did not make beer the primary drink of choice. Beer was more expensive than water, as it had to be purchased and it was subject to taxes and transportation fees. It was also less convenient, as it had to be brewed or purchased, whereas water was readily available from natural sources.

Medieval people were not foolish and would avoid drinking water that looked or smelled bad. They also took measures to prevent pollution of their water sources, with tradesmen who used water facing hefty fines if they contaminated the town's drinking supply.

While beer was consumed in the Middle Ages, it was not a replacement for water but rather a nutritious alternative. Weakly brewed from barley, beer was a calorie-dense beverage that provided energy for workers and farmers. It was also enjoyed for pleasure, just as alcoholic beverages are today.

In conclusion, while water supplies in the Middle Ages may have been contaminated at times, the notion that people primarily drank beer because water was unsafe is a myth. Medieval people had access to clean water sources and understood the importance of hydration, and beer was a supplementary or preferential drink rather than a necessity.

Beer was used for tax payments

Beer was a common way to pay taxes and tithes in the Middle Ages. For example, the 15th-century bishop of Tournai received a tithe of beer from tenants on his lands. In medieval Europe, water was free and accessible from natural sources such as rivers and streams. However, beer was often viewed as a more nutritious alternative to water, providing calories and energy to those who consumed it. This was especially true for peasants performing hard labor, as beer served as a source of carbohydrates and calories.

During the Middle Ages, the main forms of taxation in England were land taxes, custom duties, and fees to mint coins. The most important tax of the late Anglo-Saxon period was the "geld," a land tax used to pay for mercenaries. After the Norman Conquest of England in 1066, taxes were imposed on personal property and income. In the 13th century, taxes were also levied on trade, with customs duties imposed on the value of imported and exported goods.

While beer was used for tax payments, it is a myth that it was more popular than water during the Middle Ages. Records from this period indicate that water was plentiful and commonly consumed. For example, Saint Gregory of Tours mentions a boy who primarily drank water due to his religious beliefs, as well as a traveler in the sixth century who asked for water from a villager. Additionally, water was free and clean, with villages and towns often built near springs, rivers, or wells to ensure access to freshwater.

In conclusion, while beer was used for tax payments and was consumed by people of all social classes, it did not replace water as the primary drink during the Middle Ages.

Frequently asked questions