Making Beer: Worth The Effort To Save Money?

Homebrewing is a popular hobby for beer enthusiasts, but is it a more cost-effective option than buying beer from the store? The answer depends on various factors, including equipment costs, ingredient quality, and the time and effort invested in the brewing process.

On the one hand, homebrewing can offer significant savings, especially when compared to the cost of craft beer. For example, the cost of producing a 330ml bottle of all-grain homebrewed beer is estimated at around $0.70, while a similar-sized bottle of craft beer may cost around $5.00. Additionally, brewing at home provides full control over the ingredients and flavours used, allowing for customization and experimentation.

On the other hand, there are initial investments to consider when it comes to equipment and ingredients, which can be quite pricey. A basic brewing kit for beginners can cost around $200, and the cost of ingredients for a 19-litre batch of beer typically ranges from $30 to $40. Furthermore, homebrewing can be time-consuming, with each batch taking a minimum of 8-9 hours to complete, spread across a 5-week waiting period.

In conclusion, while homebrewing can offer cost savings over time, particularly when compared to craft beer prices, it also requires a significant investment in equipment, ingredients, and time. For those who enjoy the hobby and the customization it offers, homebrewing may be a worthwhile endeavour. However, for those solely focused on cost savings, buying beer from the store may be a more convenient and affordable option.

The cost of ingredients for homebrewing

The cost of ingredients for a 19-litre batch of an all-grain brew can be broken down as follows:

• Grains: 4-6 kg of malted barley, at roughly $5 per kg, for a total of $20-30.
• Hops: 70 grams, with prices at about $18 for 250 grams, for a total of $5.
• Yeast: $4.40 for a single packet of US-05.

The total ingredient cost for a 19-litre batch of an all-grain brew is approximately $39, or $2.00 per litre.

For an extract brew, the cost of ingredients for a 19-litre batch is as follows:

• Malt extract: Depending on the type and quality, malt extract can cost around $30 per batch.
• Hops: $5 for dry hopping.
• Yeast: $4.40 for a single packet of US-05.

The total ingredient cost for a 19-litre batch of an extract brew is approximately $39, or $2.00 per litre.

It is worth noting that these costs do not include the initial investment in brewing equipment, which can be substantial.

Homebrewers can also save money by buying ingredients in bulk and reusing yeast.

The cost of equipment for homebrewing

Basic Equipment:

• A basic brewing kit for beginners typically costs around $200. This includes all the essential equipment needed to start brewing good-quality beer.
• A brew system like the Brewzilla from Kegland costs around $605.
• A fermenter, which is necessary for the fermentation process, costs approximately $30.
• Bottles for packaging the beer can often be obtained for free or by buying and drinking beer.

Ingredients:

• Grains: Malted barley is a common choice, costing around $5 per kg. For a 19-litre batch, you would need 4-6 kg, totalling $20-30.
• Hops: Hops add flavour and aroma to the beer. For a typical batch, you may need around 70 grams, which could cost about $5.
• Yeast: A single packet of US-05 yeast costs around $4.40.

Additional Costs:

• Malt extract: Used in extract brewing, this can cost around $30 per batch.
• Sanitizer: Proper sanitation is crucial, and sanitizers help ensure a clean brewing environment.
• Fermentation chamber/fridge: Maintaining consistent temperatures during fermentation is important, and a fermentation chamber or fridge can help achieve this.
• Bottling or kegging equipment: For bottling, you'll need bottles, caps, and a capping device. Kegging requires a higher initial investment but can save time and effort.
• Maintenance and replacement parts: Over time, some parts may need to be replaced, such as gaskets, airlocks, and tubing.
• Labour and time: Homebrewing can be time-consuming, and it's important to consider the value of the time invested in the process.
• Energy costs: Propane or natural gas for heating and electricity for fermentation and other processes should be factored into the overall costs.

The time and labour involved in homebrewing

Homebrewing is a time-consuming process, with one source estimating that it takes a minimum of 8-9 hours of labour to produce a batch of beer. This time is spread across a 5-week waiting period, with most of the labour occurring on the first day of brewing the wort and starting fermentation, which can take up to 5 hours. The remaining time is spent on transferring the beer (1 hour), bottling (1 hour), and cleaning/sanitising equipment (2-3 hours). Brewing larger quantities may help to reduce the amount of labour per beer, but smaller batches result in less output for the effort.

The time commitment involved in homebrewing is a significant factor when considering the cost-effectiveness of the hobby. While some people argue that the value of one's time should not be included in the calculation, others believe that their time is valuable and should be factored into the overall cost. For example, if you value your time at $5 per hour and spend 8 hours labouring over a batch of beer, that adds an extra $40 to the cost, making homebrewing as expensive as store-bought beer.

Additionally, homebrewing requires regular maintenance and replacement of parts, which can impact the overall cost. Items like gaskets, airlocks, and tubing may need to be replaced periodically, and larger investments, such as a grain mill or kegging system, can add significant expenses. Sanitisation is also a critical and time-consuming aspect of homebrewing, as all equipment must be thoroughly cleaned and sanitised before each use to ensure the quality and safety of the beer.

The cost of buying beer from a store or pub

When considering the cost of store-bought or pub beer, it's important to factor in the quantity purchased and the frequency of consumption. For example, buying in bulk or during promotions can reduce the cost per beer. Additionally, the type of beer, such as craft or macrobrewed, will impact the overall cost.

It's worth noting that the cost of beer can vary significantly across different countries and regions due to factors such as taxes, production costs, and distribution channels. For instance, beer prices in Canada and Australia tend to be higher than in the United States.

In summary, the cost of buying beer from a store or pub can vary widely depending on various factors, but it generally ranges from a few dollars to over $10 per serving, depending on the quantity purchased, the type of beer, and the location.

The cost of buying beer from a microbrewery

On average, it costs between $250,000 and $500,000 to start a microbrewery, with costs ranging from $500,000 to $1.5 million for larger craft breweries. These costs include equipment such as brew kettles, fermentation tanks, milling equipment, cooling systems, packaging equipment, and quality control tools.

The price of a beer from a microbrewery will depend on these initial costs, as well as the ongoing expenses of running the business, such as ingredients, staffing, utilities, insurance, and marketing. These costs will be reflected in the price of a beer, which can range from a few dollars to over $10 per beer, depending on the specific microbrewery and the type of beer.

Microbreweries often have taprooms or restaurants attached, which can provide additional revenue streams but also increase costs. The cost of a beer at a microbrewery taproom will likely be higher than the cost of a beer at a store or regular bar due to these increased expenses.

In summary, the cost of buying beer from a microbrewery will depend on a variety of factors related to the initial investment, ongoing expenses, and the specific market the microbrewery is operating in. These costs will ultimately be passed on to the consumer in the price of a beer.

Frequently asked questions