Beer Buying For Alcoholics: Ethical Or Not?

Non-alcoholic beer is often marketed as a safe alternative to alcoholic beverages, but it's important to be aware of the risks involved, especially for those struggling with alcohol addiction. While non-alcoholic beer typically contains less than 0.5% alcohol by volume (ABV), it's not completely alcohol-free, and the potential dangers it poses, especially as a trigger for alcoholics, cannot be overlooked. The smell and taste of non-alcoholic beer, which closely resemble those of regular beer, have been known to trigger cravings and potential relapses among people with alcohol use disorder.

Non-alcoholic beer can still contain alcohol

Non-alcoholic beer is often marketed as a safe alternative to alcoholic beer, but it's important to be aware that it may still contain alcohol. In the United States, non-alcoholic beer is legally defined as any malt beverage containing up to 0.5% alcohol by volume (ABV). While this is significantly less than the alcohol content of traditional beer, which typically ranges from 4-6% ABV, it's important to note that non-alcoholic beer can still have some alcohol content.

The amount of alcohol in non-alcoholic beer can vary, and it's essential to check the labels before consuming it. Some non-alcoholic beers claim to contain 0.0% ABV, while others may have up to 0.5% ABV. By law, non-alcoholic beers can have up to 0.5% ABV, while products marketed as alcohol-free are required by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to have no detectable levels of alcohol.

Research suggests that many non-alcoholic beers may contain more alcohol than their labels indicate. One study found that 29% of no- or low-alcohol beers tested had higher alcohol levels than stated on their labels, with some zero-alcohol beers containing over 1% alcohol. Additionally, people with liver impairments may develop higher blood alcohol levels than normal after consuming non-alcoholic beer, which could cause them to test positive on alcohol urine or breath tests.

The smell of non-alcoholic beer is very similar to regular beer, and this could potentially trigger cravings and relapse in people with alcohol use disorder. While non-alcoholic beer may be a good option for those looking to reduce their alcohol intake, it's important to consider the potential risks, especially for pregnant individuals or those with a history of alcohol dependency.

In terms of legality, the laws surrounding the purchase of non-alcoholic beer by minors vary across different states in the US. While the Federal Alcohol Administration Act regulates non-alcoholic beers, the legal drinking age is set by each individual state. Some states allow minors to purchase non-alcoholic beer with certain restrictions, while others prohibit it altogether.

It may be a trigger for recovering alcoholics

Non-alcoholic beer is often marketed as a safe alternative to alcoholic drinks. However, it may be a trigger for recovering alcoholics.

Non-alcoholic beer typically contains less than 0.5% alcohol by volume (ABV). While this is a significantly lower amount of alcohol compared to regular beer, it is important to note that non-alcoholic beer is not completely alcohol-free. The small amount of alcohol present in non-alcoholic beer can still pose risks for certain individuals, especially those with a history of alcohol abuse.

The smell of beer, even non-alcoholic beer, can be a powerful trigger for recovering alcoholics. The sense of smell is strongly linked to memory and emotion. For someone with an alcohol use disorder, the smell of beer can evoke cravings and increase the risk of relapse. In a study conducted on rats, researchers found that the smell of alcohol increased levels of dopamine, a brain chemical associated with pleasure and reward. While this was an animal study, it suggests that the smell of beer, even without the presence of alcohol, can have a significant impact on the brain.

Additionally, the packaging and marketing of non-alcoholic beer are often very similar to those of alcoholic beer. This can create a sense of familiarity and increase the risk of relapse for recovering alcoholics. It is important to remember that non-alcoholic beer is not just a beverage but also a cultural experience. The act of drinking beer, even a non-alcoholic one, can evoke strong emotions and memories associated with alcohol use.

Furthermore, research has shown that non-alcoholic beer may contain more alcohol than what is indicated on the label. A study found that 29% of no- or low-alcohol beers had higher alcohol levels than what was stated on the label. This discrepancy can be dangerous for recovering alcoholics, as they may unintentionally consume more alcohol than they realize.

For these reasons, it is generally recommended that individuals recovering from alcohol use disorder avoid non-alcoholic beer and anything that resembles or smells like alcohol. It is crucial to prioritize sobriety and create a supportive environment that minimizes triggers and promotes healthy lifestyle changes.

It may be dangerous for pregnant people

It is important to note that non-alcoholic beer may still contain small amounts of alcohol. By law, non-alcoholic beers can have up to 0.5% alcohol by volume (ABV). While this is a very small amount, it is still significant for certain groups of people, including pregnant people.

The American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology (ACOG) recommends that pregnant individuals avoid drinking any alcohol during pregnancy to eliminate the risk of fetal alcohol spectrum disorder (FASD). FASD can cause low body weight, facial abnormalities, physical problems, and neurobehavioral disorders in the developing fetus. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) also states that there is no known safe amount of alcohol use during pregnancy. Therefore, consuming non-alcoholic beer may still pose a risk to pregnant individuals due to the small amount of alcohol it may contain.

Furthermore, research has found that non-alcoholic beer often smells very similar to regular beer. This can be problematic because the smell of beer may serve as a trigger for people with a history of alcohol use disorder. Relapse triggers can be powerful in disrupting recovery, and the smell of non-alcoholic beer may lead to cravings and a subsequent relapse.

Additionally, non-alcoholic beer has a higher carbohydrate content than regular beer due to the added sugars and flavorings. While this may not be a direct danger, it is important for pregnant people to be aware of the higher carbohydrate intake when consuming non-alcoholic beer.

Overall, while non-alcoholic beer may seem like a safer alternative, it is crucial for pregnant individuals to understand the potential risks associated with its consumption. The small amount of alcohol present, the potential triggers, and the higher carbohydrate content are all factors to consider when making an informed decision about consuming non-alcoholic beer during pregnancy.

It may be treated the same as alcoholic beer by retailers

In most regions, including the UK and many US states, drinks under 0.5% ABV aren't legally considered "alcohol" and aren't subject to the same restrictions as alcoholic drinks. Everyday foods and drinks such as ripe bananas and bread contain similar amounts of alcohol and aren't restricted. However, retailers may still treat non-alcoholic beer the same as alcoholic beer for two main reasons:

• To avoid promoting alcohol to children: Alcohol-free beer may not contain much alcohol, but the packaging and the drink itself are almost indistinguishable from alcoholic beer. Many alcohol-free and non-alcoholic beers are produced by companies that also produce alcoholic drinks. Promoting these drinks to minors could indirectly promote similar products that do contain alcohol.
• To make it easier to enforce rules regarding alcoholic drinks: The packaging of alcohol-free beer is almost identical to that of beer that contains alcohol. This isn't much of an issue in shops, where point-of-sale systems can flag up the differences between alcohol-free and alcoholic beer. But it can be an issue in pubs and bars where owners are responsible for what people drink on the premises. Treating alcohol-free beer the same as alcoholic drinks makes it easier to monitor what customers are drinking.

It may be restricted to minors in some places

The sale of non-alcoholic beer to minors is a contentious issue. While some retailers choose to restrict sales to minors, it is not illegal in most regions to sell these drinks to those under the legal drinking age. In the United States, the laws vary from state to state. For example, in Ohio, minors must be over 18 to purchase non-alcoholic beer, whereas in Oregon, West Virginia, and Wyoming, minors cannot purchase it at all. In Alabama, the sale of non-alcoholic beer is not regulated in wet counties, but it is prohibited in dry counties.

Retailers who choose to restrict sales to minors do so for two main reasons: to avoid promoting alcohol to children and to make it easier to enforce rules regarding alcoholic drinks. Many non-alcoholic beers are produced by companies that also produce alcoholic drinks, so promoting these products to minors could indirectly promote alcoholic products to them. Additionally, the packaging and the drink itself are often indistinguishable from alcoholic beer, making it difficult for staff to monitor what customers are drinking.

Some health researchers are calling for clear and consistent age limits for non-alcoholic beers, wines, and liquors, likening them to candy cigarettes. They argue that these drinks could be a gateway to alcohol consumption for minors and that the absence of age restrictions could lead to a public health issue. However, others in the non-alcoholic beverage industry argue that government regulation is unnecessary and that the industry can self-police to ensure that minors do not have access to these drinks.

Ultimately, the decision to restrict the sale of non-alcoholic beer to minors is left to individual retailers and states in the US. While there may be valid arguments on both sides, the primary concern is to protect minors from the potential dangers of alcohol consumption.

Frequently asked questions