Beer And Metro North: What's Allowed?

Drinking on trains and public transport is a contentious issue in many cities. In New York, drinking beer on the Metro North and Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) trains has been a long-standing tradition for commuters, with many bringing their own drinks or purchasing them from bar carts on the platforms. While the practice is not officially allowed, with both the Metro North and LIRR discouraging drinking on trains, it has been loosely enforced over the years, with commuters enjoying a beer or two on their journeys. However, there are occasional bans during busy periods, such as SantaCon weekends and the end-of-year holiday season.

Drinking beer on the Metro-North platform

On the one hand, some commuters have reported that drinking beer on the Metro-North platform is not allowed unless alcohol is sold at that particular platform. For example, drinking is permitted downstairs in Grand Central Terminal (GCT), but not on the main concourse. This suggests that drinking is only allowed in specific areas within the station where alcohol is sold.

On the other hand, there are reports of people bringing their own coolers with beer onto the Metro-North platform without any issues. Additionally, there have been bar carts on some platforms, such as Penn Station, Jamaica Station, Atlantic Terminal, and Hunterspoint Avenue, where commuters could purchase alcoholic beverages. These bar carts have since been removed as of 2018, but alcohol sales continue in dining halls at stations like Grand Central Station and Penn Station.

To further add to the confusion, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) has implemented temporary bans on alcohol during certain events, such as SantaCon, which takes place annually in December. During these times, alcohol consumption is prohibited on both trains and platforms for a specified duration.

Overall, it seems that the rules regarding drinking beer on the Metro-North platform are not strictly enforced, and there may be some discretion left to the authorities to determine when and where to allow alcohol consumption. While drinking may be discouraged, it is not uncommon for commuters to bring their own beverages onboard, including beer, and consume them discreetly during their journey.

Drinking beer on the train

However, the legalities of drinking beer on the train are a bit hazy. While the Metro-North and the LIRR discourage drinking on the trains, it's not explicitly prohibited. The Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA), which operates the Metro-North and the LIRR, has an alcohol policy that gives the railroads discretion to determine where and when to allow alcohol consumption. This has resulted in a famously ambiguous open container rule that is often skirted and loosely enforced.

That being said, there are certain times when alcohol is banned on the trains, such as during SantaCon and throughout the end-of-the-year holiday season. The MTA Police will enforce these restrictions and may confiscate alcoholic beverages, issue summonses, and remove violators from trains or stations. Additionally, drinking on the platform is generally not allowed unless alcohol is sold at that platform.

So, while it may be a common practice to drink beer on the Metro-North and the LIRR, it's important to be mindful of the rules and restrictions that may be in place at certain times. As always, drink responsibly and obey the instructions of train staff and law enforcement officials.

Buying beer at the Metro-North store

If you're looking to buy beer at a Metro-North store, there are a few things to keep in mind. Firstly, you must be of legal drinking age to purchase alcohol. Make sure you have a valid government-issued photo ID with you, as you may be asked to present it at the time of purchase.

At the Metro-North store, you'll find a variety of beer options to choose from. The selection typically includes domestic, imported, and craft beers, so you can explore different flavours and types to suit your taste preferences. You can also ask the staff for recommendations if you're looking to try something new.

When purchasing beer at the Metro-North store, you can buy individual bottles or cans, or you may even be able to bring a cooler to stock up for your trip. It's recommended to enjoy your beer on the train rather than on the platform, as drinking on the platform is generally not allowed unless they sell alcohol there. So, feel free to grab a beer from the store and take it on board with you.

Keep in mind that while drinking beer on the Metro-North train is permitted, it's important to be considerate of other passengers and dispose of your empty cans or bottles responsibly. Always follow the guidelines and instructions provided by the staff to ensure a pleasant journey for everyone.

Drinking beer on the Harlem line

There are several places to purchase beer before boarding the Harlem Line, including at GCT, which has a dedicated beer shop. Bringing your own beer from home is also an option, and some commuters have reported bringing coolers on board without comment from staff. Drinking on the Harlem Line is a great way to relax on your commute or while travelling into the city, and many commuters take advantage of this.

In addition to drinking on the train, there are also several bars and breweries located in Harlem that are worth visiting. Harlem Hops, for example, is Manhattan's first 100% African American-owned craft beer bar, offering a wide selection of fresh beers, including drafts and bottles. Harlem Tavern is another popular spot, known for its large size and diverse menu, including burgers, quesadillas, and fish and chips.

So, whether you're bringing your own beer on board or enjoying a drink at one of the many establishments in Harlem, there are plenty of options for drinking beer on the Harlem Line. Just remember to drink responsibly and always dispose of your empty cans properly.

Drinking beer on the train during SantaCon

If you're planning on joining the festive fun of SantaCon in New York City, it's important to know the rules about drinking beer on the train, specifically the Metro-North Railroad. While it is generally allowed to drink beer on Metro-North trains, SantaCon is a different story.

SantaCon is an annual event where people dress up in Santa Claus costumes and parade through the city, often including a pub crawl. The event has been characterized by drunken behaviour and public disorder, leading to community resistance and stricter rules. To maintain safety and order during SantaCon, the Metro-North Railroad and the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) implement a strict alcohol ban for the entire weekend of the event. This ban includes both trains and train platforms, and those who break the rules may have their drinks confiscated and may even be removed from the train station.

So, if you're planning on participating in SantaCon, it's important to leave your beer at home and abide by the alcohol ban on the Metro-North Railroad. The ban is put in place to ensure the safety of all commuters and to reduce the negative impacts of the event on the city. While drinking beer on the train is usually permitted, SantaCon is an exception to this rule.

It's worth noting that the rules and regulations regarding alcohol consumption on trains can change over time, so it's always a good idea to check for the most up-to-date information before your journey. Additionally, remember to drink responsibly and follow the "6 F's" of SantaCon: respect the cops, kids, bar staff, yourself, NYC, and Santa's Charity Mission.

Frequently asked questions