Beer And Oyster Pairing: A Match Made In Heaven

Oysters and beer may seem like an unusual combination, but it's a classic pairing that's well worth trying. While oysters are often enjoyed with grape-based drinks like wine or Champagne, there are many different styles of beer that can beautifully complement the unique flavours of oysters. From crisp pilsners to dark stouts, the right beer can either contrast or enhance the salty, briny, sweet and creamy notes of oysters.

Stouts and oysters

Stout is a classic pairing with oysters. The slightly bitter, slightly sweet notes of a stout complement the salty, briny flavours of oysters.

In the early 1900s in England, it was common to drink stout with oysters, and Guinness even ran ads with the line, "Opening Time is Guinness Time. Guinness and Oysters are Good for You."

Today, stouts remain a good companion for oysters. The maltiness and bitterness of stouts contrast well with the flavours of oysters. When pairing a stout with oysters, a dry stout is a good choice. Stouts poured on a nitrogen line, such as Guinness, are also recommended as the silkier, creamier texture of the stout complements the briny, mineral flavours of an oyster.

For a unique twist on the classic stout and oyster pairing, you could try an oyster stout. Oyster stouts are dark, semi-sweet beers brewed using actual oyster shells. The shells are added during the boil for the full briny ocean flavour. Oyster stouts can also be made with whole oysters. While the oyster flavour is subtle, these beers often have a faint "marine" essence. Examples of oyster stouts include Flying Dog's Pearl Necklace, 21st Amendment's Marooned on Hog Island, and Porterhouse Brewing's Oyster Stout.

Pilsners and oysters

Pilsners are a great option for those who prefer a lighter beer to pair with their oysters. The crisp, clean taste of the beer balances out the briny taste of the oysters, creating a refreshing and satisfying combination.

When it comes to fried oysters, a good hop-forward pilsner is the perfect pairing. After oysters are breaded and fried, they lose their minerality and umami flavours take over. The light, bready, highly carbonated pilsner accentuates this, and a more hop-forward version cuts through the richness. Victory Prima Pils and Firestone Walker Pivo Pils are recommended by Matt Miller-Smulski, the Beer Director at Dusek's Board & Beer in Chicago.

For those who want to try a pilsner with a slightly sweet taste, the Czech Pils from Richmond-based Triple Crossing is a good choice. It's a balanced pilsner with a slight sweetness that makes it perfect for crushing pints on a hot summer day.

If you're looking for a classic pilsner, the Pivo Pils from Firestone Walker Brewing Co. is a great option. It has a nice bready aroma mixed with slight spicy esthers and a pleasant hop bitterness.

Another classic pilsner is the Rev Pils from Revolution Brewing Co. It strikes a nice balance between strong hop notes and a mild malt backbone.

For a unique twist on the traditional pilsner, try the Florida Room from Hoof Hearted Brewing Co. This brewery is not known for its lager, so they put a hopped-up spin on the classic style. The result is a crisp, zesty beer with a fruity aroma and taste that is still true to the pilsner style.

When pairing pilsners with oysters, it's important to consider the size and flavour intensity of the oysters. Smaller oysters with smoother shells will have more delicate and subtle flavours, so they pair best with less intense pilsners. On the other hand, larger oysters that are meatier and more intensely briny will stand up to pilsners with a little more body.

Saisons and oysters

Saisons are a great pairing for oysters, especially mineral-rich West Coast oysters. The fruity spiciness of a saison, like the Dupont Saison, gives oysters a sweeter aftertaste. The pepper and spice in the beer can also replace hot sauce if you like your oysters with a kick.

Saisons are characterised by their tight carbonated bubbles, light body, and a hint of spice. These characteristics make it the best beer pairing to ease Champagne and oyster lovers into pairing their bivalves with beer.

If you're looking for something a little different, you could try an oyster-accented saison. Brackish, an oyster stout from Fonts Flora Brewing, is released every November, and they occasionally brew and release Brine, a smoked and salted mixed-culture oyster saison.

For a traditional pairing, a saison is a great choice. But if you want to branch out, there are many other types of beer that can be paired with oysters. From stouts and porters to IPAs and pilsners, there's a beer for every type of oyster.

Gose and oysters

When pairing gose with oysters, consider the dominant flavour profiles of the oysters. Oysters tend to change flavour throughout the season, with October to early April being the best time to shuck and slurp them. They usually start salty upfront and then become sweet and creamy on the back of the palate. However, the nuances of flavour differ based on location. Doing research on specific oysters or knowing the dominant flavour profile of your favourites can help in finding the perfect pairing.

If you're looking for a unique flavour combination, consider pairing a super-briny oyster with a sweeter style of gose. The sweet and sour notes of the beer will complement the salty and briny flavours of the oyster. Alternatively, if you prefer a creamier oyster, look for a gose that is more tart and funky. The carbonation and light body of a gose can also help to cut through the richness of fried oysters.

When pairing gose with oysters, it's important to keep in mind that you don't want to overwhelm the subtle and elegant nature of the oyster's flavours. Look for a gose that will complement and enhance the oyster's "taste of the sea". The natural sweetness of the gose can also contrast nicely with the saltiness of the oyster, creating a well-balanced flavour profile.

Weizen and oysters

The key to a successful pairing is to avoid overwhelming the delicate flavours of oysters with a beer that is too intense. Weizen, also known as Öyster Weizen, is a traditional German wheat beer that is brewed with copious amounts of wheat and fermented with top fermenting yeast. By fermenting the beer slightly cooler than typical, the banana and clove flavours are kept subtle, allowing the spiciness of the hops to shine through and accentuating the lemon character of the beer. This spiciness and citrusy flavour profile is an ideal match for oysters, providing a contrast to their salty, briny taste without overpowering their delicate meat.

The Anderson's Neck Oyster Company, based in Virginia, has developed its own Öyster Weizen, commemorating the unique pronunciation of "oyster" by Chesapeake Bay watermen as "Erster". Their beer is brewed in the traditional German weizenbier style, with a focus on highlighting the spicy and lemon notes that make this style of beer such a perfect match for oysters.

When pairing Weizen with oysters, consider the specific variety of oysters you are serving. Oysters tend to change flavour throughout the season, with October to early April being the best time to enjoy them. Doing a bit of research on the specific type of oysters you are pairing with Weizen can help you create the perfect flavour combination.

For a unique twist on the classic Weizen and oysters pairing, try serving the oysters with a splash of lemon juice. The citrus will enhance the lemon character of the Weizen, creating a bright, refreshing flavour combination. Alternatively, for a more indulgent pairing, serve your oysters with a cocktail sauce featuring a robust dose of horseradish, which will complement the spicy notes in the beer.

Frequently asked questions