Peanut Butter Beer: Where To Buy This Unique Brew

Peanut butter beer is a unique blend of creamy, salty, and sweet flavours. Several breweries have experimented with this combination, resulting in a range of peanut butter beers available in the market. Some popular options include the Belching Beaver Brewery's Peanut Butter Milk Stout, the Back Forty Beer Company's Peanut Butter Porter, and the Catawba Brewing Co.'s Peanut Butter Jelly Time. These beers offer a nostalgic taste of childhood favourites, such as peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, with a unique adult twist. With a growing trend of adding unconventional flavours to beer, peanut butter beers are definitely worth trying for those seeking a new beer experience.

Peanut butter beer brands

Peanut butter beers are growing in popularity, with a thirty-five per cent increase in the number of peanut butter beers on the Tavour app since 2019. The following is a list of breweries that have experimented with peanut butter beers:

DuClaw Brewing Co.

DuClaw Brewing Co. released Sweet Baby Jesus!, a chocolate peanut butter porter, in 2012. The beer was initially a one-off winter seasonal release but became an instant hit. Sweet Baby Jesus! is now one of the most popular peanut butter beers on the market.

Trillium Brewing Co.

Trillium Brewing Co. offers Peanut Butter PM Dawn, a coffee stout that combines coffee, chocolate, and peanut butter. It's like a liquid, caffeinated version of a Reese's Cup.

Liquid Mechanics Brewing

Liquid Mechanics Brewing, based in Colorado, offers a Peanut Butter Porter that combines the sweetness of peanut butter with the slight smokiness of a porter. The result is a silky smooth brew that tastes like a classic peanut butter cup.

Belching Beaver Brewing

Belching Beaver Brewing, based in California, offers a Peanut Butter Milk Stout that has notes of cinnamon and coffee to complement the peanut butter flavour. They also have a Mexican Chocolate Peanut Butter Stout, which is their highest-rated beer.

Great Notion Brewing

Great Notion Brewing ages its Imperial Milk Stout on peanut butter and chocolate to create Peanut Brother. The result is a confectionary treat with bold flavours of peanut butter and chocolate.

Blue Moon Brewing Company

Blue Moon Brewing Company offers a Peanut Butter Ale, a Belgian-style wheat ale with creamy peanut butter, honey, and molasses.

Dangerous Man Brewing

Dangerous Man Brewing, based in Minneapolis, offers a Peanut Butter Porter with flavours of coffee and peanut butter. The brewery recommends pairing the beer with Thai food, curry dishes, or desserts.

Other Notable Peanut Butter Beers:

• Peanut Butter Bandit by Junkyard Brewing Company: an award-winning stout that tastes like a peanut butter cup.
• Peanut Butter Jelly Imperial Stout by Untitled Art: a sideways pivot from the pastry stout trend, inspired by the classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich.
• Imperial Peanut Butter Cup by Ingenious Brewing Company: a fun imperial milk stout that pays homage to the king of candy, the peanut butter cup.

Where to buy online

Where to Buy Peanut Butter Beer Online

Peanut butter beer is a unique and surprising combination that has gained a following among beer enthusiasts. The creamy, nutty flavour of peanut butter blends surprisingly well with the bitterness of beer, creating a range of interesting and delicious brews. If you're eager to try this unusual combination, here are some online sources where you can purchase peanut butter beer:

• Belching Beaver Brewery: This award-winning craft beer company offers a range of unique beers, including their popular Peanut Butter Milk Stout. With a smooth, creamy texture and a hint of sweetness, it's no wonder this beer is a favourite among fans of peanut butter beer. You can find their products online at their website, belchingbeaver.com, or through retailers such as Safeway.
• Liquid Mechanics Brewing: Based in Colorado, Liquid Mechanics is known for its Peanut Butter Porter, which combines the sweetness of peanut butter with the slight smokiness of a porter. You can purchase their beers online through their website, liquidmechanicsbrewing.com, or via other online beer retailers.
• Dangerous Man Brewing: Hailing from Minneapolis, Minnesota, Dangerous Man Brewing offers a Peanut Butter Porter with subtle coffee flavours. Their beers can be purchased online through their website, dangerousmanbrewing.com, where you can explore their unique offerings and place orders.
• Catawba Brewing Co: Catawba Brewing Co's Peanut Butter Jelly Time beer is a fun recreation of your favourite childhood sandwich. This specialty brown ale is aged for weeks on raspberries and roasted peanuts, creating a unique and nostalgic flavour. You can find their beers online at catawbabrewing.com or through other online beer retailers.
• Go to Liquor Store: This online liquor store, gotoliquorstore.com, offers a range of peanut butter-flavoured beers. By entering your address, you can browse and discover the availability and pricing of peanut butter beers in your area.
• Craft Beer: Craftbeer.com is a great resource for discovering unique beers, including peanut butter beers. While they don't sell beers directly, they provide informative articles and lists, such as their feature on "10 Peanut Butter Beers You'll Crave." This can be a helpful guide to finding and sourcing peanut butter beers online from various breweries across the United States.

In-store locations

Back Forty Beer Company, Gadsden, Alabama

The Peanut Butter Porter from Back Forty Beer Company is described as "comfort food in a can". It is made with all-natural peanut butter extract and crushed peanuts.

Catawba Brewing Co., Asheville, North Carolina

Catawba Brewing Co.'s Peanut Butter Jelly Time recreates the flavour of your favourite childhood sandwich. This brown ale is aged for weeks on raspberries and roasted peanuts.

Witch's Hat Brewing, South Lyons, Michigan

Witch's Hat Brewing offers a heavy hitter with its Bourbon Barrel Traxxx Night Fury, which has an ABV of 13.5%. This imperial stout is aged on peanut butter, coconut, vanilla beans, cacao nibs, and bourbon.

Dangerous Man Brewing, Minneapolis, Minnesota

Dangerous Man Brewing's Peanut Butter Porter is perfect for those who enjoy a hint of coffee with their peanut butter. It is recommended to pair this beer with Thai food, curry dishes, or desserts.

Liquid Mechanics, Lafayette, Colorado

Liquid Mechanics' Peanut Butter Porter combines the sweetness of peanut butter with the slight smokiness of a porter. This silky smooth brew evokes the flavour of a classic peanut butter cup.

Belching Beaver Brewery, San Diego, California

Belching Beaver Brewery offers a Mexican Chocolate Peanut Butter Stout that is the brewery's highest-rated beer. This stout features flavours of cinnamon and coffee that complement the peanut butter.

How to make it at home

Making peanut butter beer at home is a complex process that requires careful preparation and the right ingredients. Here is a step-by-step guide on how to make it:

Ingredients

Firstly, gather your ingredients. For a peanut butter porter, you will need:

• Organic peanut butter or powdered peanut butter
• Maris Otter base
• Munich, Chocolate and Wheat malts
• Hops (e.g. Fuggles)
• Yeast (e.g. SafAle English Ale)
• Water

De-oiling Peanut Butter

The high fat content in peanut butter can cause issues when mixing with water or beer. To avoid this, you can de-oil your peanut butter. This involves a lengthy process of separating and removing the oil from organic peanut butter. Place the peanut butter in a container and wait for the oil to pool on the surface, then tip it away. Repeat this process over several weeks until most of the oil is removed. Alternatively, you can use powdered peanut butter, which has a much lower fat content.

Brewing Process

Start by heating 6 gallons of water to 161 degrees Fahrenheit. Add your grain bag and grains, including the Maris Otter base, Munich, Chocolate and Wheat malts. You can also add chocolate peanut butter cereal at this stage for extra flavour. Mash the grains at 154 degrees Fahrenheit for 45 minutes to give the beer sweetness and body. Remove the grain bag, squeezing out as much wort as possible. Heat another gallon of water to 170 degrees Fahrenheit to sparge or rinse the grains.

Boiling and Fermentation

Bring the wort to a boil for 30 minutes. At the start of the boil, add your chosen hops, such as Fuggles, for bitterness. Towards the end of the boil, add your peanut butter. For a 9-litre batch, use around 400 grams of powdered peanut butter. Be careful when adding, as it can cause clumping and boil-overs. Turn off the heat and chill the wort to 67 degrees Fahrenheit. Transfer the wort to a fermentor. Add your yeast, such as SafAle US-05, and let it ferment in a cool, dark place for about a week.

Final Steps

After fermentation, check the gravity to determine the ABV. You may also need to burst carbonate the beer and adjust the pressure to the serving pressure. Your peanut butter beer is now ready to be served and enjoyed!

Please note that this is a general guide, and you can adjust the ingredients and process to suit your preferences and equipment. Always remember to let potential drinkers know if your beer contains peanuts to avoid any allergic reactions.

Beer and peanut butter pairings

Peanut butter and beer is a classic combination. The saltiness of the peanut butter keeps you thirsty, while the carbonation in beer helps to clean the oil off your tongue. Here are some specific beer and peanut butter pairings to try:

Imperial Stout and White Chocolate-Infused Peanut Butter

The sweet and dark imperial stout Black Ops, paired with a white chocolate-infused peanut butter, creates a lingering impression of shortbread cookies or sweet biscotti with a shot of espresso.

Black Chocolate Stout and Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter

This pairing tastes like a slice of grown-up cake dusted with bitter baking chocolate.

Belgian Ale and Maple Peanut Butter

Brooklyn's Local #2 strong Belgian ale with PB & Co.'s Mighty Maple peanut butter is a flavour combination reminiscent of waffles with syrup and coffee.

Imperial IPA and Spicy Peanut Butter

The bitterness of an imperial IPA, paired with its carbonation, helps to clean the spice off your tongue. This combination is perfect for those who enjoy Thai or Indian food.

Peanut Butter Porter and Thai Food, Curry Dishes, or Desserts

Liquid Mechanics' Peanut Butter Porter combines the sweetness of peanut butter with the slight smokiness of the porter. It goes well with Thai food, curry dishes, and desserts.

Peanut Butter Korova Milk Porter and Chocolate

The Gnarly Barley Brewing Co. takes its base beer, Korova Milk Porter, and adds a silky peanut butter touch to create the Peanut Butter Korova Milk Porter. This porter is full of chocolate and peanut butter notes and has a smooth finish.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Stout and Chocolate

Spring House Beer's Chocolate Peanut Butter Stout is a super-intense chocolate flavour that comes from two types of chocolate malt and raw cacao nibs, which are then aged on cacao nibs. This stout is a great pairing with chocolate.

Mexican Chocolate Peanut Butter Stout and Cinnamon or Coffee

Belching Beaver Brewery's Mexican Chocolate Peanut Butter Stout has flavours of cinnamon and coffee that complement the peanut butter flavour.

Frequently asked questions