Hard Liquor Vs Beer: Which Is The Healthier Choice?

High Noons, a brand of hard seltzer, have been marketed as a healthier alternative to beer. Hard seltzers are often lower in calories, carbohydrates, and sugar than beer, and are also gluten-free. However, it's important to note that hard seltzers still contain alcohol, which has no nutritional value and can increase the risk of chronic diseases. While they may be a better option for those watching their calorie intake or with gluten sensitivities, hard seltzers should still be consumed in moderation as they can contribute to dehydration.

Calories and carbs: Hard seltzers have fewer calories and carbs than beer

Hard seltzers have taken the industry by storm in recent years, with sales skyrocketing and consumers increasingly seeking out this "lighter" alcoholic beverage. One of the main reasons for its popularity is that hard seltzers typically have fewer calories and carbohydrates than beer.

A standard 12-ounce can of hard seltzer usually contains around 100 calories and 2 grams of carbohydrates. In contrast, a 12-ounce serving of beer typically has about 150 calories and 12.8 to 30 grams of carbohydrates. This difference in calorie and carb content is significant, especially for those watching their caloric intake or following a keto or low-carb diet.

Light beer is more comparable to hard seltzer in terms of calories and carbs. A 12-ounce light beer typically contains around 100 calories and 5.3 to 6 grams of carbohydrates. However, hard seltzers still tend to have a slight edge in terms of lower carb content.

It's worth noting that the calorie and carb counts can vary slightly between different brands of hard seltzers. For example, some hard seltzers may have slightly fewer or more calories, and some may offer zero-carb options. Additionally, the fruit juice content in hard seltzers is usually very low, so it doesn't add significant nutrition or sugar content.

While hard seltzers have gained popularity for their lower calorie and carb content, it's important to remember that they are still alcoholic beverages and should be consumed in moderation. The easy drinkability of hard seltzers might also lead to overconsumption, so it's important to be mindful of your intake.

Sugar content: Beer usually has more sugar, which can worsen hangovers

Beer usually contains very little sugar, with most beers having none at all. However, light beers, such as Miller Lite, tend to have slightly more sugar. Beer is generally made from grains, spices, yeast, and water, and while sugar is not added as an ingredient, it is necessary to produce alcohol. During the brewing process, the grains are germinated, breaking down starch into fermentable sugar, mainly maltose. This is then fermented by yeast, which converts the sugar into alcohol.

The sugar content of beer can vary depending on the type and brand, but it typically has less sugar than other alcoholic drinks like wine. For example, a typical beer has around 150 calories and 15 to 30 grams of carbohydrates per 12-ounce serving, while a hard seltzer has around 100 calories and 2 grams of carbohydrates. However, some beers may have higher sugar content due to added ingredients, such as honey or corn syrup.

The sugar content of beer can impact blood sugar levels, especially for people with diabetes, hypoglycemia, or general blood sugar management concerns. Alcohol can impair sugar metabolism, leading to a sudden drop in blood sugar levels that can last up to 24 hours after consumption. This can be intensified by the use of anti-hyperglycemic medications. Therefore, it is generally recommended to consume beer with a carb-containing meal to avoid hypoglycemia.

While beer may not have a high sugar content, it is important to consider its impact on blood sugar levels and to consume it in moderation.

Alcohol content: Hard seltzers have a lower ABV than beer

Alcohol content is a key differentiator between hard seltzers and beer. Most hard seltzers on the market today have an alcohol by volume (ABV) percentage between 4% and 5%, although some may go as high as 6% or even 12%. In contrast, beer typically has an ABV of around 5%, with light beers at 4.2% and craft beers reaching 6.5% or more. This means that, generally speaking, hard seltzers have a lower ABV than beer.

The alcohol in hard seltzers usually comes from fermented cane sugars, while beer is made from fermented grains. This difference in production contributes to the lower ABV of hard seltzers. It also makes hard seltzers gluten-free, as they are not made with grains, whereas beer typically contains gluten. For individuals with gluten intolerance or celiac disease, this makes hard seltzers a more appealing choice.

The lower ABV of hard seltzers can also impact the drinking experience. With a lower alcohol content, hard seltzers may be less filling than beer, which could lead to consuming more drinks overall. Additionally, the light, barely-there taste of alcohol in hard seltzers can make it easier to sip on and potentially drink more than intended.

While hard seltzers have a lower ABV than beer, it's important to remember that any alcoholic beverage, when consumed in excess, can lead to negative health effects. Moderation is key, and drinking in excess can increase the risk of high blood sugar, heart disease, stroke, digestive problems, liver disease, cancer, and more.

Ingredients: Beer contains grains, making it unsuitable for gluten-intolerant people

Beer is a popular alcoholic beverage made from four main ingredients: malt, hops, yeast, and water. Malt, derived from barley, is the principal source of fermentable sugar in beer. It is responsible for the beer's flavour, mouthfeel, and colour. Hops, the green cone-shaped flowers of the hop plant, add balance, flavour, and aroma to the beer. They also act as a preservative. Brewer's yeast is a type of fungus that converts fermentable sugars into alcohol and carbon dioxide, and water makes up the majority of the beer.

In addition to these primary ingredients, adjuncts such as rice or oatmeal are sometimes used as a cheaper alternative to malted grains or to produce a lighter beer. These adjuncts can also contribute their own unique flavours and characteristics to the final product.

While beer has a long history and a dedicated brewing culture, it may not be suitable for everyone due to its grain content. People with gluten intolerance, celiac disease, or gluten allergies need to avoid consuming gluten, a protein found in grains such as barley, wheat, and rye. As beer is typically made with barley, it contains gluten, making it unsuitable for those with gluten-related issues.

On the other hand, High Noon, an up-and-coming hard seltzer brand, offers a gluten-free option. High Noon is labelled gluten-free and safe for those with celiac disease or gluten intolerance. It is made with sparkling water, vodka, juice, natural flavours, citric acid, and potassium citrate, providing a refreshing and safe alternative for gluten-intolerant individuals.

The availability of gluten-free alternatives like High Noon allows those with gluten sensitivities to enjoy alcoholic beverages without compromising their health. It is important for consumers with gluten-related issues to carefully read labels and choose products that cater to their dietary needs, ensuring a safe and enjoyable drinking experience.

Hydration: No alcoholic drink hydrates you, but hard seltzers are less dehydrating

Hydration: No Alcoholic Drink Hydrates You, but Hard Seltzers May Be Less Dehydrating

When it comes to hydration, it's important to understand that no alcoholic beverage, including hard seltzers, can effectively hydrate your body. Alcohol is a diuretic, which means it promotes water loss through increased urination. As a result, you lose fluids and can become dehydrated if you don't replace those lost fluids with water.

However, compared to other alcoholic drinks, hard seltzers may have a slight edge in terms of hydration. This is not because they contain seltzer water, but because they typically have lower alcohol content. Hard seltzers usually range from 4% to 5% alcohol by volume (ABV), while beers often have a similar alcohol content, ranging from 4.2% to 6.5% ABV. The lower the alcohol content, the less pronounced the diuretic effect, so hard seltzers may be marginally less dehydrating than beers with higher alcohol levels.

It's worth noting that even though hard seltzers are marketed as a refreshing and hydrating alternative to other alcoholic drinks, this perception may lead to excessive consumption. The ease of drinking hard seltzers can cause people to consume more than they realise, which can contribute to dehydration. Therefore, it's crucial to prioritise hydration by drinking water alongside any alcoholic beverage, including hard seltzers.

Additionally, the carbonation in hard seltzers can contribute to a feeling of fullness, which may make you less likely to drink water or other fluids. This further emphasises the importance of conscious hydration when consuming hard seltzers or any alcoholic drink.

In summary, while no alcoholic drink can effectively hydrate you, hard seltzers with their typically lower alcohol content may be marginally less dehydrating than beers with higher alcohol levels. However, it's crucial to prioritise hydration by drinking water alongside any alcoholic beverage and being mindful of your overall fluid intake.

Frequently asked questions