Beer Bottle Or Glass: Which Is The Best?

There are many different opinions on whether you should drink beer out of a bottle or pour it into a glass. Some people believe that drinking beer straight from a bottle or can negatively impacts the taste and aroma of the beer. On the other hand, some people believe that there is no difference in taste and that it is all in people's heads.

Should you drink beer out of the bottle?

Beer tastes better from a bottle than a can, according to research

There is a common belief that beer tastes better from a bottle than from a can. Research has been carried out to test this theory, with varying results.

A study published in the journal Beverages set out to answer the question once and for all. The study consisted of three parts: a questionnaire to determine demographics and drinking habits, a taste test, and a blind taste test. 62 people participated in the questionnaire, and 151 in the main taste test. Participants were served the same beer from either a bottle or a can, which was then poured into a plastic cup to control for factors such as headspace and packaging weight. The results of this test showed that participants rated the beer poured from the bottle as tasting better than the beer poured from the can.

However, when a blind taste test was carried out, the results were different. 29 people participated in this phase, and were served two glasses of beer: one poured from a bottle, and one from a can. The participants were not allowed to see the researchers pour the beers, and were told nothing about them. The results of this test showed that there was no significant preference for bottled or canned beer. Nearly 45% of participants rated the canned beer better, while 41% preferred the bottled beer.

The researchers concluded that people's preference for bottled beer is likely psychological. When participants had no knowledge of the beer or its original packaging, the preference for bottled beer disappeared. This suggests that there may be some stigma associated with canned beer that influences consumers' preferences.

It's worth noting that the type of beer may also play a role in how it is perceived when served from a bottle or a can. Researchers from ACS Food Science & Technology found that amber ale stayed fresher in bottles, while the container choice made less of a difference for India Pale Ale (IPA). They attributed this to the higher concentration of polyphenols from hops in IPA, which prevent oxidation and bind to amino acids, keeping the beer fresher.

So, while some research suggests that people prefer the taste of bottled beer, it may be due to psychological factors and preconceived notions about the quality of canned beer. Ultimately, when the beer is poured into a glass, it will taste the same regardless of whether it originally came from a bottle or a can.

Aroma is key to flavour, and drinking from the bottle may affect this

Aroma is key to flavour, and drinking beer from the bottle may affect this. When you drink straight from the bottle, you are essentially cutting off your sense of smell, which changes the way the beer tastes. Aroma plays a huge role in how we perceive flavour. For example, when you have a head cold, food tastes bland because you can't smell it.

On the other hand, pouring beer into a glass activates the carbonation and creates a foamy head. Each time one of those tiny bubbles pops, it releases a burst of aroma. These aromas mix with the tastes on your tongue, giving you a full-on flavour experience.

The way you pour your beer into a glass is also important. Firstly, select a clean glass, and give it a quick rinse with cold water to make it slippery, reducing friction when the beer is poured. Then, tilt the glass at a 45-degree angle and pour the beer slowly so that the liquid lands in the middle of the glass. Once you've poured about half of the beer, straighten the glass and pour the rest directly into the centre. This technique will give you the optimal amount of foam, which is important because a good head can help release a beer's aromatics.

Research suggests that most people prefer the taste of beer from a bottle compared to a can, but when the beer is poured into a glass, it all tastes the same. So, if you want to get the best flavour experience, it's best to pour your beer into a glass.

Drinking from a glass allows you to see the beer's colour, which indicates maltiness

There are many reasons why drinking beer from a glass is preferable to drinking it from the bottle. One of the most important reasons is that it allows you to see the colour of the beer, which can indicate its maltiness.

The colour of beer is one of the first things you notice when you pour it into a glass. Beer can range in colour from pale straw to deep amber or even black, and this colour comes primarily from the malt that is used in the brewing process. Lighter beers, such as pilsners and pale ales, tend to use lighter malts, while darker beers, such as stouts and porters, use darker malts. So, by looking at the colour of the beer, you can get an idea of the type of malt that was used and, therefore, the overall maltiness of the beer.

Of course, there are other factors that can affect the colour of beer, such as the type of hops used or the addition of roasted barley or other grains. However, malt is usually the primary ingredient that determines the colour. So, if you're drinking a beer that you're unfamiliar with, pouring it into a glass can give you a good indication of what to expect in terms of maltiness.

In addition, drinking beer from a glass allows you to appreciate the carbonation and the head, which can also affect the flavour and aroma of the beer. A good head can help to release the beer's aromatics, enhancing the overall flavour experience. So, if you want to get the most out of your beer, it's definitely worth pouring it into a glass and taking the time to appreciate its colour, carbonation, head, and aroma before taking that first sip.

By pouring your beer into a glass, you're not only treating yourself to a more visually appealing drink, but you're also engaging more of your senses, which can enhance the overall tasting experience. So, the next time you pop open a cold one, consider pouring it into a glass and savouring all the complex flavours and aromas that the brewer intended.

The foam created by pouring into a glass reduces beer bloat

There are several reasons why drinking beer from a glass is preferable to drinking it straight from the bottle. One of the most important reasons is that it reduces beer bloat.

When beer is poured into a glass, the carbonation is activated, creating a foamy head. This foam is crucial in releasing the aroma of the beer, enhancing the overall flavour experience. However, it also serves a practical purpose in reducing beer bloat.

If beer is poured without allowing any foam to form, the carbon dioxide (CO2) remains dissolved in the liquid. Once you drink the beer and consume food, the CO2 is released, causing an explosion of bubbles and resulting in beer bloat.

To avoid this uncomfortable situation, it is essential to embrace the foam when pouring your beer. Start by tilting your glass slightly, then return it to an upright position as the beer settles, allowing the top to foam. This way, the CO2 is released into the glass instead of your stomach, preventing that bloated feeling.

So, the next time you're tempted to swig straight from the bottle, remember that pouring your beer into a glass with a nice, foamy head not only enhances the flavour but also helps you avoid the unpleasant side effect of beer bloat.

The way a beer is poured into a glass can affect its carbonation

The angle at which the beer is poured also affects carbonation. Starting with the glass at a 45-degree angle and pouring the beer onto the side reduces excessive foam formation. As the glass fills up, it is gradually straightened to an upright position.

The temperature of the glass is another factor influencing carbonation. A frosted glass can cause a loss of carbonation, resulting in excessive foaming. Conversely, a chilled glass can help maintain the optimal drinking temperature for a longer period, allowing for a slower release of carbonation.

Additionally, the shape and size of the glass can impact carbonation levels. Different beer styles are served in specific glassware designed to optimise carbonation, aroma, and appearance. For example, highly carbonated wheat beers are typically served in long, narrow glasses, while stouts are served in wider, shorter glasses.

The act of pouring beer into a glass also affects the release of volatile compounds, enhancing the beer's aroma and flavour profile. Therefore, the way a beer is poured into a glass significantly impacts its carbonation, influencing the overall sensory experience.

Frequently asked questions