Beer Before Liquor: Is It Safe Or Not?

The saying goes, beer before liquor, never been sicker; liquor before beer, you're in the clear. But is there any truth to this? Many people swear by this rule, but it turns out that the order in which you consume your drinks is unlikely to influence whether or not you get a hangover. The amount of alcohol you consume, whether you ate beforehand, how frequently you drink, genetics, and other factors are more likely to affect whether you experience a hangover. So, while it's not true that beer before liquor will make you sicker, it's still important to drink responsibly and in moderation to avoid negative health effects.

The amount of alcohol consumed is more important than the type

The idea that drinking beer before liquor can make you sick is a common misconception. While many people believe in this adage, the truth is that the amount of alcohol consumed is more important than the type or order in which it is consumed.

The myth that "beer before liquor, never been sicker; liquor before beer, you're in the clear" likely originated from the way we digest alcohol and how it is absorbed into the bloodstream. Carbonated drinks like beer and sparkling wine can irritate the stomach lining, increasing the rate of alcohol absorption. Additionally, liquor has a higher alcohol content and can spike your blood alcohol levels more quickly compared to beer. However, this does not mean that drinking liquor before beer will protect you from a hangover.

Modern research has disproven this myth, showing that the order of consumption does not influence hangover severity. A 2019 study compared the hangover intensities of subjects who drank only beer, only wine, beer and then wine, or wine and then beer. The results indicated that neither the type nor the order of alcoholic beverages affected the hangover intensity.

The amount of alcohol you drink has a more significant impact on hangovers than the type of alcohol. High blood alcohol levels are more likely to induce a hangover, regardless of whether you drank beer, liquor, or a combination of both. Other factors that can affect your risk of a hangover include whether you ate before drinking, how frequently you drink, genetics, congeners (compounds found in alcoholic beverages), and smoking.

To reduce the risk and severity of a hangover, it is essential to drink in moderation, stay hydrated, prioritize sleep, and make informed drink choices based on alcohol content rather than the type of beverage.

Carbonated drinks irritate the stomach lining, increasing alcohol absorption

Carbonated drinks can irritate the stomach lining, which may lead to increased alcohol absorption. The carbonation in these beverages can introduce air into the stomach, causing bloating, nausea, and pain. Additionally, the carbon dioxide in carbonated drinks increases gastric volume, which can lead to feelings of fullness. The irritation caused by carbonation can further aggravate digestive conditions such as irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) and gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD).

The effects of carbonation on alcohol absorption have been studied, and it has been found that carbonation can temporarily increase the rate of alcohol absorption into the bloodstream. Carbonation may speed up the movement of liquids from the stomach to the small intestine, causing ethanol to reach the small intestine faster. This can result in feeling the effects of alcohol more quickly. However, this effect is temporary, and the amount of alcohol consumed is still the primary factor in determining overall intoxication and hangover severity.

Furthermore, the volume of the drink and the time taken to consume it are also factors to consider. For example, a bottle of beer tends to take longer to drink than a cocktail or a shot, which can result in a lower alcohol consumption rate per minute. Therefore, the order of drinks may be more significant than the type of drink. Starting with heavier drinking at the beginning of the night when one is more sober can help pace oneself and make better decisions about consumption as the evening progresses.

While carbonation can affect alcohol absorption, it is important to note that other factors, such as existing health conditions, medications, smoking, and body composition, also play a role in how quickly alcohol is absorbed and metabolized. Additionally, drinking on an empty stomach, consuming high-alcohol cocktails, and drinking speed can all contribute to faster alcohol absorption.

In conclusion, while carbonated drinks can irritate the stomach lining and potentially increase alcohol absorption, the overall amount of alcohol consumed and other factors are more significant in determining intoxication and hangover severity. It is always important to drink in moderation and be mindful of how different drinks and consumption patterns affect your body.

Drinking order is unlikely to influence hangovers

The popular saying goes, "beer before liquor, never been sicker; liquor before beer, you're in the clear". This saying suggests that drinking liquor after beer can make hangover symptoms more extreme. However, this is a myth, and research has disproven it.

A 2019 study examined the effect of beer and wine consumption in various orders and combinations on 90 adult participants. The results suggested that drinking order and type of alcohol did not influence hangover intensity. The study found that neither the type nor order of consumed alcoholic beverages significantly affected hangover severity.

The amount of alcohol consumed has a more significant effect on a hangover than the type of alcohol. To reduce the risk or severity of a hangover, it is important to drink less alcohol, regardless of the type. Other factors that can contribute to hangover symptoms include acetaldehyde, a toxic alcohol byproduct, disrupted sleep patterns, and combining alcohol with other substances.

The only way to completely prevent a hangover is to not drink alcohol or to drink in moderation. If you want to reduce the risk of a hangover, it is important to stay hydrated, drink in moderation, and get plenty of sleep.

Liquor before beer may slow subsequent spikes in blood alcohol levels

The popular saying, "beer before liquor, never been sicker; liquor before beer, you're in the clear," suggests that drinking beer before liquor can worsen hangover symptoms. However, this notion is just a myth, and modern research has disproven it. The 2019 study examined the drinking habits of 90 adult participants and found that the order of consumption did not influence hangover severity.

That being said, the theory behind "liquor before beer, you're in the clear" holds that starting the night with liquor and ending with beer may slow the spikes in blood alcohol levels. This is because liquor has a higher alcohol content and is more likely to spike your blood alcohol levels in a short period. By starting with liquor, you may quickly reach a higher blood alcohol level, and switching to beer will slow down the rate of increase in blood alcohol content. This theory suggests that the order of drinks may help limit the severity of hangover symptoms the next morning.

The idea that liquor before beer can slow the spike in blood alcohol levels is based on the different alcohol contents of the drinks. Beer tends to have a lower alcohol content than liquor, and the volume of beer is usually larger, leading to a lower alcohol consumption rate per minute. Therefore, drinking beer after liquor may help pace your drinking and potentially reduce the amount of alcohol consumed overall.

However, it's important to note that the total amount of alcohol consumed and other factors like eating, genetics, and drinking frequency play a more significant role in determining the severity of a hangover. While liquor before beer may slow the spike in blood alcohol levels, it doesn't guarantee a hangover-free experience. Responsible drinking and moderation are crucial to reducing the risk and severity of hangovers.

Drinking water and eating food can help prevent hangovers

There are many theories about how to avoid a hangover, including the popular saying, "beer before liquor, never been sicker; liquor before beer, you're in the clear." This suggests that drinking beer before liquor will make a hangover worse, but there is little scientific evidence to support this. The amount of alcohol consumed is a more significant factor in determining the severity of a hangover.

That being said, drinking water and eating food can help to prevent or alleviate hangovers. Alcohol is a diuretic, causing frequent urination, and can lead to dehydration, which is a contributing factor to hangover symptoms such as thirst, headache, fatigue, and dry mouth. Drinking water can help to reduce these symptoms. It is recommended to drink a glass of water between alcoholic drinks and before bed.

Eating food can also help prevent hangovers, as drinking on an empty stomach causes alcohol to be absorbed more quickly, leading to higher blood alcohol levels. Eating before and after drinking can help to slow the absorption of alcohol and maintain blood sugar levels, reducing the risk and severity of a hangover.

While drinking water and eating food can be helpful, the most effective way to prevent a hangover is to drink in moderation or abstain from alcohol altogether.

Frequently asked questions