Clarified Beer: Healthier Option Or Just A Fad?

Beer drinkers often favour bright beers for their clear, crisp look and their ability to allow better head formation and retention. However, some beer styles require a haze, such as Hefeweizens, Wits, or Hazy IPAs. The hazy appearance of a finished beer can be caused by biological and non-biological factors. While biological hazes are caused by poorly flocculating yeast strains or bacterial infections, non-biological hazes are produced when malt proteins and hop polyphenols combine to form a protein-polyphenol mix as the beer is chilled. This process is known as chill haze and occurs at temperatures between 32–45 °F (0–7 °C). To achieve a clear beer, brewers can use a variety of techniques, including filtration, pasteurization, and the addition of clarifying agents such as gelatin or Irish Moss.

Clarified beer is achieved through processes like filtration and pasteurization

Beer clarification is the process of removing solids from wort or beer to achieve a clear liquid. Commercial breweries use filtration and pasteurization techniques to keep beer crystal clear. While filtration is sometimes used by advanced winemakers, there are simpler techniques that can help improve clarity.

One of the most common ways to clarify beer is through the use of fining agents, which are substances that help remove tannins, proteins, and yeast from the beer. These fining agents can be added at different stages of the brewing process, such as during the boil, at the end of fermentation, or post-fermentation. Some commonly used fining agents include:

• Irish Moss: A type of red seaweed that contains carrageenan, a thickening agent that helps proteins coagulate and fall out of suspension.
• Whirlfloc: A refined form of carrageenan extracted from Irish Moss, often used in tablet form.
• Isinglass: Derived from the swim bladders of fish, it helps remove yeast and, when combined with other fining agents, can also remove proteins and polyphenols.
• Gelatin: A common food ingredient derived from animal sources, it helps remove both proteins and polyphenols from the beer.

In addition to fining agents, there are other techniques that can be used to clarify beer:

• Selecting lower-protein grains: Proteins can hinder the clarity of the beer, so choosing grains with lower protein content can help improve clarity.
• Using a wort chiller: Quickly cooling the wort can cause undesirable matter like tannins and proteins to clump and fall out, resulting in a clearer beer.
• Choosing a highly flocculant yeast strain: Flocculation is the rate at which yeast settles out of the beer after fermentation. A yeast strain with a high flocculation rating will result in a clearer beer.
• Cold storage (lagering): Storing beer at low temperatures makes it more difficult for tannins, proteins, and yeast to remain in suspension, leading to clearer beer.

By using a combination of these techniques and fining agents, brewers can effectively clarify their beer and achieve the desired level of clarity and quality.

Unclarified beer can be due to high yeast levels, creating a yeasty, bread-like taste

The taste of beer is influenced by a variety of factors, including the levels of sediment and the types of yeast and protein present. Unclarified beer can be the result of high yeast levels, which can give it a yeasty, bread-like taste. This is caused by high sediment levels that haven't settled, as well as yeast particles and unsettled proteins floating in the beer. These can mask certain flavours and aromas that are meant to be part of the recipe.

Sediment in beer is largely made up of yeast, so high sediment levels can indicate high yeast levels. Yeast is added to the beer during the brewing process, and it is this yeast that ferments the beer, converting sugars into alcohol. However, if the yeast isn't removed through the clarification process, it can affect the taste of the beer.

Yeast is a type of microorganism, and different strains of yeast can have different effects on the beer. Some yeasts are added specifically to give the beer a hazy appearance, such as in Hefeweizens, Wits, or Hazy IPAs. Other yeasts can affect the clarity of the beer, with some yeasts adding a haze that won't go away even with clarifying agents or cold crashing.

The choice of yeast can also affect the flavour of the beer. For example, non-conventional yeasts can be used to produce low-alcohol or non-alcoholic beers. These yeasts are chosen because they are unable to ferment maltose, which results in lower ethanol production. The type of yeast used can also affect the levels of sediment in the beer, as some yeasts are better at flocculating (clumping together and settling) than others.

In addition to yeast, other factors can also affect the clarity and taste of beer. For example, the choice of grains can impact haze, with flaked grains adding haze due to their high beta-glucan content. The amount of protein in the beer can also affect clarity, as proteins can form haze in combination with other compounds.

To summarise, unclarified beer can be due to high yeast levels, which can create a yeasty, bread-like taste. This can be the result of high sediment levels, yeast particles, and unsettled proteins in the beer. The choice of yeast and other factors, such as grains and protein levels, can also affect the clarity and taste of the beer.

Clarification removes solids from wort or beer, improving quality and making it easier to filter

The process of clarification improves the quality of beer by removing solids from wort or beer, making it easier to filter. This is achieved through various techniques and agents that target three things that make beer cloudy: tannins, proteins, and yeast.

Tannins are naturally found in barley grain husks and are extracted during the mashing process or when steeping grains. They can be minimised by selecting appropriate grains and controlling the grain bed pH and water temperature during the sparging process.

Proteins are present in all grains and to some extent in malt extracts. While they enhance the body and head retention of a beer, they hinder clarity. The challenge lies in achieving a delicate balance to create a full-bodied beer without excessive protein. Certain fining agents can help reduce the "chill haze" caused by proteins.

Yeast is present during fermentation and remains suspended in the beer. Most yeast strains eventually precipitate to the bottom of the beer, but it can take a considerable amount of time. Choosing a yeast strain with good flocculation characteristics can help eliminate a lot of particulate matter.

To improve beer clarity, brewers can employ several methods:

• Selecting low-protein cereal ingredients: Reserving high-protein adjuncts for wheat and dark beers, and choosing light malt for light beers, helps achieve the desired colour and body without compromising clarity.
• Using a wort cooler: Quickly cooling the wort to below 80°F (48.8°C) causes undesirable substances like tannins and proteins to clump and settle at the bottom of the boiling pot, resulting in clearer beer.
• Opting for highly flocculating yeast strains: Flocculation refers to the rate at which a yeast strain precipitates from beer after fermentation. Choosing a strain with a high flocculation rate makes the yeast settle faster, improving clarity.
• Cold storing (lagering) the beer: Storing beer in a refrigerated environment, ideally at 33-35°F (0.5-1.6°C), makes it more challenging for tannins, proteins, and yeast to remain in suspension, leading to faster clarification.
• Employing clarifying agents: Various clarifying agents, such as Irish moss, Whirlfloc, isinglass, gelatin, and silica gel, can be added during or after fermentation. These agents attach themselves to proteins, yeast, and tannins, making them heavier and causing them to settle at the bottom of the fermenter, thereby enhancing clarity.

Non-biological particles in unclarified beer include starch, protein, and calcium oxalate

The process of clarifying beer involves removing solids from the wort or beer to achieve a clear liquid. While some beer styles require a haze, such as Hefeweizens, Wits, and Hazy IPAs, others are expected to be clear, like Lagers, Blonde Ales, and Marzens.

Other non-biological particles that can contribute to haze in beer include yeast, polyphenols (mostly tannins), and carbohydrates from the grains and hops. Haze in beer can also be influenced by factors such as pH, alcohol content, carbohydrates, and metal ions.

Clarifying agents, such as fining agents or filtration techniques, can be used to remove these non-biological particles and create a clearer beer. However, some brewers of hazy beers argue that they intentionally add hops to enhance flavour and aroma, so removing these particles through clarification would be counter-intuitive.

Clarified beer is favoured by beer drinkers for its appearance, but it can be elusive to brew

Beer drinkers tend to favour bright, clarified beers for their appearance, but brewing them can be elusive. While some beer styles require a haze, such as Hefeweizens, Wits, or Hazy IPAs, other styles are expected to be clear. Lagers, Blonde Ales, and Marzens are expected to be clear, with some purists insisting their Marzens are so clear that they can read a newspaper through it.

The hazy appearance of a finished beer can be caused by two groups of factors: biological and non-biological. Poorly flocculating yeast strains or an infection by wild yeast strains or bacteria cause biological hazes. Non-biological hazes are caused by the creation of a protein-polyphenol mix when the beer is chilled, which is known as a 'chill haze'.

Brewers can use a few methods to clarify their beer. One method is to use a wort cooler to rapidly cool the wort to below 80°F (27°C). This causes undesirable substances like tannins and proteins to clump and fall to the bottom of the brew tank, preventing them from entering the fermentation tank. Another method is to use high flocculation yeast. Flocculation is the rate at which a particular yeast strain is shed from the beer after fermentation is complete. A yeast strain with a high flocculation rate will clear faster than one with a low rate. Brewers can also cold store their beer, which involves storing it in a refrigerated environment of around 33-35°F (1-2°C). At these lower temperatures, it is more difficult for tannins, proteins, and yeast strains to remain in suspension, and the beer clarifies faster. Finally, brewers can add clarifying agents, such as gelatin or isinglass, to help remove unwanted sediment.

Frequently asked questions