Strong Beer: Healthy Or Harmful?

The smell of beer is an important part of the drinking experience, with the aroma preparing your palate for tasting. However, the strong smell of beer can sometimes indicate the presence of off-flavors, which are unpleasant tastes and smells that should not be present. These off-flavors can be caused by various factors such as bacterial infections, improper sanitation, or issues during the brewing, packaging, storage, or transportation process. While the strong smell of beer itself may not be inherently unhealthy, it could be an indication of an unhealthy drink.

The smell of strong beer can be influenced by the type of yeast used during fermentation

The smell of beer is influenced by a variety of factors, including the grain used, the herbs, the yeast, the temperature, and even the expiration date. Beer is typically made with either barley or wheat, or a combination of the two, and the smell of the beer will depend on the type of grain used. For example, beer made with barley tends to have a maltier, more caramelized, and roasted scent due to the kilning process before brewing. On the other hand, wheat beer is usually more citrusy and has a lighter, bready scent.

However, one of the most significant contributors to the smell of beer is the type of yeast used during fermentation. Yeast produces over 500 different compounds that give beer its unique flavour and aroma. Each type of yeast has its own distinct scent and flavour profile. For instance, the yeast used in wheat beer, such as Hefeweizen, often has banana, clove, and bubblegum notes, enhancing the citrusy and bready scent of the wheat.

Additionally, different types of yeast are used for ales and lagers, which also contributes to their distinct smells. Ales, which are fermented at warmer temperatures, tend to have a stronger scent, while lagers, fermented at cooler temperatures, are more subtle on the nose.

Furthermore, wild yeast and bacteria, such as Lactobacillus, Pediococcus, and Brettanomyces, used in sour beers can add their own unique scents, such as tart, fruity, peppery, zesty, and spicy notes.

In summary, the type of yeast used during fermentation plays a crucial role in determining the final aroma profile of a beer, working in conjunction with other factors like grain type, herbs, temperature, and more, to create the complex and varied scents found in different beers.

The aroma of beer can be enhanced by using specific glassware, such as an IPA glass

The aroma of beer is an important part of the drinking experience. In fact, 70-90% of our perception of flavour comes from our sense of smell. The right glassware can enhance the aroma of beer, and different styles of beer tend to pair best with certain types of glass.

The IPA glass, for example, is designed to aerate the beer, capturing and directing hop aromatics to your nose. The glass is tall, slender, and tapered, with a nucleated bottom to release carbonation and promote a steady stream of bubbles. The IPA glass is best suited for IPAs, of course, but also for American wild ales, Scotch ales, and barleywines.

The tulip glass, or Belgian glass, is another type of glassware that enhances the aroma of beer. The glass has a bulbous body and a flared lip, which captures the head and promotes the aroma of Belgian ales and other malty, hoppy beers. The short stem facilitates swirling, further enhancing the sensory experience.

Other types of glassware that can enhance the aroma of beer include the pilsner glass, the weizen glass, and the stange glass. The pilsner glass is tall and slim, helping to retain the head of the beer and keeping volatile aromatics locked under your nose. The weizen glass showcases the colour of wheat beers, locking in the signature banana and clove aromas and providing space for a thick, fluffy head. The stange glass, on the other hand, is narrow, straight, and cylindrical, concentrating soft hop and malt aromas while preserving carbonation.

Off-flavours in beer can be caused by bacterial infections, resulting in unpleasant tastes and smells

Infection refers to the introduction or presence of undesirable microorganisms in beer or raw materials. When these undesirable microorganisms are made into beer and start to compete for sugar with cultured yeast, infection will occur. Bacteria or undesirable microorganisms in wild yeast can destroy beer.

The most common off-flavours caused by bacterial infections include:

• Diacetyl: This off-flavour smells like butter, buttered popcorn, or butterscotch and can be caused by high flocculating yeast, weak or mutated yeast, issues with oxygenating, low fermentation temperatures, or short boils.
• Dimethyl Sulphide: This off-flavour can smell like sweet corn, cooked cabbage, tomato sauce, or even shellfish and oysters. It is caused by compounds created during the malting process of grains, which are later converted to Dimethyl Sulphide when heated.
• Metallic: This off-flavour can smell like iron, pennies, ink, or blood and is caused by beer or raw materials coming into contact with poor-quality metal pipes or machinery.
• Sulfidic: This off-flavour smells like rotten eggs, a burning match, or raw sewage. It is caused by hydrogen sulfide produced during fermentation, with lager yeasts tending to create greater sulfur aromas.
• Acetaldehyde: This off-flavour smells like green apples, rotten apples, or freshly cut pumpkin and is caused by a lack of fermentation time, not enough yeast, or low-quality yeast.
• Butyric Acid: This off-flavour smells putrid, rancid, or like baby sick and is caused by bacterial infection during the wort production phase or after packaging.
• Acetic: This off-flavour smells like vinegar or spoiled beer and is caused by wild yeast infection, which produces more acetic acid than other yeasts.

Proper sanitation and yeast management are crucial to preventing butter or butterscotch aromas in beer

The aroma of beer is an important part of the drinking experience, and sanitation and yeast management are key to ensuring a pleasant-smelling beer.

Sanitation is critical in the brewing process to prevent contamination by undesirable microorganisms. Brewing equipment must be thoroughly cleaned and sanitised to eliminate bad bacteria that can cause off-flavours and aromas. This includes ensuring that anything that comes into contact with the wort or beer is also sanitised, as contamination can occur at any stage of the brewing process. While it is difficult to completely sterilise equipment, proper sanitation techniques reduce the number of wild microbes, giving the added yeast a competitive advantage.

Yeast is a crucial ingredient in beer, and yeast management is essential to preventing butter or butterscotch aromas. Yeast produces diacetyl, the compound responsible for buttery aromas, during fermentation. If the diacetyl is not reabsorbed by the yeast before bottling or transferring to a secondary fermentation vessel, it will remain in the beer. To prevent this, brewers should allow fermentation to fully finish and, if fermenting at cooler temperatures, warm the beer briefly to encourage yeast activity. Additionally, the use of highly flocculating yeast or yeast with mutations can result in unabsorbed diacetyl.

By practising proper sanitation and yeast management, brewers can minimise the risk of butter or butterscotch aromas in their beer, ensuring a more pleasant drinking experience.

High fermentation temperatures can lead to increased ester production, resulting in strong fruity aromas

Fermentation is an exothermic process, meaning it generates its own heat. The higher the fermentation temperature, the faster the yeast will work and metabolise sugar. This also means that the temperature can rise during fermentation, and unless the rate of heat dissipation matches or exceeds the rate of heat production, the temperature will continue to increase.

Higher fermentation temperatures can lead to increased ester production, resulting in strong fruity aromas. Ester is a vital group of aromatic compounds in beer and wine, and even small changes in their concentration can have large effects on the final sensorial quality of fermented beverages. Ester is formed intracellularly by fermenting yeast cells and can diffuse through the cellular membrane into the fermenting medium.

The rate of ester formation depends on three factors: the concentration of the two substrates (the acyl coenzyme A (acyl-CoA) component and ethanol) and the activity of the enzymes involved in their synthesis and hydrolysis. Therefore, all parameters that influence substrate concentrations or enzyme activity may affect ester production.

The temperature during fermentation is one such parameter. A study by Saerens et al. found that increasing the fermentation temperature from 14 to 26°C released higher levels of esters through more efficient excretion and/or enhanced autolysis of the yeast. Another possible explanation is that an increase in temperature affects the thermodynamic equilibrium of ester solubility in cellular lipids and the aqueous medium.

The concentration of ethyl octanoate and ethyl decanoate esters increased with increasing temperature, while ethyl hexanoate production decreased but only up to a temperature of about 20°C. Thus, increasing the temperature above 20°C affects only the ethyl octanoate and ethyl decanoate levels and not the ethyl hexanoate level.

Frequently asked questions