Good Friday Beer: Is It Allowed?

Good Friday is a day of fasting and abstinence for Christians, particularly Catholics, who are required to forgo solid foods and, in some cases, alcohol. However, there is no formal prohibition against drinking beer or other alcoholic beverages on Good Friday within the Catholic Church. While many Catholics choose to abstain from alcohol on this holy day, others partake in drinking beer, wine, or spirits. This variation in practices highlights the individual's choice to drink or abstain, influenced by their personal beliefs and the spirit of penance associated with Good Friday.

Can you drink beer on Good Friday?

Drinking alcohol on Good Friday is not banned by the Catholic Church

Good Friday is a day of fasting and abstinence for Catholics, who are required to eat just one full meal and two smaller meals that do not add up to a full meal. However, this tradition of fasting only applies to solid foods, meaning that Catholics are allowed to consume liquids, including alcoholic beverages.

While many Catholics choose to abstain from alcohol on Good Friday and other holy days, there is no formal ban on drinking beer, wine, or spirits. According to Anthony D. Andreassi, a parish priest in Brooklyn, New York, "there is no prohibition from drinking alcohol on Good Friday according to the church's own rules."

Historically, drinking alcohol was often safer than drinking water. Adding a little wine to water could kill water-borne pathogens, and beer with a low alcohol content ("small beer") contained just enough alcohol to kill germs but not enough to impair one's work skills.

Additionally, alcohol, especially beer, played a role in compensating for the Great Fast during Lent. A special beer called doppelbock was invented to provide extra nutrients and vitamins during this period of fasting.

While Good Friday is a solemn day for Catholics, it does not necessarily have to be a completely sober one. However, alcoholic beverages are not seen as ideal drinks to be consumed on this day. If one chooses to drink alcohol, it should be done in moderation to avoid any potential problems.

Good Friday is a day of fasting and abstinence for Catholics

According to the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, "a person is permitted to eat one full meal, as well as two smaller meals that together are not equal to a full meal." This definition has been refined over time by the Church in terms of what is allowed during fasting. Liquids such as juice, coffee, tea, or milk do not technically violate the fast, although refraining from ingesting any animal products such as milk is considered virtuous.

Historically, Catholics during Lent fasted but did not necessarily abstain from alcohol. In fact, drinking alcohol was often safer than drinking water, as a little wine added to water kills water-borne pathogens, and beer with a low alcohol content ("small beer") contained just enough alcohol to kill germs but not enough to impair one's work skills. Additionally, alcohol, especially beer, was a way to compensate for the Great Fast. Special beers, such as doppelbock and Salvator, were invented to provide extra nutrients and vitamins during Lent.

While Good Friday is a day of fasting and abstinence, there is no specific restriction on alcohol consumption. However, drinking on such a somber day may be seen as diminishing the spirit of penance, as it is a day when Christians are supposed to focus on Christ's passion. Ultimately, the decision to drink alcohol on Good Friday is a personal choice for Catholics, and there is no official prohibition from the Church.

Drinking alcohol on Good Friday is not ideal

Good Friday is a solemn day for Christians, particularly Catholics, as it commemorates the day Jesus was crucified. It is a day of penance, reflection, and fasting, where Catholics traditionally abstain from meat and are only permitted to eat one full meal and two smaller, non-meat meals. While there is no formal prohibition against drinking alcohol on Good Friday, consuming alcoholic beverages on this day is generally not encouraged.

Firstly, drinking alcohol may diminish the spirit of penance and reflection that is intended for Good Friday. This day is meant to be a time of sorrow and remembrance of Christ's passion and sacrifice, and consuming alcohol may detract from the somber nature of the occasion.

Secondly, while alcohol is not explicitly forbidden, it is also not considered a necessity during fasting. According to Catholic tradition, fasting involves abstaining from food and limiting oneself to one full meal and two smaller meals that do not equal a full meal. Liquids such as water, juice, tea, and milk are allowed, but alcohol is not necessary for sustenance and may be seen as indulgent during a period of sacrifice and restraint.

Additionally, alcohol consumption during Good Friday could interfere with the spiritual benefits of fasting. Fasting is meant to bring the body into compliance and build self-control and self-mastery, which are important virtues in the Christian life. Drinking alcohol may hinder this process and distract from the focus on spiritual growth and contemplation.

Finally, Good Friday is a day of anticipation and preparation for the celebration of Christ's resurrection on Easter Sunday. Drinking alcohol may detract from the sense of anticipation and take away from the solemnity of the occasion.

While there is no explicit ban on alcohol consumption on Good Friday, it is generally not encouraged as it may detract from the true meaning and spirit of the day. It is a day meant for reflection, penance, and spiritual growth, and consuming alcohol may not align with these intentions.

In Ireland, laws banning alcohol sales on Good Friday have been relaxed

In Ireland, the sale of alcohol on Good Friday has been banned for almost a century, since the Intoxicating Liquor Act was introduced in 1927. However, in recent years, the country has relaxed these laws, allowing the sale of alcoholic beverages on this religious day. This change is largely due to the growth of tourism in Ireland, as well as changing demographics and decreasing religious observance.

David Stanton, the Junior Justice Minister, explained that tourism now contributes significantly more to the Irish economy than it did when the original ban was implemented. He also noted that changing demographics and increasing diversity have led to a reduction in traditional religious practices. As a result, the government decided to re-evaluate the Good Friday restrictions.

While the sale of alcohol is now permitted on Good Friday in Ireland, there are still laws regulating the sale and consumption of alcohol in the country. Alcohol can only be sold during specific hours and only by licensed businesses. It is also illegal to serve alcohol to minors or to supply alcohol to drunken individuals. Additionally, drinking in public places may be restricted by local bylaws, and there are strict rules regarding the advertising of alcohol.

Despite the relaxation of laws banning alcohol sales on Good Friday, Good Friday remains a solemn day for Christians, who recall and mourn the crucifixion of Jesus. While fasting is observed, it only applies to solid foods, and individuals are allowed to consume liquids, including alcoholic beverages. However, drinking alcohol on this day is not considered ideal.

In the past, drinking alcohol was safer than drinking water

Good Friday is a solemn day for Catholics, who traditionally fast and attend a liturgy service. However, there is no prohibition from drinking alcohol on this day, and some Catholics may choose to drink beer, wine, or spirits, while others abstain. In Brooklyn, New York, for example, a group of men from the Oratory of St. Boniface gather to share German beers and pretzels after the Good Friday service, a tradition that their parish priest affirms is well within church rules.

Now, to address your statement, "In the past, drinking alcohol was safer than drinking water."

It is true that in some parts of the world and at certain points in history, drinking alcohol was indeed safer than drinking water. This was because the process of fermentation during brewing killed many pathogens, and the resulting alcoholic drinks, when diluted with contaminated water, retained their antiseptic power. Beer and wine were also naturally acidic, further contributing to their pathogen-killing properties. For these reasons, people of all ages in the West consumed beer and wine as their primary thirst-quenchers, rather than water.

However, it is important to note that this practice was not universal. In the East, for instance, the practice of boiling water, usually for tea, created a non-alcoholic potable supply. Additionally, genetics played a role in making alcohol consumption uncommon in Asia, as approximately half of all Asian people lack an enzyme necessary for complete alcohol metabolism, making drinking an unpleasant experience.

While it is true that alcohol could make contaminated water safer to drink, it is a myth that people historically drank alcohol primarily for this reason. Clean water is, of course, essential for life, and while people in pre-modern times likely became ill from water more often than we do today, there is no historical record indicating that a lack of clean water was a widespread concern. On the contrary, people recognized when local water sources became unsafe and invested in infrastructure to bring fresh water to cities. For example, London's Great Conduit was built to address water quality issues in the city.

In conclusion, while alcohol may have been safer than water in certain contexts, it is inaccurate to claim that this was the primary reason for historical alcohol consumption. Instead, the choice to drink alcohol was influenced by a variety of cultural, social, and economic factors, and access to clean water varied depending on the time period and geographic location.

Frequently asked questions