Beer Vs Water: Which Is Healthier?

Beer has been a staple drink for thousands of years, dating back to the Middle Ages when it was considered safer to drink than water due to the scarcity of clean drinking water. Today, the question of whether beer is healthier than water is more complex. While beer has some nutritional benefits, such as being a source of antioxidants, vitamins, minerals, and protein, it also contains alcohol, which has various health risks. On the other hand, water is essential for hydration but may not offer the same nutritional benefits as beer. A direct comparison between the two beverages reveals that they serve different purposes and have unique impacts on the body, making it challenging to declare one as unequivocally healthier than the other.

Beer has more nutrients than water

The brewing process of beer also makes it cleaner than its original water source, which was especially important during the Middle Ages when clean drinking water was scarce. Beer was preferred over water during this period as it had been boiled during brewing, ensuring its purity.

However, it's important to note that the health effects of beer are mixed. While moderate consumption may have some benefits, heavy or binge drinking is associated with negative health consequences. These include an increased risk of alcohol use disorder, depression, liver disease, weight gain, and more.

In summary, while beer may have more nutrients than water, it should still be consumed in moderation as part of a healthy and balanced diet that includes a variety of whole foods like fruits and vegetables.

Beer is safer than water in the Middle Ages

It is a common misconception that beer was seen as a safer alternative to water during the Middle Ages. While beer was indeed consumed during this period, water was also a common beverage, and records indicate that it was plentiful and widely consumed.

During the Middle Ages, water sources in Europe were relatively clean due to limited manufacturing and the understanding of the importance of clean water sources. Communities generally avoided polluting their water sources with human or livestock waste. Even in more densely populated areas, such as London, there were infrastructures in place to supply clean water to citizens. For example, in 1236, a system of pipes was constructed to transport water from a fresh spring to a pumping house, making fresh water available throughout the city.

However, it is important to note that the risk of contaminated water was always present. Diseases such as cholera, spread through contaminated drinking water, were a major concern. Other waterborne diseases, such as those caused by E. coli and the parasite Giardia lamblia, could also be contracted from drinking water. As a result, beer may have been viewed as a safer alternative by some people during this time.

The brewing process makes beer cleaner than its original water source, as the water is boiled during brewing. In an era where the purity of water was uncertain, alcoholic drinks like beer, which had been boiled, were a popular choice. Beer was also considered more nutritious than water, providing calories and carbohydrates, especially for those performing hard labor or farming work.

While beer was consumed during the Middle Ages, it is important to note that it was not a replacement for water. Water was widely available and consumed by people from all walks of life. Beer, on the other hand, was more expensive and was subject to taxes and transportation fees. Therefore, while beer may have been seen as a safer alternative by some, it was not the only beverage consumed during the Middle Ages.

Beer has fewer calories than other drinks

Beer has fewer calories than other alcoholic drinks. A standard 12-ounce can of beer contains approximately 100 to 150 calories. However, this varies depending on the type of beer and its alcohol content. Light beers, for example, typically have lower alcohol content and fewer calories, with around 90 to 100 calories per 12-ounce serving. On the other hand, high-alcohol beers, such as some IPAs or stouts, may contain more calories due to their increased alcohol and malt content, ranging from 200 to 350 calories per 12-ounce serving or more.

When compared to other alcoholic beverages, beer may offer a slightly lower-calorie option. For instance, a 5-ounce glass of red wine typically contains around 125 calories, while a 7-ounce mixed drink or a standard 7-ounce spirit contains approximately 155 calories. However, it is important to note that the calorie content of alcoholic drinks can vary widely, depending on factors such as alcohol percentage, additional ingredients, and serving size.

While beer may have fewer calories than some alcoholic drinks, it is still considered a significant source of empty" calories, providing energy without contributing much in terms of nutritional value. This means that while beer may have a lower calorie count than certain beverages, it should still be consumed in moderation as part of a balanced and healthy diet.

In summary, when it comes to calorie content, beer can be considered a slightly lower-calorie option compared to certain alcoholic drinks, but it still contributes to the overall calorie intake and should be consumed in moderation for maintaining a healthy lifestyle.

Beer has antioxidants

Beer is a low-alcohol beverage that contains appreciable amounts of bioactive compounds, mainly antioxidants, which are associated with health effects. Polyphenols and melanoidins are the major natural antioxidants in beer. The antioxidant capacity of beer depends on the antioxidant contents in its two main ingredients, malt and hop, and on different parameters involved in brewing.

Polyphenols are characterized by the presence of one or several phenolic groups in their structure, which are capable of reducing reactive oxygen species and various organic substrates and minerals. These redox properties explain the considerable interest in their role in the prevention of several major chronic diseases associated with oxidative stress, such as cardiovascular diseases, cancers, type II diabetes, neurodegenerative diseases, and osteoporosis. Phenols present in beer help lower blood pressure and increase the concentration of nitric oxide in the plasma, reducing the risk of cardiovascular disease.

Polyphenols are also recognized as preventers of colon cancer and are able to cause positive changes in the gut microbiota. They are also associated with improvements experienced by women in menopause and improvements observed in people suffering from arthritis.

Melanoidins are macromolecular, nitrogenous, and brown-colored products of Maillard reactions, which are formed during the malting and brewing process. Several works have shown that, in addition to their ability to affect the color, flavor, and body of beer, these compounds can exert a certain effect on health. Melanoidins demonstrate the ability to bind metal ions such as Fe+2 and are considered as antimutagenic and tumor growth-inhibiting compounds. They also protect against damage caused by reactive oxygen species to DNA, and a more intense effect was found for dark beers than for blond beers due to dark beers being richer in melanoidins.

Beer has a higher protein content

The protein in beer comes from the grains used in the brewing process. Grains such as barley and wheat are rich in carbohydrates and other nutrients, including protein. However, it is important to note that the amount of protein in beer is still relatively low compared to other sources of protein. For example, a 3-ounce serving of chicken breast contains around 26 grams of protein.

While beer may have a higher protein content than water, it is not a significant source of protein compared to other foods or beverages. The protein content of beer is minimal, and whole foods are better sources of protein and other nutrients. Additionally, the calories from alcohol do not adequately provide the nutrition that the body needs.

It is also important to consider that beer is typically consumed in larger quantities than water, which could contribute to a higher intake of protein. However, excessive consumption of beer can lead to short-term and long-term health risks, including injuries, alcohol poisoning, weakened immune system, and social problems. Therefore, it is important to consume beer in moderation, which is typically defined as no more than two drinks per day for men and no more than one drink per day for women.

Frequently asked questions