Seltzers Vs Beer: Which Is The Healthier Choice?

Hard seltzers are often marketed as a healthier alternative to beer, but are they really? Hard seltzers are alcoholic beverages typically made by fermenting cane sugar or adding alcohol to carbonated water. They have gained popularity due to their low-calorie and low-carb content, with an average of 100 calories and 2 grams of carbohydrates per 12-ounce can. Beer, on the other hand, contains approximately 150 calories and 15-30 grams of carbohydrates in a similar-sized serving. While hard seltzers may be lower in calories and carbs, they are still alcoholic drinks, and excessive alcohol consumption is linked to various health risks. Additionally, the refreshing and light nature of hard seltzers can make it easier to overconsume, leading to potential health issues. Ultimately, when it comes to alcohol, moderation is key, regardless of the specific beverage.

Calories: Hard seltzers have fewer calories than beer

Hard seltzers are often marketed as healthier alternatives to beer, but are they really? Well, when it comes to calories, the answer is yes. Hard seltzers typically contain about 100 calories, while beers can have up to 175 calories. Light beers are more comparable to hard seltzers, with around 100-150 calories. However, it's worth noting that many people consume multiple cans of hard seltzer in one sitting, which can quickly add up in terms of calories.

The reason for the calorie difference lies in how these drinks are made. Hard seltzers are usually made by fermenting cane sugar, while beer is typically made from fermented grains. The use of fermented sugars in hard seltzers, rather than fermented grains, also makes them gluten-free, which can be a bonus for those with gluten intolerances.

The lower calorie count in hard seltzers might lead people to believe they are a healthier option. However, it's important to remember that alcohol itself is seven calories per gram, and those are empty calories providing no nutritional value. So, while hard seltzers might be lower in calories, they are not necessarily "healthy."

In addition, the refreshing and light nature of hard seltzers can make it easy to drink several without feeling full, which can lead to consuming more alcohol and calories than intended. As with all alcoholic beverages, it's important to consume hard seltzers in moderation.

So, while hard seltzers may have fewer calories than beer, it's not just about the numbers. The effects of alcohol on the body, regardless of the source, are important to consider when making choices about alcoholic beverages.

Carbohydrates: Beers have more carbs than hard seltzers

Beers typically have more carbohydrates than hard seltzers. A beer of a similar alcohol by volume (ABV) to a hard seltzer can contain anywhere from 8 to 15 grams of carbs, compared to the 2 grams of carbs in a hard seltzer. This is because the alcohol in hard seltzers comes from fermented cane sugars, while beer is made by fermenting grains.

The number of carbohydrates in a beer varies depending on the type of beer. Light beer has 5.3 grams of carbs per 12-ounce serving, while craft beer can have up to 15 grams of carbs per 12 ounces.

The difference in carbohydrates between hard seltzers and beers is one of the reasons why people may perceive hard seltzers as a healthier alternative to beer. However, it's important to note that hard seltzers are also lower in calories and easier to drink, which may lead to consuming more alcohol overall.

While hard seltzers are a better option for those on a keto or low-carb diet, it's important to remember that alcohol is still alcohol, regardless of the source. Excessive drinking of any alcoholic beverage can lead to long-term health issues such as high blood sugar, heart disease, stroke, digestive problems, liver disease, and cancer.

Therefore, when it comes to carbohydrates, hard seltzers are a better choice than beers if you're looking for a drink with fewer carbs. However, it's important to consider other factors, such as calorie count, taste, and overall health effects, when making a decision between the two.

Gluten: Hard seltzers are gluten-free, beers are not

Hard seltzers are gluten-free, beers are not. This is because beer is typically made from barley, wheat, or rye, all of which contain gluten. Hard seltzers, on the other hand, are usually made with brewed cane sugar and/or malted rice, with added soda water and flavourings. They may also contain a small amount of fruit juice, but not enough to add any nutritional value.

The gluten-free nature of hard seltzers makes them a better choice than beer for people who are gluten intolerant or have coeliac disease. Coeliac disease is a disorder in which eating gluten triggers an immune response in the body, causing symptoms such as digestive problems, bloating, and even headaches. For those with coeliac disease, consuming gluten can lead to more severe issues such as damage to the intestines and poor absorption of nutrients.

It is important to note that while hard seltzers are gluten-free, they are not necessarily healthier than beer. They tend to have fewer calories and carbohydrates, but their low-calorie content does not make them a healthier option. Additionally, the light and refreshing taste of hard seltzers can make it easier to consume more than the recommended amount, leading to excessive alcohol intake and associated long-term health effects.

When it comes to gluten content, hard seltzers are a better choice than beer for those who are gluten intolerant or have coeliac disease. However, it is important to read labels carefully as not all hard seltzer brands may be 100% gluten-free. Some may contain malted barley, which contains gluten. Beers, on the other hand, are typically not gluten-free due to the use of gluten-containing grains in the brewing process.

Hydration: Hard seltzers are hydrating, beers are not

Hard seltzers are often marketed as a hydrating beverage, but this is misleading. While hard seltzers may contain water and electrolytes, they also contain alcohol, which is a diuretic. This means that instead of hydrating you, hard seltzers can lead to dehydration as they make you pee more often.

Non-alcoholic seltzers, on the other hand, are a great way to give your body the water it needs. But when alcohol is added, this is no longer the case. In fact, no alcoholic beverage is a good choice for hydration. So, if you're drinking hard seltzers or any other type of alcohol, it's important to drink plenty of water too.

Hard seltzers are often seen as a healthier alternative to beer because they are lower in calories and carbohydrates. A typical 12-ounce can of hard seltzer contains around 100 calories, while a beer can have up to 175 calories. However, many people consume multiple cans of hard seltzer in one sitting, which can quickly add up in terms of calories.

Hard seltzers are also made from fermented sugars, which means they are gluten-free. This makes them a better choice than beer for people who have a gluten intolerance.

While hard seltzers may be a better option for those looking to cut down on calories or carbohydrates, they are not necessarily healthier than beer. It's important to consume any alcoholic beverage in moderation and to be aware of the potential health risks associated with excessive alcohol consumption.

Health: Hard seltzers are not a healthy drink

Hard seltzers are often marketed as a "healthy" alcoholic beverage, but this is misleading. While they may contain fewer calories and carbohydrates than beer or sugary cocktails, they are still alcoholic and should be consumed in moderation. Hard seltzers are not notably healthier than other alcoholic drinks and come with similar health risks when consumed in excess.

One of the main reasons hard seltzers are perceived as healthy is their low-calorie content. A typical 12-ounce can of hard seltzer contains around 100 calories, which is similar to a light beer. However, many people consume multiple cans in one sitting, which can quickly add up in terms of calories. Additionally, hard seltzers are often marketed as sugar-free, but this is not entirely accurate. While they may not contain added sugars, they are made from fermented sugars and contain some residual sugar.

Another factor contributing to their healthy image is the perception that hard seltzers are hydrating. However, this is not true. Hard seltzers contain alcohol, which is a diuretic and can lead to dehydration. It is important to drink water along with hard seltzers to stay hydrated.

Furthermore, hard seltzers are easy to drink and do not make you feel full, so it is easy to have too many. The calories and alcohol content can add up quickly, leading to potential health consequences such as high blood sugar, heart disease, stroke, digestive problems, liver disease, and cancer. Excessive drinking is linked to many long-term health risks, and alcohol itself is empty calories with no nutritional value.

While hard seltzers may be a better option for those looking to cut down on calories or carbohydrates, they are not inherently healthy. It is important to consume any alcoholic beverage, including hard seltzers, in moderation and to be aware of the potential health risks associated with excessive alcohol consumption.

Frequently asked questions