Nonalcoholic Beer: Healthy Or Just Hype?

Non-alcoholic beer is a growing market, with many people turning to it as a healthier alternative to alcoholic beer. But how healthy is it?

Non-alcoholic beer is a type of beer that has had its alcohol content reduced to a very low level, usually less than 0.5%. It is often produced by removing the alcohol from regular alcoholic beer, through filtration or distillation. This can impact the flavour, and brewers have been working to develop new methods that preserve the taste.

Non-alcoholic beer is often lower in calories than regular beer, but it may contain more sugar and carbohydrates. It also contains the same vitamins and minerals as regular beer, including B vitamins, potassium, magnesium and phosphorus.

There are some health benefits associated with non-alcoholic beer. It has been found to reduce inflammation and incidence of respiratory tract illness, and it can be a good source of hydration and electrolytes. However, there are also some risks to consider, particularly for pregnant people and those with alcohol use problems.

Non-alcoholic beer and health risks

Non-alcoholic beer is often marketed as a healthier alternative to regular beer, and it can be, but it's important to be aware of the potential health risks associated with non-alcoholic beer consumption.

May Still Contain Alcohol

Non-alcoholic beers are allowed to contain a small amount of alcohol. In the US, for example, non-alcoholic beers can contain up to 0.5% alcohol by volume (ABV). However, research suggests that many non-alcoholic beers contain more alcohol than their labels indicate. One study found that 30% of non-alcoholic beers tested had more alcohol than their labels stated, with some containing up to 1.8% ABV. This can be a problem for those with alcohol use problems, those who are pregnant, or those trying to become pregnant.

Trigger for Alcoholics

The smell and taste of non-alcoholic beer is very similar to regular beer, and this can trigger cravings and a subsequent relapse among people with alcohol use disorder. In one study, scientists found that the smell of beer may be enough to trigger a relapse in certain people with alcohol use disorder.

Less Nutritional Value

Non-alcoholic beers offer very little nutritional value and are mostly carbohydrates. While they tend to be lower in calories than regular beers, they are not calorie- or carb-free.

Not a Good Source of Hydration or Electrolytes

Some proponents of non-alcoholic beer claim that it can be used by athletes to hydrate and replace electrolytes. However, there are better and more affordable ways to achieve this, such as drinking chocolate milk, which has carbs and protein to aid in recovery. Non-alcoholic beer also can't replace electrolytes like sodium, which are lost through sweating.

Nutritional content of non-alcoholic beer

Non-alcoholic beer is often presented as a healthier alternative to alcoholic beer, and while it does have fewer calories, it is not necessarily nutritious. Non-alcoholic beers are similar to regular beers in terms of their calorie, protein, and fat content, but differ significantly in their carbohydrate and alcohol content.

Non-alcoholic beers tend to be lower in calories than regular beers, but they are not calorie-free. For example, a can of Budweiser has 146 calories, while a non-alcoholic beer like Athletic Brewing's Upside Dawn has only 50 calories. However, some non-alcoholic beers can have up to 98 calories, which is comparable to regular beer.

The main difference in nutritional content between non-alcoholic and regular beer is in their carbohydrate content. Non-alcoholic beers contain more than twice the amount of carbohydrates as regular beers, mostly in the form of sugar. This added sugar helps to improve the taste of the beer after the alcohol has been removed.

Non-alcoholic beers also contain small amounts of several vitamins and minerals, including phosphorus, magnesium, and B vitamins. A glass of non-alcoholic beer contains about 8% of the niacin you need for the day, as well as 5% of your riboflavin requirement, which helps your body break down food.

While non-alcoholic beer may be a healthier alternative to regular beer in some ways, it is important to note that it still contains alcohol. In the US, non-alcoholic beers can legally contain up to 0.5% alcohol by volume (ABV), and some brands offer options with 0% ABV. However, research suggests that many non-alcoholic beers contain more alcohol than their labels indicate, with some found to have up to 1.8% ABV. Therefore, it is important to read labels carefully, especially for those who need to abstain from alcohol completely, such as pregnant women.

Non-alcoholic beer and pregnancy

Non-alcoholic beer is often marketed as a safe alternative for pregnant women. However, it is important to critically evaluate its safety. While non-alcoholic beer typically contains less than 0.5% ABV, it is worth noting that even this small amount of alcohol can be present in the final product. Furthermore, studies have shown that beverages labelled as non-alcoholic or alcohol-free can still contain trace amounts of alcohol, and in some cases, higher amounts than declared on the label.

The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) advise pregnant women to completely abstain from alcohol consumption due to the serious risks associated with drinking during pregnancy. These risks include an increased chance of miscarriage, stillbirth, premature birth, and Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders (FASD), which can cause physical, mental, and behavioural impairments in children exposed to alcohol in the womb.

Given these risks, it is generally recommended to avoid non-alcoholic beer during pregnancy altogether. Instead, pregnant women can opt for alcohol-free mocktails or drinks labelled as "alcohol-free", which by law must contain no detectable alcohol.

While the exact effects of consuming non-alcoholic beer during pregnancy are not well-studied, it is important to prioritise the health and well-being of the baby. Even trace amounts of alcohol can pose risks, and there is currently no known safe threshold for alcohol intake during pregnancy. Therefore, complete abstinence from alcohol is recommended by most clinicians.

Additionally, drinking non-alcoholic beer during pregnancy may have implications for the health of the expectant mother as well. A study conducted in 2018 found that pregnant individuals who consumed more than 12.5 alcoholic drinks per week had a higher likelihood of experiencing pregnancy-related high blood pressure disorders, which can lead to long-term and life-threatening complications for both the baby and the parent.

In conclusion, while non-alcoholic beer may seem like a tempting option during pregnancy, it is best to avoid it altogether due to the potential risks associated with even trace amounts of alcohol. Instead, pregnant women should explore alternative beverage options and seek support from healthcare professionals and fellow expectant mothers.

Non-alcoholic beer and addiction recovery

Non-alcoholic beer has gained popularity as a viable alternative for those in recovery from alcohol addiction. It can be a valuable option for people looking to moderate their alcohol intake or cut back for dietary or mental health reasons. However, it's important to consider the potential risks, especially for those in addiction recovery.

Non-alcoholic beer is typically defined as having an alcohol content of 0.5% or less by volume (ABV). While this is significantly lower than regular beer, it's important to note that non-alcoholic beers still contain trace amounts of alcohol, and some may have higher levels than indicated on their labels. This can be a concern for people in recovery who need to avoid alcohol completely. Additionally, the smell and taste of non-alcoholic beer may trigger cravings and emotional associations related to past drinking experiences, potentially leading to a relapse.

The decision to consume non-alcoholic beer during addiction recovery is a personal one. Some individuals in recovery may find that it helps them feel included in social situations without compromising their sobriety. On the other hand, others may view it as a trigger that could jeopardize their hard-earned progress. It's crucial for those in recovery to assess their own triggers and make informed choices accordingly. Seeking guidance from healthcare professionals or support groups can aid in making a decision that aligns with their recovery goals.

While non-alcoholic beer can be a helpful tool for some, it's not a substitute for addressing the underlying issues that led to addiction. A comprehensive approach to recovery should include lifestyle changes, social support, and addressing triggers to build a foundation for long-term sobriety.

Non-alcoholic beer and hydration

Non-alcoholic beer has been marketed as a healthier alternative to regular beer, and its consumption has been associated with various health benefits, including improved hydration. However, it is essential to examine the evidence and potential risks related to non-alcoholic beer to understand its impact on hydration fully.

The Rise of Non-Alcoholic Beer

The non-alcoholic beer movement has gained traction in recent years, with improvements in taste and a growing craft beer scene contributing to its popularity. Non-alcoholic beers now make up about 1% of the beer industry, and they are increasingly available at local craft breweries.

Health Benefits of Non-Alcoholic Beer

Non-alcoholic beer is often viewed as a healthier option because it contains fewer calories and carbohydrates than regular beer. Alcohol is considered a toxin, so reducing alcohol intake by choosing non-alcoholic alternatives can have health benefits. Additionally, non-alcoholic beer may help improve sleep and reduce alcohol-related sleep issues.

Hydration and Non-Alcoholic Beer

One of the key benefits of non-alcoholic beer is its potential to aid hydration. German beer companies have historically marketed non-alcoholic beer as the "car driver's beer," positioning it as a responsible alternative to regular beer. In recent years, non-alcoholic beers have been specifically marketed to athletes as recovery drinks.

Several studies have supported the use of non-alcoholic beer as a recovery beverage for athletes. For example, a study led by Johannes Scherr and David Nieman, called "Be-MaGIC" (Beer, Marathons, Genetics, Inflammation, and the Cardiovascular system), found that when marathon runners drank up to 1.5 litres of non-alcoholic beer a day, their risk of upper respiratory infection was reduced, and markers of inflammation were lowered by 20%.

Another study by Dr. Ben Desbrow from Griffith University in South East Queensland found that a reduced-alcohol beer with added electrolytes helped athletes retain more fluids compared to regular beer. This study highlighted the importance of correcting fluid and sodium losses after sweating for effective recovery.

Considerations and Potential Risks

While non-alcoholic beer has been associated with improved hydration and recovery in athletes, it is important to note that it still contains small amounts of alcohol. By law, non-alcoholic beers can contain up to 0.5% alcohol by volume (ABV). Therefore, pregnant individuals and those with a history of alcohol use problems should avoid consuming non-alcoholic beers due to the potential risks associated with even small amounts of alcohol.

Additionally, the smell of non-alcoholic beer may serve as a relapse trigger for individuals recovering from alcohol use disorder. It is crucial to consider individual comfort levels and potential triggers when deciding whether to consume non-alcoholic beer.

Non-alcoholic beer has been linked to improved hydration and recovery in athletes, but it is not without potential risks. While it can be a healthier alternative to regular beer, it is important to remember that optimal recovery may still be achieved by skipping the alcohol altogether and opting for traditional post-exercise electrolyte sports drinks.

Frequently asked questions