Should We Buy The Homeless Alcohol?

There are differing opinions on whether it is okay to buy a homeless person a beer. Some people believe that it is okay as homeless people are already going through a lot and a beer might help them get through the day. Others believe that it is wrong to buy a homeless person beer, especially if they are an alcoholic, as it would be enabling their addiction.

Homeless people are people too and can make their own choices

There are differing opinions on whether it is okay to buy a homeless person a beer. Some people argue that it is okay as homeless people are also people and can make their own choices. They believe that homeless people should be treated with dignity and respect, and that a beer may bring them some happiness or comfort. Others argue that it is not okay as it may enable or encourage harmful behaviour, such as addiction.

Those who are against the idea of buying a homeless person a beer often assume that the person will use the money for alcohol or drugs. They believe that giving money to homeless people will only worsen their situation and enable their addiction. However, this assumption ignores the fact that homeless people, like anyone else, have different needs and priorities. While some may indeed spend the money on substances, others may use it to buy food, clothes, or other essential items. Judging or making assumptions about how a homeless person will spend the money is not only disrespectful but also ignores the fact that they are individuals with their own agency.

Additionally, the assumption that all homeless people are addicts is incorrect and perpetuates negative stereotypes. Homelessness is caused by a variety of factors, including a lack of affordable housing, mental illness, and addiction. By recognising that homeless people are individuals with unique stories, we can move beyond these stereotypes and provide more effective support.

Ultimately, the decision to buy a homeless person a beer is a personal one. Those who do so often recognise that the person may be going through a difficult time and believe that a beer could bring them some comfort. They respect the person's agency and understand that a beer is not going to significantly worsen their situation. While there may be concerns about enabling addiction, it is important to remember that addiction is a complex issue that often requires professional help. A single beer is unlikely to be the deciding factor in someone's addiction, and refusing to provide it may do more harm than good.

In conclusion, the debate around buying a homeless person a beer centres on the balance between respecting personal agency and preventing potential harm. Those who support the idea believe that homeless people should have the freedom to make their own choices, while those against it prioritise the potential risks associated with substance abuse. Ultimately, the decision is a personal one, and it is essential to approach each situation with empathy and understanding.

You can't know what they'll spend your money on

When it comes to giving money to homeless people, many are hesitant due to the belief that the money will be spent on alcohol or drugs. However, this concern may be unfounded as there is no way of knowing how the money will be spent. While some may argue that giving money to homeless people enables their addiction, others counter that not all homeless people are addicts and that everyone deserves a little comfort, regardless of their living situation.

Some people believe that it is better to give homeless people food, water, or other necessities rather than money, to ensure that the donation is not used to fuel an addiction. However, this approach can be problematic as it assumes that the recipient will accept and appreciate the offered items. Offering food or other items may also be seen as a way to control how the recipient spends their money, which can be seen as disrespectful and paternalistic.

Ultimately, once money is given to a homeless person, it is up to them to decide how to spend it. While some may use it to buy alcohol or drugs, others may use it to purchase essentials or simply to get through another day. Judging a homeless person for how they choose to spend a few dollars can be seen as self-righteous and ignorant of the complex issues surrounding homelessness.

It is important to recognize that homelessness is often caused by a combination of factors, including mental illness, addiction, lack of affordable housing, and other socioeconomic issues. Giving money to a homeless person may not solve these larger systemic problems, but it could provide some comfort or assistance in the short term.

So, while there is a possibility that the money could be spent on alcohol or drugs, it is not necessarily a reason to withhold help. Each situation is unique, and it is up to the individual to decide how they want to respond to a homeless person asking for money, keeping in mind the complexities and challenges of homelessness.

It's not your place to judge

Whatever the reason is, all you know from your brief interaction with them is that this individual is in a bad enough situation where they have to put aside their dignity and ask you for money. If you don't want to give someone money, then don't. But don't act like it's because you're an altruistic, self-righteous saint. Unless you're ready to go out of your way to help re-home them and pay for their rehabilitation services, your judgement of how they spend a small amount of money is not warranted.

People are homeless for a number of reasons, and it's wrong to assume that substance abuse is the cause of their situation. Surviving and living are two very different things, and in order to live, one has to find a way to enjoy their life, in whatever way possible.

It's important to realize that homeless people are not all addicts, and they are people just like anyone else. Most people like to enjoy a drink once in a while, so why shouldn't homeless people be allowed to as well? As long as you're not forcing them to drink, it's their choice to spend their money on alcohol if they want to.

At the end of the day, many services for the homeless just help them survive another day since true rehabilitation would require stable housing and a source of income. It's not your place to decide what they do with their money or judge them for their choices. If you can afford to give someone money, even if it's just a little bit, do it without worrying about what they'll spend it on. It could make a tremendous difference in their day, and that possibility is worth it.

It's legal and ubiquitous

Alcohol is a legal substance, and it is a common sight to see people drinking it. It is not illegal to buy a homeless person a beer, and it is a personal choice whether to do so or not.

There are differing opinions on the morality of buying a homeless person alcohol. Some people believe that it is wrong to enable a homeless person's addiction and that it would be better to give them food or money instead. Others argue that addiction is a serious issue and that alcohol can help addicts avoid dangerous withdrawal symptoms. Some people also believe that it is not their place to judge how a homeless person spends their money.

Ultimately, it is a personal decision whether to buy a homeless person a beer or not. Some people may feel that it is the humane thing to do, while others may feel that it is enabling harmful behaviour. It is important to respect the dignity of homeless people and remember that they are individuals with their own agency.

If you are unsure about buying a homeless person alcohol, there are other ways to help. You could offer to buy them food or a hot drink, or give them money and let them decide how to spend it. You could also donate to charities that help homeless people, especially those focused on providing housing and supporting those with addictions.

Refusing a beer isn't for their benefit, it's for yours

Refusing a beer to a homeless person isn't for their benefit, it's for yours.

There are a variety of reasons why people may refuse to buy a homeless person a beer. Some people may be concerned that they are fueling an addiction or that the person will be unable to cope with the effects of alcohol. Others may believe that the money would be better spent on food or other essentials. Some may even feel that it is unsafe to provide alcohol to someone who is already in a vulnerable position.

While these concerns are understandable, they are often rooted in judgment and stigma rather than fact. The assumption that all homeless people are addicts is inaccurate and harmful. Homeless people are diverse, and many may simply want a drink, just like anyone else.

Additionally, refusing to provide a beer can be seen as a way of maintaining control and power over someone who is already marginalized and disenfranchised. It reinforces the idea that homeless people are incapable of making their own decisions and need others to decide what is best for them.

It's important to recognize that everyone has different needs and priorities. For some, a beer may be a source of comfort or a way to cope with the challenges of living on the streets. It may even provide a sense of normalcy or community in an otherwise difficult and isolating situation.

Ultimately, the decision to buy a beer for a homeless person is a personal one. If you are uncomfortable with the idea, you can always offer other forms of assistance, such as food, water, or a warm meal. However, it's essential to approach these interactions with empathy and respect, recognizing that homeless people are individuals with their own agency and autonomy, who deserve to be treated with dignity and compassion.

So, while refusing a beer may provide some people with a sense of control or reassurance, it's important to question whose benefit this truly serves.

Frequently asked questions