Guinness Beer: High Iron Content Or Just A Myth?

Guinness Beer is often associated with health benefits, and one of the most well-known claims is that it contains high levels of iron. With approximately 0.3 mg of iron per pint, it contributes to the recommended daily intake of iron for both men and women, which ranges from 9-18 mg. While this may not seem significant, it has historically been used to replenish iron levels in post-op patients, pregnant women, and blood donors. The iron content in Guinness, combined with its other nutritional properties, has contributed to its reputation as a relatively healthy alcoholic beverage.

Health benefits of Guinness

While it's important to remember that Guinness is still a form of alcohol and should be consumed in moderation, there are some surprising health benefits to drinking the "black stuff".

Firstly, Guinness contains antioxidants, known as flavonids, which are commonly found in fruit and vegetables. These can help to reduce levels of cholesterol and lower the risk of blood clots and heart attacks.

Secondly, Guinness contains iron. While there is only 0.3mg of iron per pint, most adults don't reach their recommended 9-18mg per day, so every little helps! In the past, Guinness was even given to post-op patients, pregnant women, and people who had donated blood to help replenish their iron levels.

Thirdly, Guinness is relatively low in calories compared to other beers. A pint of Guinness has 210 calories, whereas a pint of Heineken has 255 calories, and a pint of ale or stout typically contains over 250 calories.

Fourthly, Guinness is good for your bones. Beer contains a plant hormone called phytoestrogen, which is key to building dense bones, as well as calcium and dietary silicon, which are important for the growth and development of bone and connective tissues. Studies have shown that moderate beer drinkers are less likely to develop osteoporosis and have a lower risk of hip fractures.

Finally, Guinness is relatively low in alcohol content compared to other beers, with an ABV of 4.2% compared to the average of 5%.

Iron content in Guinness

While Guinness does contain iron, the amount is relatively small. There is approximately 0.3 mg of iron per pint of Guinness, which amounts to around 3% of the recommended intake for men and 2% for women. Despite the low iron content, Guinness was once given to post-op patients, pregnant women, and people who had donated blood, as it was believed to help replenish their iron levels.

Iron is essential for the production of haemoglobin, which is responsible for transporting oxygen via red blood cells. In addition to iron, Guinness also contains other nutrients such as folate, fibre, and ferulic acid. It is also relatively low in calories compared to other beers, with only 15 more calories than a Bud Light.

Guinness has long been associated with health benefits, with its famous slogan "Guinness is good for you". While some of these benefits may be exaggerated, there is evidence to suggest that Guinness has positive effects on the body. For example, a 2003 study found that Guinness could potentially reduce the risk of blood clots forming in the arteries, which may be due to its antioxidant properties.

Guinness is also a good source of silicon, which is important for maintaining bone density and health. Additionally, it contains all the different B vitamins, except for B12, which can have a positive impact on energy levels, brain function, and cell metabolism.

However, it is important to consume Guinness in moderation, as excessive alcohol intake can have negative effects on the body, including negative impacts on bone density. While Guinness may have some health benefits, it should still be consumed in moderation as part of a balanced lifestyle.

Comparison with other beers

A study by the University of Valladolid in Spain analysed 40 brands of beer and found that dark beers have an average free iron content of 121 ppb (parts per billion), compared to 92 ppb in pale beers and 63 ppb in non-alcoholic beers. The study also found that the beers with the highest iron content were a dark Spanish beer (165 ppb) and a dark Mexican beer (130 ppb). Those with the lowest levels of iron were from the Netherlands and Ireland (41 ppb and 47 ppb, respectively).

Guinness, a dark beer, contains approximately 0.3 mg of iron per pint, which is around 3% of the recommended intake for men and 2% for women. While this amount may seem small, it can still contribute to an individual's overall iron intake, especially if they are not meeting the recommended daily intake of 9-18 mg. Additionally, alcohol can affect iron absorption, with heavy drinkers at an increased risk of iron overload.

When compared to other beers, Guinness has a relatively lower iron content. For example, the dark Spanish and Mexican beers mentioned earlier have higher iron content at 165 ppb and 130 ppb, respectively. However, it is important to note that the iron content in beers can vary widely, and factors such as production processes and raw materials used can influence the final amount.

In terms of health benefits, while Guinness may not be the top choice for iron intake, it does offer other advantages. It is considered a "light" beer, with only slightly more calories than a Bud Light. It is also relatively low in alcohol content, with an ABV of 4.2%, compared to the average beer at 5%. Additionally, Guinness contains antioxidants that can improve heart health and reduce the risk of blood clots and heart attacks. It also has higher fibre content due to the use of unmalted barley, which can provide various health benefits such as reducing the risk of developing type 2 diabetes and improving immune function.

History of Guinness and iron

The history of Guinness and iron is a fascinating one, dating back to the late 18th century when Arthur Guinness laid the foundation for what became an international icon. Here is a detailed timeline:

The Late 1700s: The Birth of Guinness

Arthur Guinness, a visionary brewer, established the St. James's Gate Brewery in Dublin, Ireland, in 1759. On December 31, 1759, he signed a 9,000-year lease for the unused brewery at the age of 34, marking the beginning of the Guinness journey. Initially, Guinness brewed ales, and it wasn't until 1778 that he started selling the dark beer porter.

1840s: The Introduction of "Stout"

The first Guinness beers to use the term "stout" were Single Stout and Double Stout in the 1840s. Over time, the meaning of "stout" shifted from referring to the strength of a beer to describing its body and colour.

1920s: "Guinness is Good for You"

In the 1920s, Guinness began marketing its product as a health tonic. The campaign was based on claims made by consumers that drinking Guinness helped them fight fatigue, lack of sleep, and general weakness. The company promoted the beer as a tonic, even reaching out to medical professionals. The belief that Guinness was rich in iron led doctors to prescribe it to patients following operations and to pregnant women. This medical endorsement strengthened the campaign, and it remained central to the Guinness brand for the next 40 years.

1930s: Guinness and Iron in Hospitals

In the 1930s, the perception of Guinness as an iron-rich beverage had taken hold. In hospitals in Ireland, new mothers were given a bottle of Guinness daily to support milk production. The belief was that beer stimulated lactation, and Guinness was thought to be particularly effective.

2003: Guinness and Antioxidants

In 2003, a study found that stouts like Guinness could have benefits in reducing the deposit of harmful cholesterol on artery walls due to their higher levels of antioxidants compared to lagers. However, Diageo, the company that manufactures Guinness, stated that they do not make any medical claims for their drinks.

2021: Re-evaluating the Health Claims

In 2021, Lisa Drayer, a nutritionist and author, re-evaluated the historical health claims of Guinness. She concluded that while Guinness does contain some iron, the amounts are minimal. Drayer also emphasised that while moderate alcohol consumption may have some health benefits, these should always be weighed against the risks, especially during pregnancy.

Recommended daily iron intake

The recommended daily iron intake for men is 8.7mg, while women need 14.8mg. A pint of Guinness contains approximately 0.3mg of iron, which is about 3% of the recommended daily intake for adults.

While Guinness does contain iron, it is not significant enough to be of any health benefit. There are much healthier ways to boost iron levels, such as eating leafy green vegetables, beans, nuts, and red meat.

It's important to note that while Guinness may have some nutritional benefits, it is still an alcoholic beverage and consuming too much can have negative health effects. Heavy drinking and binge drinking are associated with health problems, including liver disease, pancreatitis, and high blood pressure.

Therefore, while Guinness may have a higher iron content compared to other beers, it should not be relied upon as a significant source of iron in one's diet. A balanced diet that includes a variety of iron-rich foods is the best way to ensure adequate iron intake.

Frequently asked questions