Mixing Beer And Wine: What's The Harm?

Mixing beer and wine is a controversial topic that many people are against. There are many old wives' tales and folk beliefs about the effects of drinking beer and wine together, or drinking one before the other. For example, the popular saying: Beer before wine and you'll feel fine. Wine before beer and you'll feel weird. However, science paints a different picture. While drinking too much of any alcoholic beverage can lead to negative consequences such as feeling sick, having a hangover, or alcohol poisoning, the order in which you drink beer and wine does not seem to matter.

Mixing beer and wine: will it send you to the hospital?

It's a common question with a controversial answer. Many people are against mixing beer and wine, and there are plenty of old wives' tales and folk sayings that warn against it. But is there any truth to these tales?

The Science

According to scientists, drinking beer and wine in any order will not make you feel sick or increase the risk of a hangover. The liver can effectively process one standard drink per hour, which is 5 ounces of wine or 12 ounces of beer. However, the amount of alcohol in these drinks may cause you to feel the effects sooner. For example, wine generally has a higher alcohol percentage than beer, so you may feel its effects quicker.

A 2019 study at the University of Cambridge set out to test this theory. They enrolled 90 adults between the ages of 19 and 40, randomly assigning them to one of three groups. Group 1 drank beer until their breath alcohol level was at least .05%, then drank wine until it was at least .11%. Group 2 did the opposite, starting with wine and ending with beer. Group 3 was allowed to drink either only wine or only beer until their breath alcohol level was at least .11%. After a week, the groups swapped, so those who drank wine first now drank beer first, and vice versa.

The results showed no correlation between hangover symptoms and whether subjects drank only wine, only beer, or switched between them in either order. The best predictors of a bad hangover were how drunk the subjects felt or whether they vomited after drinking.

Folk Sayings Debunked

There are many folk sayings that warn against mixing beer and wine, such as "beer before wine and you'll feel fine; wine before beer and you'll feel weird" or its more explicit cousin, "wine after beer and you'll feel queer; beer after wine and you'll be fine." These sayings are based on the idea that the carbonation in beer causes you to absorb alcohol faster, leading to greater inebriation and a worse hangover. However, science has debunked this myth, showing that it is the total amount of alcohol consumed that matters, not the order in which it is consumed.

So, Will Mixing Beer and Wine Send You to the Hospital?

No, as long as you drink in moderation. Suffering from hangovers or alcohol poisoning can land you in the hospital, so it is important to avoid overdrinking and to stay hydrated and well-nourished before consuming large amounts of alcohol. Mixing beer and wine will not make you feel sick or increase your risk of a hangover, but drinking too much of either can lead to negative consequences.

Beer and wine together: will it give you an upset stomach?

Mixing your drinks is often frowned upon, and many people believe that drinking beer and wine together will make you feel unwell. However, according to science, this is not the case.

The science

Several studies have been conducted to test the theory that drinking beer and wine together will make you feel unwell, and all have found that it is not the combination of beer and wine that causes sickness, but the amount consumed.

One study, conducted at the University of Cambridge, tested the popular saying: "beer before wine and you'll feel fine; wine before beer and you'll feel weird". The study found no evidence that mixing wine and beer in any specific order would speed up the effects of the alcohol or make participants feel sick.

Another study found that beer and wine can, in fact, aid digestion. It found that beer and wine "significantly accelerated gastric emptying in comparison with ethanol of the same concentration". However, another study disputed this, finding that there was "no additional effect of beer, wine or spirits on this postprandial response".

Other factors

While drinking beer and wine together will not make you sick, drinking too much alcohol can cause an upset stomach. Alcohol can irritate the digestive system, causing inflammation of the stomach lining, and can also lead to an imbalance of helpful digestive bacteria.

Drinking beer and wine together can also make you feel more intoxicated than usual, as carbonated drinks can make you absorb alcohol faster. This can lead to drinking more than usual, which can, in turn, lead to sickness.

Tips for drinking

If you want to avoid an upset stomach, it is best to drink in moderation and stay hydrated. It is also a good idea to eat before and while drinking, as this will slow the absorption of alcohol into the body.

Will mixing beer and wine give you a hangover?

Mixing beer and wine will not automatically give you a hangover. However, drinking too much alcohol will.

A 2000 review of previous research confirmed that hangovers are caused by dehydration, changes in hormone levels, and the toxic effects of alcohol. The more alcohol you consume, the more likely you are to experience a hangover.

According to a 2019 study by the University of Cambridge, the order in which you drink beer and wine does not affect the severity of a hangover. The study found no evidence that mixing wine and beer in any specific order would speed up intoxication or make you feel sicker. Instead, it is the total amount of alcohol consumed that matters.

That being said, wine is more likely to result in a worse hangover than beer. This is because wine, especially red wine, contains higher levels of congeners, which are chemical byproducts of the fermentation process. Congeners increase inflammation in the body, contributing to the feeling of malaise associated with hangovers.

To avoid a hangover, it is important to drink in moderation, stay hydrated, and make sure to eat before and during drinking alcohol.

Are there drinks that mix beer and wine?

Mixing beer and wine is a controversial topic, with many people holding strong beliefs about the potential negative consequences of doing so. However, science has proven that it is perfectly safe to mix beer and wine, and there are even drinks on the market that combine the two.

The Science Behind Mixing Beer and Wine

Despite common warnings, there is no scientific evidence that mixing beer and wine will make you sick. The old adage, "beer before wine and you'll feel fine; wine before beer and you'll feel weird," holds no weight. The only thing that will make you feel sick or increase your risk of a hangover is drinking too much. The liver can effectively process one standard drink per hour, which equates to 5 ounces of wine or 12 ounces of beer.

Beer and Wine Hybrid Drinks

Brewers and winemakers have been mixing beer and wine ingredients for thousands of years, and this tradition continues today in the form of beer-wine hybrids. These drinks are typically made by combining wine grapes with beer mash and fermenting them together, sometimes in wine barrels to impart a wine taste. The result is a beverage that looks like beer but tastes like wine.

One popular example of a beer-wine hybrid is Midas Touch by Dogfish Head Brewery, which combines wine, mead, and beer. With a 9% ABV, it offers subtle, fruity notes with a dry, crisp finish.

Beer and Wine Cocktails

In addition to hybrids, there are also cocktails that mix beer and wine, such as the Black Velvet, which combines stout and champagne or sparkling wine. This cocktail dates back to 19th-century London and is said to have been created following the death of Prince Albert, Queen Victoria's husband. The deep, dark colour of the drink symbolised mourning, especially that of the Queen, who wore black for the rest of her life.

To make a Black Velvet, simply combine equal parts stout and sparkling wine in a champagne flute. It is best served without ice, so be sure to chill the ingredients beforehand.

Does it matter if you drink wine or beer first?

There are many old sayings about the order in which you should consume alcohol, including: "beer before wine and you'll feel fine; wine before beer and you'll feel weird", and "beer then liquor, never sicker; liquor then beer, never fear". However, there is no scientific evidence to support these theories.

In 2019, a study was conducted at the University of Cambridge to determine the effect of drinking wine before beer and then beer before wine. The study found no evidence that mixing wine and beer in a specific order would speed up alcohol's effects or make you feel sicker. So, it does not matter in which order you consume wine and beer, but rather the amount you consume.

That being said, wine generally has a higher alcohol percentage than beer, so you may feel the effects of wine more quickly than with beer. If you start drinking wine and then switch to beer, you may consume more beer more quickly to maintain the same level of effects as the wine. This could ultimately lead to feeling sick.

Additionally, carbonated drinks can make you absorb alcohol faster, so drinking beer along with wine can make you feel buzzed faster. This could also lead to drinking more than intended and a worse hangover. However, this effect is not dependent on the order in which the drinks are consumed, but rather the total amount of alcohol consumed.

Frequently asked questions