Stoop Drinking: Beer, Law, And You

Drinking on the stoop is a common practice in New York, especially during the summer. However, it is considered illegal according to the city's open-container law, which prohibits drinking alcoholic beverages in public places. The law defines a public place as one accessible to the public or a large group of people, including sidewalks, streets, and parks. Despite this, many New Yorkers consider their stoop an extension of their home and believe they have the right to drink on their private property. This has led to a legal grey area, with some people receiving summonses and fines for drinking on their stoops, while others do not face any consequences. The interpretation of the law and whether a stoop is considered public or private property is still a matter of debate.

Drinking on your stoop is illegal in New York

New York's open-container law prohibits anyone from drinking an alcoholic beverage, or possessing and intending to drink from an open container containing an alcoholic beverage, in any public place. The law defines a public place as one "to which the public or a substantial group of persons has access, including, but not limited to," a sidewalk, street or park.

This means that if you're drinking on your stoop, you're breaking the law. Even if you're on private property, if your stoop can be seen from the street or sidewalk, it may still be considered a public place. The same goes for drinking in your driveway or garden; if it's visible to passersby, you could be fined.

Some people try to get around this law by drinking from a paper bag or a coffee cup, but this is not always effective. If the police suspect you are drinking alcohol, they may still issue you a ticket.

The law is controversial, and many New Yorkers believe it is an outrageous and idiotic waste of police resources. They argue that stoop drinking is a harmless activity that should be allowed, especially since it's often done in moderation and doesn't cause any trouble.

Despite the controversy, the law remains in place, and those who break it risk receiving a fine or even a brief jail sentence. So, if you're thinking of enjoying a beer on your stoop in New York, you may want to think again.

The open-container law prohibits drinking in public places

The definition of a "public place" is critical in understanding this law. In New York, a stoop can be considered a public place if it is accessible and visible from the street or sidewalk. This means that drinking on a stoop is illegal and can result in a fine, as it is considered a public place. However, the interpretation of what constitutes a "public place" is still debated, with some arguing that a stoop is more like a private kitchen than a public sidewalk.

Open-container laws also apply to vehicles, prohibiting the possession and consumption of open alcoholic beverages in the passenger compartments of most motor vehicles. These laws aim to reduce alcohol-related traffic fatalities and are enforced in many states across the US.

While the open-container law prohibits drinking in public places, it is important to note that it may vary by location and specific circumstances. Some cities or municipalities may have their own regulations that differ from state laws. Additionally, there may be exceptions for certain types of vehicles, such as taxis or recreational vehicles.

It is essential to be aware of the specific open-container laws in your area and to understand your rights and responsibilities when it comes to drinking in public places. While stoop drinking may be a cherished pastime for some, it is important to follow the local laws and regulations to avoid any legal consequences.

The definition of a public place is open to interpretation

The definition of a public place is indeed open to interpretation, as evidenced by the differing opinions on whether drinking beer on a stoop is legal in New York. While some people consider stoop drinking to be illegal, others argue that it is well within their rights as it falls under private property.

According to the New York Administrative Code, a public place is defined as "a place to which the public or a substantial group of persons has access." This definition leaves room for interpretation, as it does not specify the number of people that constitute a "substantial group." Additionally, the presence of a gate separating the stoop from the sidewalk can further blur the line between public and private spaces.

In the case of Mr. Kimber VanRy, he received a $25 summons for drinking a beer on his stoop in Brooklyn. VanRy questioned whether his stoop was considered a “public place” under the law, as it was not an area that a "substantial group of persons" could access. Steve Wasserman, a lawyer with the Legal Aid Society, supported this argument, suggesting that a stoop is more akin to private property than a public sidewalk.

On the other hand, some people argue that a stoop can be considered a public place because it can be viewed from the street or sidewalk and is technically part of the building in which one lives. This ambiguity in the definition of a public place has led to ongoing debates and varying interpretations, even among legal professionals.

The interpretation of a public place also varies across different countries and legal systems. For example, in the United Kingdom, a "public place" includes any highway, premises, or place that the public has access to, whether through payment or otherwise. Meanwhile, in Nordic countries like Norway and Sweden, all nature areas are considered public spaces due to the "allemansrätten" law, which grants the right to common passage.

The interpretation of a public place has significant implications for the enforcement of laws, such as open container laws, and can vary depending on the specific context and location. Ultimately, the definition of a public place remains subjective and open to ongoing debate and interpretation.

Drinking on your stoop may be considered drinking in public

However, some people argue that a stoop is an extension of one's home and therefore should not be considered public property. In addition, the original city motto of New York was "just mind your own fucking business" (in Dutch), reflecting a tradition of respect for private property and tolerance for what individuals do in their own homes.

The ambiguity of the law and its interpretation has led to confusion and debate among New Yorkers, with some receiving summonses and fines for drinking on their stoops, while others do not. This has also led to accusations of classism and racism, as the enforcement of these laws appears to vary depending on the neighborhood and the demographics of its residents.

In California, the definition of "public" is similar, but the determination of whether a particular place is public or private can depend on various factors, such as the presence of a locked fence or gate, and local ordinances. While drinking on your front porch may be considered private, doing so on a busy street or in full view of the public may be more likely to be considered a violation.

To avoid any potential issues, it is generally recommended to drink indoors or in a backyard or other private area that is not visible from a public street or sidewalk.

You could get a ticket or fine for drinking on your stoop

Drinking on your stoop is a beloved New York tradition. Stoop drinking is a quintessential New York pastime, with many New Yorkers considering their stoop an extension of their home. However, drinking on your stoop can lead to a ticket or fine.

New York's open-container law prohibits drinking alcoholic beverages in any public place. A public place is defined as a place to which the public or a substantial group of people has access, including sidewalks, streets, and parks. While there are exceptions, such as drinking at a block party or licensed premises, drinking on your stoop may fall into a legal grey area.

The issue of whether a stoop is considered public or private property is a matter of debate. On the one hand, a stoop is part of the building in which you live, and you are responsible for any accidents or incidents that occur there. However, because a stoop can be viewed from the street or sidewalk and is accessible to a group of people, it can be argued that it is a public place. This ambiguity has led to confusion and frustration among New Yorkers, who feel they should be able to drink on their stoops without repercussions.

The fines and penalties for drinking on your stoop can vary. In New York, the punishment for violating the open-container law is a fine of up to $25, imprisonment of up to five days, or both. However, the decision to issue a summons often appears to be at the discretion of the individual police officer, and the enforcement of these laws has been criticized as classist and racist.

Until the law is clarified or changed, those who choose to drink on their stoops do so at their own risk and may face legal consequences.

Frequently asked questions