Beer On The Nyc Subway: What's Allowed?

New York City's laws on drinking in public are complex. While it is illegal to drink alcohol in public in NYC, there are some exceptions and loopholes. For example, drinking on commuter trains is generally allowed, and in the past, people have been able to get away with drinking on the subway by concealing their alcoholic beverage in a brown paper bag. However, this is not always effective, and you may still receive a ticket or fine. The laws vary depending on the borough, with Manhattan no longer arresting citizens for drinking in public, instead issuing criminal summonses.

So, can you drink beer on the NYC subway? The short answer is no, but some people may get away with it.

Drinking beer on the NYC subway is illegal

The law was instituted in the 1970s under the Koch administration, and while it is still illegal to drink on the street in New York, the way the law is enforced has changed over time. In 2016, the Manhattan district attorney, Cyrus R. Vance Jr., announced that police would no longer arrest people for minor offenses like drinking in public, opting instead to issue criminal summonses. This change in policy was intended to reduce a backlog of cases in Manhattan's criminal courts and temper the impact of "broken windows" policing, which disproportionately affects communities of color. As a result, while drinking beer on the NYC subway is still illegal, you are more likely to get a summons than be arrested.

It's worth noting that the policy change applied specifically to Manhattan, and while officers in the other four boroughs often issue civil summonses, you could still get a criminal summons there. Additionally, while drinking in public is illegal, simply having an open container of alcohol is not, as long as you are not drinking from it. This has led to the practice of "brown bagging," where people conceal their alcoholic drinks in brown paper bags, although this is not a surefire way to avoid a ticket.

So, while you may be able to get away with drinking beer on the NYC subway without facing arrest, it is still illegal and you may receive a summons. The best way to avoid any trouble is to save your beer for a bar or a permitted block party.

Drinking in public in NYC can result in a criminal summons

Drinking in public in New York City is illegal. The New York City Administrative Code states that you can only drink outdoors if you are at a permitted block party or a bar or restaurant with outdoor seating.

In 2016, Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus R. Vance Jr. announced that police would no longer arrest people for drinking in public, but they may still receive a criminal summons. This change in policy was intended to reduce a backlog of cases in Manhattan's criminal courts and temper the impact of "broken windows" policing, which treats low-level offenses as harbingers of major crime and disproportionately affects communities of color.

If you are issued a summons and choose to plead guilty, you owe a $25 fine, which you can pay by mail. If you choose to contest the charge, you may appear in court, and the charge may be dismissed by a judge. However, if you misplace your ticket or miss your court date, a warrant may be issued for your arrest, which could lead to being handcuffed, fingerprinted, and taken to jail.

While drinking in public may not always result in an arrest, it is important to be mindful of the potential consequences and to drink responsibly. Additionally, keep in mind that the laws and enforcement practices may vary between different boroughs of New York City.

Drinking on the NYC subway can result in a fine

In 2016, the city of New York announced that NYPD officers would no longer arrest citizens for committing minor infractions in Manhattan, such as drinking in public. Instead, officers would issue criminal summonses. This change in policy was intended to reduce a backlog of cases in Manhattan's criminal courts and temper the impact of "broken windows" policing, which treats low-level offenses as the harbingers of more major crimes.

While drinking in public is illegal in NYC, the accepted method to circumvent the law is to brown bag your container. Back in the day, as long as you used a brown bag, the cops would leave you alone. However, even the brown bag will get you a ticket nowadays. If you're issued a summons and choose to plead guilty, you owe a $25 fine, which you can pay by mail. If you choose to show up at summons court to contest the charge, it may be dismissed because a judge thinks it is unsubstantiated or nonsense.

It's important to note that the MTA LIRR and Metro-North Railroad previously permitted the consumption of alcoholic beverages and carrying open alcoholic beverage containers on trains, platforms, terminals, and stations. However, this was amended in 2020 to remove specific areas where alcohol consumption is permitted and instead gives the railroads discretion to determine where and when to allow such activities.

Drinking on the NYC subway can lead to an arrest

The law against public drinking was instituted during the 1970s under the Koch administration. While it is still illegal to drink outdoors, the consequences for doing so have been reduced in recent years. In 2016, the Manhattan district attorney announced that police would no longer arrest people for minor offenses, including drinking in public. Instead, they would issue criminal summonses, which may result in a fine. This change in policy was intended to reduce the backlog of cases in Manhattan's criminal courts and temper the impact of "broken windows" policing, which disproportionately affects communities of color.

However, it's important to note that this policy change only applies to Manhattan. In the other four boroughs of New York City, you could still receive a criminal summons for drinking in public, although many officers may issue a civil summons instead. Additionally, if you are acting belligerently drunk or bothering other passengers, you may still be arrested, even in Manhattan.

To avoid any legal trouble, it's best to refrain from drinking alcohol on the NYC subway or in other public spaces. If you want to drink outside, it's recommended to do so at a bar or restaurant with outdoor seating, a permitted block party, a beer garden, or in your own or someone else's backyard.

Drinking is allowed on some NYC commuter trains

The Metro-North Railroad ("MNR") and Long Island Rail Road ("LIRR"), which are both commuter train services, previously allowed the consumption of alcoholic beverages and carrying open alcoholic beverage containers on trains, platforms, terminals, and stations. However, as of April 29, 2020, the rules have been amended to give the railroads discretion to determine where and when to allow such activities. This means that drinking may be permitted on certain LIRR and MNR trains, but it is important to check the specific rules and regulations before consuming alcohol.

It is worth noting that drinking in public is generally illegal in New York City. The New York City Administrative Code states that open alcohol containers are prohibited in any public place, and this includes the NYC subway system. Those who are caught drinking in public may receive a criminal summons, a fine, or even be arrested if they are causing a disturbance.

Historically, there have been ways to circumvent the no-drinking laws in NYC. One method was to use a brown paper bag to conceal the alcoholic beverage container. While this may have been tolerated by law enforcement in the past, it is not a guarantee that it will be allowed, and it is still illegal to drink in public, regardless of the container.

In recent years, there have been some changes to the enforcement of public drinking laws in Manhattan. In 2016, it was announced that NYPD officers would no longer arrest citizens for committing minor infractions, including drinking alcohol in public. Instead, they would issue criminal summonses, which could result in a fine. This change was intended to reduce the backlog of cases in Manhattan's criminal courts and temper the impact of "broken windows" policing, which disproportionately affects communities of color. However, it is important to note that this policy change only applies to Manhattan and not the other four boroughs of New York City.

Frequently asked questions