Non-Alcoholic Beer: The Ultimate Recovery Drink?

Non-alcoholic beer has gained popularity as a recovery drink for athletes and a substitute for those in recovery from alcohol addiction. It is designed to taste and look like traditional beer but contains minimal or no alcohol. The question of whether consuming non-alcoholic beer is considered breaking sobriety is subjective and depends on individual circumstances. While it can be a viable alternative for those who want to enjoy the taste and social experience of drinking beer without the intoxicating effects, it may still trigger cravings or emotional associations for individuals with a history of alcohol addiction.

Non-alcoholic beer is isotonic, meaning it can be an effective recovery drink for athletes

Non-alcoholic beer has gained popularity as a recovery drink for athletes in recent years. This is partly due to its isotonic nature, which means it can aid rehydration after exercise.

The rise of non-alcoholic beer in sport

German consumption of non-alcoholic beer grew by 43% between 2011 and 2016, and this is not just because Germans drink a lot of beer. Non-alcoholic beer is extremely popular among athletes in Germany because it has been identified as an effective recovery drink.

The Bavarian brewery Erdinger, for example, markets its non-alcoholic wheat beer as "the isotonic thirst quencher for athletes". Regular alcoholic beer, on the other hand, is highly hypertonic and therefore less effective as a recovery drink.

At the 2017 Berlin Marathon, 30,000 bottles of Erdinger were handed out to runners, and even the podium finishers were presented with a pitcher of the drink.

Another German brand, Krombacher 0%, became a partner of the Association of German Cyclists (BDR) in 2018 and supplied around 3,500 litres of non-alcoholic beer to the athletes' village at the Pyeongchang Winter Olympic Games that year.

The appeal of non-alcoholic beer for athletes

Triathlon Coach Mario Schmidt-Wendling attributes the popularity of non-alcoholic beer among athletes partly to its lack of sweetness. After several hours of consuming sweet, sugary drinks during a race, athletes often prefer something less sweet, and non-alcoholic beer can offer a welcome alternative.

The health benefits of non-alcoholic beer

Beer's most oft-cited health benefits include its high concentration of polyphenols, which are plant-derived compounds with unique molecular structures that can regulate genes that control inflammation and provide antiviral properties.

In 2011, researchers from Appalachian State University and the University of Munich investigated the effects of non-alcoholic beer on athletes. They found that when marathon runners were instructed to drink 1.5 litres of non-alcoholic beer a day, their risk of upper respiratory infection was reduced, and the activity of white blood cells, an indicator of inflammation, was lowered by 20%.

Non-alcoholic beer was shown to limit athletes' risk of illness, which is often cited as a common reason for inconsistency in training.

The rehydration benefits of non-alcoholic beer

Regular alcoholic beer is a diuretic, which means it causes athletes to urinate more and can lead to dehydration. However, non-alcoholic beer can actually aid rehydration.

In 2013, Dr Ben Desbrow of Griffith University in South East Queensland formulated a reduced-alcohol beer with added electrolytes and tested its effect on fluid balance. He found that this "light" beer rehydrated participants better than regular beer.

The addition of sodium to a drink helps the body retain more fluid, and the diuretic effect of regular beer means that beverages with lower alcohol content or higher sodium content can lead to better rehydration. Helping the body correct fluid and sodium losses after sweating is key to aiding recovery.

The verdict: Is non-alcoholic beer an effective recovery drink?

While non-alcoholic beer has been shown to have some benefits for recovery, the current research lacks evidence that it outperforms traditional post-exercise electrolyte sports drinks.

However, in social situations, non-alcoholic beer can be a good alternative for athletes who want to join in without compromising their recovery. It provides a sense of normalcy and inclusivity, enabling individuals to enjoy the taste and experience of beer while maintaining their commitment to sobriety.

It contains polyphenols, which are credited with health-promoting properties such as supporting the immune system and reducing inflammation

Beer contains polyphenols, micronutrients that naturally occur in plants and are credited with health-promoting properties. These benefits in relation to athletic performance include supporting the immune system and reducing inflammation.

Polyphenols are organic compounds derived from plants that often have defining tastes. For example, the spice of peppers comes from the polyphenol Capsaicin, while the pungent heft of oregano or the smoke in scotch is from the polyphenol Carvacrol. Polyphenols have been found to lower inflammation and reduce the risk of sickness. David Nieman of Appalachian State University says that polyphenols " [have] a very unique molecular structure that can actually regulate the genes that control inflammation," in addition to having general antiviral properties.

In a study led by Nieman and Johannes Scherr of the University of Munich, the effects of beer on athletes were investigated. Beer contains around 50 polyphenols, and intense physical activity can compromise athletes' immune activity. When marathon runners were instructed to drink 1.5 litres of non-alcoholic beer a day, their risk of upper respiratory infection was reduced. The activity of white blood cells, a good indicator of inflammation, was lowered by 20%. The study found that when athletes consistently drank non-alcoholic beer, markers of inflammation like white blood cell activity were down by 20% and there was a lower frequency of infection (along with milder symptoms).

Non-alcoholic beer has been shown to limit athletes' risk of illness, which is often cited as one of the more common reasons for inconsistency in training. The Bavarian brewery Erdinger calls its non-alcoholic wheat beer "the isotonic thirst quencher for athletes". Regular alcoholic beer is highly hypertonic, so it is not effective as a recovery drink.

In addition to the health benefits of polyphenols, non-alcoholic beer can also aid in rehydration. In a 2013 study, Dr. Ben Desbrow of Griffith University in South East Queensland found that having athletes drink a reduced-alcohol beer with added electrolytes allowed them to retain more fluids. This is important for recovery, as helping the body correct its fluid and sodium losses after sweating is key to aiding quality recovery.

Non-alcoholic beer can be a good recovery drink for social situations, helping individuals in recovery feel included without feeling pressured to consume alcohol

Non-alcoholic beer has gained popularity as a recovery drink for social situations, helping individuals in recovery feel included without feeling pressured to consume alcohol.

The Benefits of Non-Alcoholic Beer for Social Situations

The social aspect of drinking beer is just as important as the taste. In many cultures, alcohol consumption is a social activity, and non-alcoholic beer can help individuals in recovery navigate social situations where alcohol is present without feeling left out or isolated. It provides a sense of normalcy and inclusivity, enabling people to enjoy the taste and experience of beer while maintaining their commitment to sobriety.

The Health Benefits of Non-Alcoholic Beer

Non-alcoholic beer has also been touted for its health benefits, particularly for athletes. Studies have shown that non-alcoholic beer can reduce the risk of upper respiratory infection and lower inflammation in athletes, thanks to its high concentration of polyphenols, which are plant-derived compounds with anti-inflammatory and antiviral properties. Additionally, non-alcoholic beer can aid in rehydration, as it does not have the same diuretic effects as regular alcoholic beer.

The Psychological Implications of Non-Alcoholic Beer

However, it is important to consider the psychological implications of consuming non-alcoholic beer for individuals in recovery. The act of consuming a beverage that resembles beer can trigger a placebo response, leading to sensations or emotions associated with alcohol consumption. For some, this may be positive, but for others, it may increase the risk of relapse. It is crucial for individuals in recovery to assess their own triggers and consult with healthcare professionals or support groups to determine if non-alcoholic beer is suitable for their journey.

Individual Factors and Perspectives

Ultimately, the decision to consume non-alcoholic beer during recovery is a personal one and depends on individual circumstances and preferences. Some individuals in recovery may find that non-alcoholic beer helps them feel included during social occasions, while others may prefer to avoid any reminder of their past struggles with alcohol addiction. It is important to know your triggers and stay away from high-risk situations to maintain sobriety.

However, it may also trigger cravings or emotional associations for those with a history of alcohol addiction

For individuals with a history of alcohol addiction, non-alcoholic beer may trigger cravings and emotional associations with past drinking experiences. The taste, smell, and appearance of non-alcoholic beer can evoke powerful memories of the good times associated with drinking, a phenomenon known as euphoric recall. This can be dangerous for those in recovery, as it may lead them to romanticise alcohol and forget the negative consequences of their active addiction.

The act of consuming a beverage that resembles beer can also trigger a placebo response, leading to sensations and emotions similar to those associated with alcohol consumption. This can be detrimental to the recovery process, as it may blur the lines between non-alcoholic and alcoholic drinks, increasing the risk of relapse. Additionally, the very presence of non-alcoholic beer can serve as a reminder of the real thing, triggering cravings and making it challenging for individuals to maintain their sobriety.

While non-alcoholic beer can be a helpful tool for navigating social situations where alcohol is present, it is crucial for those with a history of alcohol addiction to assess their physical and emotional triggers. Consulting with healthcare professionals or support groups is essential to determine if non-alcoholic beer is a suitable choice for their recovery journey. It is important to remember that the decision to consume non-alcoholic beer during recovery is highly individualised and depends on one's unique circumstances, motivations, and triggers.

Some individuals in recovery may find that non-alcoholic beer helps them feel included in social gatherings without compromising their sobriety. However, others may view any beverage resembling alcohol as a potential trigger and prefer to avoid it altogether. Ultimately, the decision to consume non-alcoholic beer during recovery should be based on one's own assessment of risks and rewards, with the understanding that the rewards of doing so must outweigh the risk to one's sobriety.

Opinions vary among sobriety coaches and recovering alcoholics, with some advocating for complete abstinence and others recognising it as a harm-reduction tool

Sobriety coaches, who provide guidance and support for individuals recovering from alcohol addiction, have differing views on non-alcoholic beer. Some coaches recommend total abstinence from any beverage resembling alcohol, as it may blur the lines or increase the risk of relapse. On the other hand, some coaches adopt a more moderate stance, acknowledging non-alcoholic beer as a potential harm-reduction tool when consumed responsibly.

Recovering alcoholics also hold diverse viewpoints. Some individuals find that drinking non-alcoholic beer helps them feel included in social situations without jeopardising their sobriety. They can participate in social gatherings without feeling left out or pressured to consume alcoholic drinks. However, others prefer to avoid any beverage that reminds them of their past struggles with alcohol addiction. The taste and smell of non-alcoholic beer may be enough to trigger a relapse for some individuals, bringing back memories of their drinking days.

The decision to consume non-alcoholic beer during recovery is a personal one, and individuals must consider their unique circumstances, triggers, and motivations. Evaluating personal goals, consulting healthcare professionals, and seeking support from the recovery community can help individuals make informed choices that support their long-term well-being.

While non-alcoholic beer can be a helpful tool for some, it is crucial to recognise that it may still contain trace amounts of alcohol and trigger cravings or emotional associations for those with a history of alcohol addiction. Ultimately, the decision to include non-alcoholic beer in one's recovery journey depends on individual circumstances and should be made with careful consideration and professional guidance.

Frequently asked questions