Sugar In Beer: Added After Fermentation?

The addition of sugar to beer is a common practice, especially in Belgian and British beers, and can be done at various stages of the brewing process. While sugar is typically added before or during fermentation, some brewers choose to add it after fermentation to increase sweetness, flavour, or body. However, it's important to note that adding sugar after fermentation can have unintended effects on the alcohol content and gravity of the beer.

Sugar is usually added during fermentation to increase alcohol content

Yeast converts all starches and sugars to alcohol and carbon dioxide, which is why beer is alcoholic and carbonated. However, not all sugars are created equally. The easiest sugar for yeast to convert is dextrose, while barley contains glucose and fructose, which are complex carbohydrates that yeast takes longer to break down and convert. The malting process creates a different kind of sugar, another complex carbohydrate called maltose. Thus, once the barley, wheat, or oat has been malted, it is then mashed into water, boiled, and steeped. During this hours-long process, all the malted sugars are released into the liquid, and now you have wort, or grain sugar water.

Now, to make beer, you add the yeast. The yeast gets to work on this highly activated sugar water and converts all the sugars into alcohol and carbon dioxide, also adding something called "gravity" to what will become beer. Gravity refers to the total volume of dissolved solids in a liquid, in this case, those solids are sugars. The gravity of a beer will tell you how many sugars from those grains were dissolved/converted by the yeast.

If you add sugar to beer before or during fermentation, you will only add more alcohol and gravity to your beer. Your ABV will likely shoot up, especially as most people add corn syrup, which is pure dextrose, the easiest sugar for yeast to convert. One of the possible side effects is that you will simply end up with a runny, high-alcohol beer. Sometimes, when added correctly, you can add body and flavor to your beer with a bit of corn syrup. However, if you add too much sugar, the yeast gets overwhelmed and dies off, leaving you with a sickly sweet drink.

There are two common reasons you might use sugar additions in a homebrew recipe. Either it was planned in advance for a particular recipe, or you are using it as a stopgap measure to recover from a poor gravity reading in an all-grain recipe. Adding simple sugar (corn sugar ferments out the cleanest) is a quick way to get those gravity-read sugars up closer to where you want them to be. On average, you will see about a 10-point rise in gravity readings for every pound of corn sugar you add, or roughly 1% in alcohol in a 5-gallon batch.

The second, and more legitimate reason for using sugar in a homebrew recipe is when a recipe calls for it. In this case, it is the particular flavor that is being sought, and this will determine how much or what type of sugar is called for. While corn sugar can be used this way, more robust sugars can leave behind desirable unfermentable sugars and flavor profiles, creating a unique character in the beer. Examples of this include brown sugar, sugar in the raw, Belgian candi sugars and syrups, and honey.

While it's safe to add sugars at any time in the process, adding them late can be very beneficial. First, yeast can get lazy if offered simple sugars upfront, and stall out early or ferment slower than normal once they have to convert more complex sugars. To prevent this, add the sugar after a few days of primary fermentation. Next, if you're adding sugars with a lot of flavor and aroma, the initial portion of primary fermentation can send a lot of desirable aromas out of the beer. Adding them after this vigorous portion of fermentation helps keep them in the beer, but still allows the yeast to ferment them out.

Sugar can be added to beer after fermentation, but it may increase alcohol content

Sugar is an essential ingredient in beer, but this usually refers to the natural grain sugars derived from barley, wheat, or oats. During the fermentation process, yeast converts these sugars, as well as starches, into alcohol and carbon dioxide. However, it is possible to add extra sugar to beer before, during, or after fermentation.

If you add sugar to beer before or during fermentation, you will likely increase the alcohol content and gravity of the beer. This is because yeast will convert the additional sugar into alcohol. Adding sugar during fermentation can also help prevent a stalled fermentation. However, adding too much sugar can overwhelm the yeast, leading to a sickly sweet drink.

Adding sugar after fermentation can also increase the alcohol content if there is still active yeast present in the beer. While the yeast may be mostly skimmed off or tired, it can still convert some of the added sugar. Therefore, it is challenging to guarantee that the sugar will only serve the purpose of sweetening the beer.

To sweeten beer without increasing the alcohol content, alternative sweeteners such as Xylitol or Stevia can be used. These non-fermentable sweeteners do not contain glucose or fructose and will not be converted into alcohol by yeast. However, they can add sweetness and change the flavor of the beer. It is recommended to add these sweeteners after fermentation and in small amounts to avoid altering other factors such as body, texture, mouthfeel, flavor, and aroma.

When adding sugar to beer, sanitation and oxidation are important factors to consider. Sugar should be sanitized by boiling, pasteurizing, or soaking in a high-alcohol environment to prevent spoilage from microorganisms. Additionally, adding ingredients to the fermenter after fermentation can introduce oxygen into the beer, so a gentle approach is recommended.

Sugar additions can be planned or used as a stopgap to fix a problematic brew

Sugar additions to beer can be planned or used as a stopgap to fix a problematic brew. While it is not common to add sugar to beer, it can be done before, during, or after fermentation.

Planned Sugar Additions

Sugar additions can be planned in advance for a particular recipe. For example, in IPAs, sugar is added to thin out the beer and achieve a desired gravity. Belgian ales also often call for more complex sugar additions, such as Belgian Candi sugar, to add new and interesting flavor profiles. Other sugars that can be used in planned additions include brown sugar, honey, and Sugar In the Raw.

Stopgap Measure

Sugar additions can also be used to fix a problematic brew. If the mashing process fails and the gravity reading is lower than desired, adding simple sugar is a quick way to increase the gravity readings. For every pound of corn sugar added, there will be an average increase of about 10 points in gravity readings, or roughly 1% in alcohol in a 5-gallon batch. However, it is important to be careful with these additions, as too much sugar can thin out the beer, adding alcohol but no real flavor or body, and potentially resulting in a substandard product with cider-like characteristics.

Timing of Sugar Additions

The timing of sugar additions is important. Yeast can get "lazy" if offered simple sugars upfront, so it is recommended to add sugar after a few days of primary fermentation. Additionally, if sugars with a lot of flavor and aroma are being used, adding them after the initial vigorous portion of fermentation helps to retain those desirable aromas in the beer.

Sanitation and Oxidation

When adding sugar or any other ingredient to the fermenter, it is important to consider sanitation and oxidation. While alcohol is lethally toxic to the vast majority of microorganisms, certain organisms such as Pediococcus, Lactobacillus, and wild yeast can survive and multiply. Therefore, a sanitation step may be necessary, such as boiling, pasteurizing, or soaking in a high-alcohol environment. It is also important to minimize oxidation by gently adding ingredients and avoiding dumping additions directly into the beer.

Adding sugar to beer can thin it out and throw it out of balance

Sugar is often added to beer during the fermentation process to increase its alcohol content. This is known as "adding sugar to the fermentor". However, if too much sugar is added, it can overwhelm the yeast and cause it to die off, resulting in a sickly sweet drink.

The type of sugar used can also affect the taste of the beer. For example, Belgian Candi sugar can darken the beer and add a caramel or honey flavor, while brown sugar can create a rum-like flavor.

It's important to carefully balance the amount and type of sugar added to beer to avoid throwing it out of balance. Too much sugar can increase the alcohol content to the point where the beer tastes more like cider than beer. Additionally, the sugar should be added during the fermentation process, as adding it afterwards may unintentionally increase the alcohol content and sweetness.

Overall, while adding sugar to beer can increase its alcohol content and change its flavor, it should be done carefully to avoid thinning out the beer and affecting its balance.

Belgian brewers are known to use sugar to achieve a dry and drinkable beer

Belgian brewers utilize an appreciable amount of simple sugar in their beer to achieve that signature drinkability, a culmination of several factors making for a beer that’s dry and pleasant to drink despite its high original gravity (OG). The concept is accepted by many as paramount to a well-executed Belgian beer. Sugar, in all of its various forms, makes an appearance not only in high-gravity Belgian styles but in many other beers as well. For example, British brewers have a history of using it in their beer, and more recently, sugar has come to be viewed as a key ingredient in higher-OG IPAs.

Belgian Candi Syrup is an invert sugar, typically refined beet sugar, that is used to increase fermentability and ABV without increasing body. Color can also be manipulated with these syrups. Belgian-style beers also incorporate Belgian syrups and candi sugars to enhance their taste.

Many beer recipes call for the addition of simple sugars such as sucrose, or table sugar, to increase alcohol content and lighten the body of the beer. Sucrose is a disaccharide that gets broken down into glucose and fructose by the invertase enzyme during fermentation, which are then metabolized into alcohol and CO2. Yeast is quite good at consuming sucrose, and while smaller amounts can be added to boiling wort in the kettle, too much can inhibit the fermentation of maltose, leading to poor attenuation. As such, some brewers have taken to adding sugar to the beer during active fermentation, and one common approach involves splitting the sugar up into multiple additions made over time to improve yeast performance.

There are several types of sugar that can be used in brewing. Corn sugar, for example, is employed for carbonation and can be metabolized by yeast, while lactose and maltodextrin are used to add mouthfeel and body. Honey is another exception to the rule that sugar should be added to the boil kettle, as boiling can drive off its delicate aromas. Thus, honey is typically added near the end of active fermentation.

Frequently asked questions