Explore The Difference Between Ales And Lagers In Beer

Beer is a broad term for a fermented alcoholic beverage made with grains, water, yeast, and hops. The two main types of beer are lager and ale. The difference between lager and ale lies in the type of yeast used, the fermentation process, and the resulting flavour. Lager is made with bottom-fermenting yeast at cooler temperatures, resulting in a smooth, crisp flavour. Ale, on the other hand, is made with top-fermenting yeast at warmer temperatures, giving it a fruitier, more complex flavour.

Lager vs. ale: the brewing process

The main difference between ales and lagers is the type of yeast used in the brewing process. Ales are brewed with Saccharomyces cerevisiae, a hardy yeast that can withstand a wide range of temperatures and alcohol content. This yeast is commonly called "top-fermenting" because it rises to the top of the vessel during fermentation, forming a layer of foam. Lager, on the other hand, is brewed with Saccharomyces pastorianus (formerly known as Saccharomyces uvarum), a more fragile yeast that requires more specific conditions. This yeast is often referred to as "bottom-fermenting" because it sinks to the bottom of the vessel during fermentation.

Temperature also plays a crucial role in the brewing process. Ales are typically fermented at warmer temperatures, between 60-80°F (with some strains requiring up to 100°F), while lagers are fermented at cooler temperatures, usually between 35-55°F. The warmer temperature used for ales results in a faster fermentation process, usually taking less than a week. Lagers, on the other hand, require a longer fermentation period, typically lasting 1-3 weeks for primary fermentation, followed by a cold conditioning phase that can last several weeks or even months.

The choice of yeast and fermentation temperature has a significant impact on the flavour and characteristics of the final product. Ales tend to have a higher alcohol content and a stronger, fruitier flavour due to the higher fermentation temperature. They also tend to be darker and have a cloudier appearance. Lagers, on the other hand, have a lower alcohol content and a smoother, crisper, and sweeter flavour due to the slower fermentation and the preservation of more sugars. Lagers are generally lighter in colour and have a clearer appearance due to the cold conditioning step, which removes haze-forming solids.

While the type of yeast and fermentation temperature are the main distinguishing factors, other ingredients and brewing techniques can also vary between ales and lagers. Ales often have a higher hop content, which provides a protective element during fermentation and contributes to the bitter and fruity flavours. Lagers, on the other hand, showcase the delicate flavours of the hops due to the cold treatment process. Additionally, ales have more room for variation, resulting in a wide range of styles such as IPAs, stouts, and wheat beers. Lagers, bound by tradition and specific ingredients, have a more consistent flavour profile across different varieties.

Lager vs. ale: appearance

While it is difficult to distinguish between ales and lagers based on appearance alone, there are some general trends.

Lagers are generally clearer and lighter in colour, ranging from pale yellow to golden hues. They are usually crisper and more effervescent, with a lighter body and a refreshing quality. This is due to the lager's use of bottom-fermenting yeast, which settles at the bottom of the fermentation vessel and works more slowly, especially at cooler temperatures.

Ales, on the other hand, often appear darker and cloudier than lagers, displaying a wide spectrum of colours, from pale gold to deep brown. They tend to possess a more noticeable and active carbonation, contributing to a fuller mouthfeel. Ales are brewed using top-fermenting yeast strains that operate at warmer temperatures, typically between 60-75°F (15-24°C).

However, it is important to note that there are many exceptions to these generalisations, and the appearance of a beer can vary widely depending on the specific style and brewing process. For example, while most lagers are pale, there are also darker variations such as Dunkels and Schwarzbiers. Similarly, while ales can be dark, there are also pale gold or even white ales, such as Belgian witbiers.

Lager vs. ale: taste profile

Lagers and ales are the two broadest categories of beer. Most other beers (with some exceptions and overlaps) are either lagers or ales.

Lagers are typically "cold fermented", using yeast that ferments at lower temperatures, while ales are "warm fermented", using yeast that ferments at higher temperatures. Lagers are "bottom-fermenting", meaning the yeast tends to stick to the bottom, and ales are "top-fermenting", meaning they get a foamy layer on top while they ferment.

Lagers tend to have a smooth, crisp, clean, and refreshing flavour profile with a lower fruitiness level than ales. Ales, on the other hand, tend to have a more complex, fruity, robust, and spicy flavour profile. They often exhibit a diverse range of tastes, from fruity and spicy to intense hoppy bitterness, and can have a richer, more pronounced aroma due to the higher fermentation temperatures.

Lagers are often described as being easier to drink, which is why most of the top-selling beers worldwide are lagers. They are also served very cold, which affects their taste.

Some popular types of lager include pilsners, bocks, and Vienna lagers, while some popular types of ale include brown ale, pale ale, India pale ale (IPA), Belgian ale, and stout.

Lager yeast vs. ale yeast

Lager yeast and ale yeast are two different species of yeast that are used during the fermentation process of beer. Lager yeast is the "bottom-fermenting" type, called Saccharomyces pastorianus or Saccharomyces uvarum, while ale yeast is the "top-fermenting" type, called Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Lager yeast thrives at lower temperatures, generally between 42°F and 55°F, with some strains performing well at temperatures as low as 32°F. The colder temperature slows down the fermentation process, resulting in a smoother and less foamy beer. All strains of lager yeast will flocculate and then settle to the bottom of the fermenting vessel.

Ale yeast, on the other hand, performs best at temperatures ranging from 60°F to 75°F, with certain strains even functioning optimally at 55°F or lower. Some ale yeast strains tend to flocculate at the surface of the fermenting beer during the early stages of fermentation, which is why it is called "top-fermenting". The warmer temperatures increase the rate of fermentation and the production of carbon dioxide, contributing to the yeast rising to the top.

The different fermentation temperatures and behaviours of lager yeast and ale yeast also influence the taste of the final product. Colder temperatures cause yeast to produce fewer aromatic compounds, resulting in lagers having a ''cleaner' taste that allows the malt and hops to be more noticeable. Ales, on the other hand, tend to have stronger fruity and spicy flavours that balance out the malt and hops.

Cold temperatures vs. warm temperatures

When it comes to beer, temperature is critical. It can make or break your beer, affecting the process and the final product. This is especially true during fermentation, where temperature control is essential to achieving the desired outcome.

Cold temperatures:

When it comes to brewing, cold temperatures are typically associated with lager production. Lager yeasts, or saccharomyces uvarum, work best at cooler temperatures, usually between 40 to 54°F (4 to 12°C). This is known as cold fermentation, and it results in a smoother, crisper, and less fruity flavour profile compared to ales. Lager yeasts are bottom-fermenting, meaning they don't rise to the surface during fermentation and require delicate handling. The cold slows down the yeast's activity, reducing their ability to convert sugars into alcohol. This leads to a slower fermentation process and a cleaner, less complex beer.

Storing beer at colder temperatures also helps maintain freshness. Heat can accelerate the ageing process in beer, with higher temperatures leading to faster chemical reactions and oxidation. By keeping beer cold, the "brewery fresh" taste can be preserved for longer.

Warm temperatures:

On the other hand, ale production favours warmer temperatures, typically between 55 to 70°F (13 to 21°C). This is known as warm fermentation, and it results in a fruitier, more complex flavour profile. Ale yeasts, or saccharomyces cerevisiae, are top-fermenting, rising to the surface during fermentation and then sinking when the process is complete. Warmer temperatures encourage the yeast to be more active, leading to a faster fermentation process and a stronger, sweeter flavour.

Serving beer at warmer temperatures can also enhance its flavour and aroma. While ice-cold beer can be refreshing, it can mask many of the nuances that make each beer unique. As beer warms towards room temperature, more of its flavours and aromas are released, providing a more robust drinking experience. However, it is important not to let beer get too warm, as this can also lead to an unpleasant drinking experience.

Frequently asked questions