Low-Carb Beer: Better Energy Source Than Sugary Drinks?

Low-carb beers are often marketed as healthier alternatives to regular beers, but are they really better for you than energy drinks? A standard beer contains about 1.4 grams of carbohydrates per 100ml, while a low-carb beer typically has around half of that. However, it's important to note that beer doesn't contain a high amount of carbs to begin with, so the reduction in carbs may not have a significant impact. Additionally, low-carb beers still contain alcohol, which is the main contributor to weight gain and health issues associated with beer consumption. On the other hand, energy drinks are typically high in sugar and calories, which can also lead to weight gain and health problems. So, when comparing low-carb beer and energy drinks, it's not a straightforward decision. Ultimately, moderation is key, and it's important to be mindful of the amount of alcohol and calories consumed, regardless of the type of beverage.

Low-carb beers have a similar amount of carbohydrates as regular beers

Low-carb beers are often chosen by people who want to reduce their carbohydrate intake or are on a keto diet. While these beers do contain fewer carbs than regular beers, they still have a similar amount of carbohydrates. Beers are made by fermenting grains such as barley and wheat, which naturally contain carbohydrates. The number of carbohydrates in beer varies according to the fermentation process and the type of grains used.

According to the Cancer Council of Victoria, a typical lager or ale has around 1.4 grams of carbohydrates per 100ml. In comparison, a "low-carb" beer like Pure Blonde has just over 0.5 grams, while a "lower-carb" beer like Carlton Dry has 1.9 grams. This small difference in carbohydrate content led the council to conclude that low-carb beers have a similar amount of carbohydrates as regular beers.

To put this into perspective, a standard beer has around 13 grams of carbs per bottle, while people on a restricted carbohydrate diet may aim for under 50 grams per day. This means that even a "low-carb" beer can contribute a significant portion of your daily carb intake.

It's worth noting that the amount of alcohol in beer also plays a role in its overall calorie and kilojoule content. A low-carb beer is not low in alcohol and usually contains full strength. On the other hand, a low-alcohol beer will have fewer kilojoules, which is better for your health and can help reduce the risk of liver and heart disease, as well as certain types of cancer.

So, while low-carb beers do have a slightly lower carbohydrate content than regular beers, the difference is not significant enough to make a substantial impact on your diet. If you're looking to make healthier choices, focusing on reducing your alcohol intake or choosing low-alcohol beers may be a more effective strategy.

Low-carb beers have fewer kilojoules than regular beers

Low-carb beers typically have about a third less carbohydrates than regular beers, which sounds like a substantial reduction. However, beer doesn't contain a high amount of carbs to begin with, so the per-bottle savings amount to about half a slice of bread.

Most people equate carbs with energy, and low-carb beers do have about 25% fewer kilojoules (energy) than standard brews. However, beer is still a kilojoule-dense beverage option, even if it is low-carb. This is because most of the energy in beer comes from the alcohol, not the carbs.

A standard 375ml bottle of beer contains about 7% of the average recommended daily kilojoule intake, while a low-carb beer contains about 5%. Overindulging in either will quickly add up in terms of energy intake. While low-carb may be a "healthier" option in comparison, it's important not to let this be an excuse to overindulge.

It's worth noting that the problem with "straight swaps" like this is that they can give a false sense of having made a "healthy" choice and stop people from making other more healthy changes. So, if you prefer the taste of a standard brew and don't want to pay the "health" markup, it's more enjoyable and just as effective to cut the number of drinks you consume. Ultimately, beer is never going to be a health food, no matter the marketing, so it's important to enjoy it responsibly.

Low-carb beers are not lower in alcohol

It's important to note that low-carb beers are not low in alcohol; in fact, they usually have full strength. For a reduced health risk to your liver, blood pressure, and cancer risk, it is better to choose a low-alcohol beer over a low-carb beer.

The role of alcohol in weight gain

When you've had too much to drink, your body's metabolism slows down, and it directs all its energy toward dealing with the effects of alcohol. This is why the alcohol in beer, not the carbs, can affect your metabolism and weight loss journey.

Additionally, alcohol can further impede weight loss by stimulating appetite and decreasing inhibitions, leading to increased food intake.

Alternatives to beer

If you're trying to lose weight, it doesn't mean you can't unwind with a few drinks every now and then. In fact, drinking the right amount of alcohol may be good for you! While it may slow down your metabolism, it also has health benefits like lowering the risk of heart disease and type 2 diabetes, as long as you drink in moderation.

If you love beer and drink it often, light beer brands are a good option. Light beer in Australia is not about the calories but the alcohol percentage, which is around 2.5% on average. However, if you're conscious about beer calories, then drinks like wine and spirits are good alternatives to consider.

The bottom line

When it comes to weight loss and overall health, the most important thing to consider when choosing a beverage is the alcohol percentage: the lower the alcohol content, the fewer inches on your waistline. So, while low-carb beers do have fewer kilojoules than regular beers, it's important to remember that they are not a magic solution and that overall alcohol intake and consumption patterns are more significant factors in determining health outcomes.

Alcohol is an energy source with almost no nutritional value

Alcohol is a known depressant and the most widely used drug in the world. It is not an essential nutrient, meaning that it does not need to be included in our diets. Alcoholic beverages are primarily composed of water, alcohol (ethanol), and varying amounts of sugar. The calories in these drinks are considered "empty calories" due to the lack of other essential nutrients.

Alcohol is high in calories, with one gram containing seven calories. This is more than both carbohydrates and protein, which have four calories per gram, and only slightly less than fat, which has nine calories per gram. As such, alcohol can contribute to weight gain, especially when consumed in large quantities.

Alcohol is also detrimental to overall health and nutrition in several ways. Firstly, it inhibits the absorption of vital nutrients such as thiamin (vitamin B1), vitamin B12, folic acid, and zinc. This can lead to health issues such as beriberi, a disease that affects the cardiovascular and nervous systems, and megaloblastic anemia, which lowers the oxygen-carrying capacity of the blood.

Secondly, alcohol disrupts the body's ability to maintain healthy blood glucose levels. This can be particularly dangerous for people with diabetes, as alcohol can increase the risk of hypoglycemia and impair the body's ability to rectify low blood sugar.

Thirdly, alcohol can cause a loss of calcium in the body, increasing the risk of osteoporosis. This is especially true for heavy alcohol use during adolescence and young adulthood, which can have a significant impact on bone health later in life.

Finally, alcohol interferes with the absorption of amino acids in the small intestine and can alter protein metabolism, leading to complications such as decreased albumin, ascites, and an increased risk of hepatic encephalopathy.

In summary, while alcohol provides energy in the form of calories, it has almost no nutritional value and can negatively impact the absorption and utilisation of essential nutrients, increasing the risk of various health issues.

Beer is not excessive in carbohydrates to begin with

It's worth noting that the amount of carbohydrates in beer can vary depending on factors such as whether it's a light or regular variety, the fermentation process used, and the specific ingredients and sugar levels. However, in general, beer is not a high-carbohydrate beverage.

The misconception that beer is high in carbohydrates may have arisen due to the popularity of low-carb diets, which recommend avoiding carbohydrate-rich foods like cereals and grains. Since beer is made from malted cereal grains, it was quickly labeled as a high-carb drink. However, this label is not accurate, as the majority of beers on the market contain relatively low levels of carbohydrates.

In fact, alcoholic drinks that contain mixers such as ginger ale, cola, tonic, or tomato juice typically have a higher carbohydrate content than beer. Additionally, beer can be a good source of soluble fiber and prebiotic substances that promote digestion. It can also contain significant levels of vitamins, antioxidants, and minerals.

Therefore, it's important to consider the calorie content and the overall nutritional profile of beer, rather than solely focusing on its carbohydrate content.

Low-carb beers are not low in alcohol

While low-carb beers are a healthier alternative to regular beers in some ways, they are not low in alcohol. In fact, they usually contain full-strength alcohol.

Low-carb beers are produced by adding enzymes to the beer that help break down the complex carbohydrates from grains into simpler sugar units. This process results in a very light, low-carbohydrate beer. However, it does not significantly reduce the alcohol content. While "light" beers may contain slightly less alcohol than their regular counterparts, it is not by much. For example, Budweiser Select 55 has 2.4% ABV, while a typical Budweiser has 5% ABV.

It is important to note that alcohol itself is high in kilojoules, which can lead to unwanted weight gain and increase the risk of various health issues such as obesity, cancer, type 2 diabetes, heart and kidney disease, and stroke. Therefore, while low-carb beers may have a slightly reduced kilojoule content compared to regular beers, they are not a low-alcohol option.

When it comes to health, it is recommended to choose low-alcohol beers over low-carb beers. Reduced alcohol intake provides a lower health risk to your liver, blood pressure, and cancer risk. Additionally, the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) guidelines advise healthy men and women to drink no more than 10 standard drinks per week and no more than 4 standard drinks on any one day. It is always important to consume alcohol in moderation.

Frequently asked questions