Explore Amber And Lager Beer: Their Unique Differences

Amber and lager are two different styles of beer with distinct characteristics. The main differences between the two types of beer lie in their colour, flavour, alcohol content, brewing process and fermentation process. Lager is a bottom-fermented beer, brewed at low temperatures for a longer period, resulting in a finer flavour. Amber, on the other hand, is top-fermented, brewed at warm temperatures for a shorter duration, and has a higher alcohol content. Amber beers also have a transparent appearance and a distinct tone due to the addition of coloured malt.

Differences between Amber and Lager Beer

Fermentation process

The fermentation process is the main differentiator between amber ales and lagers. Amber ales are produced through top-fermenting yeasts, while lagers are made from bottom-fermenting yeasts.

Amber Ale Fermentation

Amber ales are fermented at higher temperatures than lagers. The warmer temperatures allow for a shorter fermentation time, typically between 7 and 10 days. The primary fermentation is followed by maturation, where the yeast reduces diacetyl and acetaldehyde—byproducts that contribute to buttery and green apple flavours, respectively.

The maturation phase can be carried out in several ways, depending on the desired flavour profile. One method is to transfer the beer to a secondary fermentation vessel, such as a carboy or soda keg, and allow the yeast to continue working. This approach is suitable when the beer is racked before it has completely fermented, leaving enough yeast in suspension to finish the job.

Another method is to keep the beer in the primary fermenter until it has completely fermented and the diacetyl levels have been sufficiently reduced. While this process makes it more challenging to build up carbonation, it offers the advantage of a larger amount of yeast available in the primary fermenter for a quicker maturation.

After fermentation and maturation, the beer is racked to a serving keg for force carbonation or bottled for conditioning. When bottle conditioning, fresh yeast may be added along with priming sugar to ensure consistent carbonation.

Lager Fermentation

Lager fermentation takes place at lower temperatures than amber ales, typically between 46 and 54 °F (8 and 12 °C). This slower metabolism results in a longer fermentation time, usually between 1 and 3 weeks. The primary fermentation is followed by maturation, where the yeast reduces byproducts such as diacetyl and acetaldehyde.

Lager maturation can be achieved through cold storage (lagering), which gives lager beers their smoother taste and longer shelf life. During this phase, proteins, polyphenols, and yeast sediment precipitate out of the beer, and hop polyphenols drop out, resulting in milder hop bitterness.

After maturation, the beer is racked to a serving keg for force carbonation or bottled for conditioning. When bottle conditioning, fresh yeast may be added, especially if the yeast present in the beer is older than six weeks, to ensure consistent carbonation.

Brewing time and temperature

Amber beers are brewed at higher temperatures than Lagers. Amber ales are brewed at temperatures between 60 to 80°F (16–26°C). The warmer temperature range allows for a shorter brewing time, usually between one to three weeks. Ales are then conditioned for a week or more to develop their flavours.

Lagers, on the other hand, are brewed at cooler temperatures, typically in the range of 48–58°F (9–14°C). Lager brewing takes a longer time due to the lower temperatures, with primary fermentation lasting one to three weeks. After the primary fermentation, lagers undergo an additional cold lagering period of at least two to three weeks near 32°F (0°C). This extended cold conditioning phase allows the beer to age and contributes to the smooth, crisp drinking experience characteristic of lagers.

The choice of brewing temperature also influences the flavour profiles of Amber and Lager beers. The warmer temperatures used in brewing Amber ales promote the production of complex esters and phenols, resulting in a spicier and fruitier flavour. In contrast, the cooler fermentation temperatures of Lagers suppress the formation of these compounds, leading to a cleaner, crisper, and less complex flavour profile.

While the specific brewing times may vary depending on the particular style and recipe, the fundamental difference lies in the temperature ranges employed during the brewing process, with Amber ales favouring higher temperatures and shorter brewing times, while Lagers utilise lower temperatures and longer brewing durations.

Alcohol content

Amber ales and lagers differ in their alcohol content. Amber ales have a higher alcohol content than lagers. Amber ales typically have a moderate alcohol content, ranging from 4.5% to 6% ABV (alcohol by volume). On the other hand, lagers are known for their lower alcohol content, which makes them a good option for new drinkers.

The difference in alcohol content between the two types of beer can be attributed to the fermentation process and the type of yeast used. Amber ales are produced through top-fermenting yeasts, while lagers are made from bottom-fermenting yeasts. The lager brewing process takes longer and occurs at lower temperatures, usually below 10°C or between 44°F (7°C) and 55°F (13°C), which contributes to the finer flavour and lower alcohol content.

In addition to the standard lager, there is also a sub-type known as "amber lager", which is brighter than the standard lager. This variety is generally darker in colour than pale lagers, often a deep tan or amber hue. Common styles of amber lager include Märzen, Bock, and Vienna lager.

Colour

The colour of beer is determined by a number of factors, including the type of grain used, the roasting method, and the presence of additives such as caramel and crystal malts. The colour of beer can vary from pale yellow to jet black, and even the same colour can indicate different flavours depending on the context.

Lager beers can be pale, amber, or dark. Pale lager is the most widely consumed and commercially available style of beer. Amber lagers are generally darker in colour than pale lagers, often a deep tan or amber hue. Some common styles of amber lager include Märzen, Bock, and Vienna lager. The Vienna lager, for example, has a copper to reddish-brown colour, while Bock is a darker amber lager with a higher alcohol content.

Amber ales, on the other hand, are named after the golden to amber colour they exhibit. This colour is derived from the use of caramel and crystal malt additions, which are roasted to provide the distinctive hue. Amber ales are darker in colour than their pale ale cousins, and the presence of caramel and crystal malts lends them a toasted, toffee flavour. The colour of amber ales can range from copper to reddish-brown, with a clear to slight haze.

While lager beers are typically paler in colour compared to amber beers, it is important to note that the term "amber" can be used to describe different beers with varying colours. Additionally, lager beers may contain adjuncts such as rice or maize, which can lighten the colour and provide a crisp, bright finish to the flavour.

Taste and aroma

The main difference between lager and amber beer is their flavour. Lagers have a stronger taste than ambers, which is something to note for aspiring beer enthusiasts. Lager beer has a light and malty taste. It is also consistent, crispier, and cleaner, but not sophisticated. Well-made lagers have a stronger aroma, flavour, and taste with malt flavours and hops. Even if you’re fond of other types of beers, you’re likely to enjoy drinking lager beers due to their consistency in flavour.

Amber ales, on the other hand, have a balanced flavour profile, offering a harmonious blend of malt sweetness and hop bitterness, resulting in a medium-bodied brew. They are also categorised as light beers and lack a strong aroma, flavour, or taste as is the case with lagers. Amber ales have a reddish-brown colour and a maltier flavour profile. They are made with caramel or roasted malts, giving them a reddish or amber hue. They have a malty and sweet flavour with a slight bitterness and a higher alcohol content than lagers.

The lager brewing process takes a longer time and occurs at low temperatures, usually less than 55 degrees Fahrenheit, to support fermentation. This results in lager beers with a finer flavour than amber ales. However, amber ales are brewed at higher (warm) temperatures and the fermentation process takes a shorter time. The two beer types also differ in alcohol content, with lagers containing less alcohol content than ambers.

Frequently asked questions